Thanks very much for the opportunity to be here and talk to this point. Hydrocarbons have been the backbone of UK industry for a long time now. The reason why the industrial clusters are where they are is that, historically, they have been where the oil and gas would come onshore—the chemical industry would then turn that into the basic raw materials that go into our manufacturing industries in general. The chemical industry sits at the heart of our manufacturing supply chains and it is critical to a modern manufacturing economy. Thanks very much for bringing that to the attention of the committee.
On the on-going importance of carbon, we need to get to a world that is net zero, and that requires the eventual circulation of the carbon that we have already extracted throughout the economy. We have carbon in an economic pool, an atmospheric pool and a biological pool. We need to be pulling on all of those resources to start to displace the carbon that we have historically been pulling from fossil fuel resources. It will not happen straight away, and in fact we are quite a long way from that position. That is because if we are pulling carbon to use in products from sources other than fossil fuels, we are having to do all the work that geology has done to get to a raw material that is usable to create the kind of advanced materials, pharmaceuticals and chemicals that we use every day in our modern lives. That is obviously a very energy-intensive process. Planet Earth took millions of years of high pressure and high heat to get to the incredible material—crude oil—that we have been using. We will have to do the same thing. We will have to reach high temperatures and high pressures. That is energy intensive, and we will have to do it with electricity.
The industry is looking at three main sources for carbon in the future. There is bio-based carbon. Any waste biomaterial from forestry and farming—anything that cannot otherwise be used—we can turn into valuable product, adding value to the economy. Another source is recycling, as you correctly mentioned. Even the stuff that cannot be mechanically recycled can be captured by our industry and chemically recycled into Tacoil, which is similar to crude oil, that can be used again for things like chemical production or even sustainable aviation fuel production.
The third source is captured carbon. One of the side benefits of putting carbon capture infrastructure in the clusters—we are waiting for funding to come to the Scottish cluster and we hope that that will happen soon—alongside hydrogen infrastructure is that we can take the captured carbon molecules and combine them with hydrogen to make hydrocarbon molecules that can be used for the chemical products that we currently make with fossil fuels.
All of this stuff is energy intensive and we are already in a position where the industry is uncompetitive because there are other locations with cheaper energy costs and cheaper raw material costs. We are already uncompetitive, and to make the transition we are facing increased energy use, which at the moment would make us fall flat on our faces. Without action to drive down the electricity price and, in the short to medium term, drive down the gas price, the industry remains at risk. It is critical that we get the energy price situation right. We were pleased to see mention of that in the industrial strategy and the Scottish climate change plan. We note your point that there is a very small section on reducing the electricity price, but I think you make it clear that a lot of this is reliant on national policy action, which is key. Your pressure on Westminster in that area is really useful and we thank you for that.
I will pick up the electricity points. You mentioned that high-heat processes often do not have off-the-shelf technology that can be deployed using electricity. That is the case in our sector for high-heat processes like cracking. There is ethylene production in Grangemouth that relies on high-heat cracking. There is not an off-the-shelf technology, as there is in the steel sector with electric arc furnaces, for the cracking of ethane into ethylene. There are various conglomerations of chemical companies working towards that, but they are still pilot scale. There is nothing that you can buy that you can plug in and play. If you could buy it, plug it in and play it, you would not do it here because the electricity price is too high. In the interim, it is fundamental that the Acorn cluster gets the funding to deploy the hydrogen network so that we can start putting hydrogen into the high-heat processes in Grangemouth and start building out some of the projects that were identified in project willow.
On the electricity price in general, it is not just about the electricity price versus the gas price here. Global firms are looking around the world for where they invest. We can have the cleanest electricity here, but if it is not competitively priced they will invest in electricity-based chemical production elsewhere. They are looking for competitively priced electricity to underpin the manufacturing. You have to look at the price versus gas in the UK, but also versus electricity elsewhere.
What is keeping the cost high? It is everything that everyone has already said, but it is also the policy cost. No one has mentioned that yet. We have subsidies for the deployment of renewables in the UK that are currently paid for on the electricity bill. There is support for some, and there is more support coming for some, to remove that policy cost from the electricity bill, but more is needed—that support is needed for more firms. There is also—