Agenda item 2 is consideration of another instrument that is subject to the negative procedure. The purpose of SSI 2007/483 is to amend the Natural Mineral Water, Spring Water and Bottled Drinking Water (Scotland) Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/435), which we considered on 31 October. The regulations contained a drafting error.We had arranged to take evidence from a representative of the Food Standards Agency Scotland, but he has had an accident, unfortunately—I trust that it did not have anything to do with our calling him before us—and he has been taken into hospital. Therefore, I welcome Patrick Layden QC TD from the Scottish Government's legal directorate, who has been given the task of speaking to us. I ask him to speak to the regulations and to then take questions from members.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Natural Mineral Water, Spring Water and Bottled Drinking Water (Scotland) (No 2) Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/483)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Christine Grahame SNP 3
- Patrick Layden Scottish Government Legal Directorate 2
The record
5 contributionsI regret the absence of Sandy McDougall of the Food Standards Agency Scotland. However, the interests of the FSAS and the Scottish Government Legal Directorate in the matter are the same, so I am grateful to the committee for allowing me to represent both organisations.First, I apologise unreservedly on behalf of the FSAS and the Scottish Government Legal Directorate for the typographical error that caused us to have to replace SSI 2007/435. I will explain how the error was made. The process of drafting this Scottish statutory instrument—which is, in essence, a revocation and re-enactment of previous SSIs—began some time ago, but was delayed last year because the regulations had to be referred to the European Commission under the technical standards and regulations directive. Work resumed this summer. The process involves the FSA in London preparing a draft which is then passed on to FSA Scotland and to my office. We look at such things critically, because everyone is concerned to get such things right. We do not draft our own regulations in Scotland because doing so would not be very user friendly: the people who use the regulations prefer to have the same regime north and south of the border. Therefore, even in cases in which we could do things differently, we try to do things the same. However, we take account of drafting and other alterations that have been made in London and we ask why things are being done in particular ways.In this case, the draftsperson in England was replaced after the summer, and the new person rearranged some of the material. We took account of that in our next draft, but that was when the typographical error came in—regulation 12 is where the error occurred. I have copies of the regulation with me if committee members would like to see it. A look will make it clear what happened: the word "not" was missed out in regulation 12(1)(b). In spite of the fact that lots of people looked at the regulation here, in Aberdeen and in London, the error was not picked up.I do not know whether committee members have noticed, as I have, that once you imagine that a word is there, your eye runs over it and you seem to see that it really is there. The point was not noticed before the instrument was laid on 20 September, and it was not noticed in either of the committees of this Parliament that considered the regulations. The point was finally noticed by a stakeholder who looked at a copy of the regulations and said, "What's all this?" As soon as we found out about it, we sent a submission to the minister and presented a new statutory instrument.The end result was that the new instrument came into force before the old instrument had come into force, so there was never a time when the law was wrong. However, we deeply regret having made the mistake, we deeply regret not having noticed it, and we deeply regret having wasted the committee's time with a replacement instrument. I apologise for that.
There are no questions from committee members, so I thank Patrick Layden. We are all somewhat culpable—certain committees here should perhaps have noticed the mistake along the way. What has happened just shows that it is often the person who has to implement a statutory instrument who notices problems and asks, "How on earth do I do this?"I thank Mr Layden for coming to explain what happened. We will all, including the Subordinate Legislation Committee, have to pay more attention in the future.
We all will. Thank you very much indeed.
Are committee members agreed that the committee does not wish to make any recommendation in relation to SSI 2007/483?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Nov 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Health and Sport Committee Wednesday 14 November 2007 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 5
- Budget Process 2008-09 Committee business · 181
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.