Item 4 on the agenda is our approach to developing a work programme. Members have substantial paperwork on the previous committee's legacy paper and the sports issue that is now tied into the committee's remit. Before I ask for brief comments, I refer members to page 10 of the briefing pack, which contains a breakdown of the percentages of time that the previous Health Committee spent on various activities, as a steer for what we can do. I cannot find page 10. I am told that it is in the green paper. Have all members located it? It shows the percentage of time that the Health Committee in the previous session spent on various things. I ask members to look at that, and also at the list of anticipated legislation on page 23.I open the meeting for members to discuss the work programme and briefly give their views. The legacy paper is substantial and it contains a lot of interesting stuff—too much, frankly.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Christine Grahame only · show everyone- Christine Grahame SNP 16
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 6
- Ross Finnie LD 3
- Malcolm Chisholm Lab 3
- Mary Scanlon Con 3
- Simon Watkins Clerk 3
- Ian McKee SNP 1
Christine Grahame’s contributions
16 contributionsIndeed. You anticipated what I was going to say. It would be useful to have a meeting before the recess for that very purpose. It would be useful to get the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing or the Minister for Public Health and the Minister for Communities and Sport so that we get a steer on the forthcoming legislation and issues. I agree with Ross Finnie—it would be useful to hear from the cabinet secretary so that we do not prepare a work programme only to be presented with legislation that we had not anticipated.
We could write to the minister and simply have a note to the committee, if members agree, although we are required to meet next week in any event. I am in your hands.
I can answer that. There are four negative instruments which, if we did not consider them, would come into force without our seeing them. That would not be good practice. I will read them all out—I ask members to bear with me. They are the Spreadable Fats (Marketing Standards) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/303), the Health Protection Agency (Scottish Health Functions) Amendment Order 2007 (SSI 2007/316), the National Health Service (Charges for Drugs and Appliances) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/317) and the Addition of Vitamins, Minerals and Other Substances (Scotland) Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/325).If we were to consider those and have a minister before us or consider a note from the minister at a short meeting, it would give us something substantive to do, but it would also give us a steer before the away day, to which I will come later. The last time that I did this job, the away day was when we really got down to discussing what the committee's agenda would be over the next period. The minister, who was Malcolm Chisholm, and the junior minister both came to speak to the Health Committee on its away day to manage the workload.We could have a very brief meeting next week—say from 11 o'clock to 12 o'clock—to deal with the subordinate legislation. Do we want ministers to appear before the committee or do we simply want to consider a note from them?
That is absolutely fine. We will write to the cabinet secretary.
I am sure that the cabinet secretary's staff will read the Official Report of the meeting—or will be listening even as we speak.
We have agreed what we are doing next week. I also advise members that, before 17 September, we have to consider an affirmative instrument on raising from 16 to 18 the age at which tobacco products can be purchased. That is a significant measure to be dealt with by subordinate legislation. Would members consider it appropriate to take evidence from the usual suspects—the relevant bodies, including the minister—before we debate the instrument?
Perhaps we could ask for some written evidence, but I do not know whether we would have it in time to make a decision on taking oral evidence. If some groups are satisfied, we would not need to speak to them but, if others have issues with the instrument, we could call them before us. What are members' views?
We have to consider and take a view on the instrument before 17 September. I am advised that after we return from the summer recess, we will have just two meetings before that date.
So we will see whether anyone wants to make submissions before we take a view.
That is important. There might be enforcement issues as a result of the instrument. Although I do not know much about it, I take it that it will create a criminal offence. In addition to enforcement issues there will be evidential and corroborative issues. It is sometimes the little things that we miss that cause trouble later. We will ask for written submissions and we will take a view—
Are there any others? Did the Scottish Youth Parliament send in a submission?
Let us talk about the away day. I hasten to add for the record that it will not be fun and parlour games; it will be a work day. I assume that members have fixed their holidays. Suggested dates are 28 and 29 August, which will be just before we come back, so I anticipate that most members will be available at that time. I ask members to check their diaries before we convene next.I ask you to give the clerks lists of any issues that you want us to consider at the away day so that briefing papers and an agenda can be prepared. We will hear evidence from the minister next week, which will give us something of a steer; then we will hear ideas from members. I hope that we will pick up issues from the legacy paper, in which there are some excellent suggestions. The clerks will issue a note of some suggestions for the away day for your comments after today's meeting. We will have those suggestions before our next meeting. Are members content with that?Members indicated agreement.
I ask members to consider a paper that suggests options for places where we might have our away day. I ask for your answers and any other suggestions that you might have. However, bear it in mind that we have finite resources and that the heavy hand of freedom of information legislation is on our shoulders whenever we breathe. That is pretty much it, I think.
I note the remarks in the legacy paper—they would be corroborated by many other committees—about the budget process not always being satisfactory for committees. We note your comments too.
Yes. When I chaired a previous Health Committee, we had a budget adviser who gave us difficult questions to ask the ministers and explained to us what lines of figures really meant. That was very useful. I notice that the previous Health Committee made considerable use of advisers, which is a worthy pursuit. We can put
consideration of the principle of appointing a budget adviser on next week's agenda and talk about the details later.That concludes the meeting. The date and time of our next meeting is Wednesday 27 June at 10:15. Thank you for being gentle with me at this first meeting.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Jun 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Health and Sport Committee Wednesday 20 June 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 7
- Convener Procedure · 8
- Deputy Convener Procedure · 5
- Work Programme Procedure · 36
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.