Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Official Statistics (Scotland) Amendment Order 2026 [Draft]

Wednesday 7 January 2026 Education, Children and Young People Committee About 09:30–09:45 Subordinate legislation 34 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

34 contributions
Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Good morning, and welcome to the first meeting in 2026 of the Education, Children and Young People Committee.

The first item on our agenda is consideration of subordinate legislation that is subject to the affirmative procedure. The committee will take evidence from the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills and her Scottish Government officials on two draft instruments, and the cabinet secretary will then move the motions to approve the instruments.

I welcome Jenny Gilruth, the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills, and her officials Jaxon Parish, who works on Qualifications Scotland policy in the education reform directorate, and Judith Brown, who is a solicitor in the legal directorate.

I invite the cabinet secretary to make an opening statement on the instruments.

Jenny Gilruth SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Happy new year to you, convener, and to committee members.

Thank you for inviting me to discuss the draft Official Statistics (Scotland) Amendment Order 2026 and the draft Education (Scotland) Act 2025 (Consequential Provisions) Regulations 2026. The two instruments are being considered together as they are both, in effect, required as a consequence of implementing the Education (Scotland) Act 2025. The instruments, alongside a wider package of secondary legislation, will ensure that Qualifications Scotland and the chief inspector for education in Scotland can take on the relevant functions, duties and responsibilities of the Scottish Qualifications Authority and of His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Education.

The Official Statistics (Scotland) Amendment Order 2026, if approved, will make changes to the Official Statistics (Scotland) Order 2008. The 2008 order provides that

“Wholly Scottish devolved statistics produced ... by the persons listed in the Schedule are specified as official statistics for the purposes of ... the Statistics and Registration Service Act 2007.”

Listed persons are bound by the code of practice for official statistics and how they are published. Put simply, in the schedule to the 2008 order, the instrument will replace the SQA with Qualifications Scotland as a producer of official statistics.

The Education (Scotland) Act 2025 (Consequential Provisions) Regulations 2026, if approved, will update the Budget (Scotland) Act 2025, as well as provisions in legislation that were inserted by the recent Scottish Languages Act 2025. For the budget act updates, the instrument will add references to Qualifications Scotland and to the office of His Majesty’s chief inspector of education in Scotland as regards the education and skills portfolio. The Scottish statutory instrument will ensure that they can be funded by the Scottish ministers during this budget year. For the provisions made in the Scottish Languages Act 2025, the SSI will replace all references to the SQA and to HM inspector of schools with references to Qualifications Scotland and to the chief inspector, ensuring that the recently agreed provisions in the Scottish Languages Act 2025 will work, or continue working, as originally intended.

I commend the order to the committee and am happy to answer any questions.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

The cabinet secretary will recall that, during the bill process, we discussed changes to quality assurance, as well as the accreditation function and the fact that separate reviews of both were under way. Will you update us on how those reviews are progressing?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

In relation to accreditation, as far as I am aware, that is being taken forward by Qualifications Scotland. I met Shirley Rogers recently, towards the end of last year, and will meet her again next week along with Nick Page, the new chief executive. I would be more than happy to write to the committee with more detail in relation to accreditation following my meeting with Shirley Rogers and Nick Page, because we discussed that issue at length with the committee during stage 2 amendments and in the chamber during stage 3.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I understand that those are also being taken forward. Jaxon Parish might want to speak about the work that officials have been supporting.

Jaxon Parish Scottish Government
link

There has been work to develop what the national quality assurance review will cover; that is being done with colleagues at Qualifications Scotland. As per the legislation, we are looking to appoint an independent adviser to undertake that review; that must be done within three months of the provision coming into force, which will happen in the next month or so.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

I will make the obvious point that a compromise was reached during the bill process, when we thought that a pragmatic and reasonable way to progress would be to have a review so that everything could be considered in the round. There was quite a lot of confusion about exactly what counted as accreditation and where the quality assurance functions would come in. Many of us took the strong view that, ultimately, everything should be accredited and should be in a separate body, and I hope that that will all be considered as part of the review. I have put that marker down to repeat the point from before.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Yes, that is very much the intention. We discussed that matter of accreditation with the committee, along with the fact that a number of qualifications—not least national qualifications that are often delivered in schools—are not accredited at present. I reassure Willie Rennie that that issue is being taken forward by Qualifications Scotland. However, I will raise those matters again with Shirley Rogers and Nick Page when I meet them in the coming days, and I commit to writing to the committee with further details following that meeting, to provide reassurance on those points. They were heard very clearly by me at the time and were a key component of the bill as it was passed.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Since we are speaking about the SQA and your on-going discussions with it, where are you now, months and years on from the 2024 higher history exam results? Does that issue still concern you? In a sit-down interview with The Herald, the new chief executive, Nick Page, said that he still had concerns about those results. What is your position, as cabinet secretary, in relation to that cohort of students, their teachers and their parents and carers, who have concerns about those results?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Concerns were raised at the time in relation to the 2024 higher history qualification. I am mindful of the fact that we are now into 2026. There was consideration of the issue and an investigation was carried out by the SQA that was then peer reviewed independently by Qualifications Wales. The advice that I was provided with at the time was that no further action could be taken and that the detail of the issue had been fully considered.

I am cognisant of the views of the new chief executive, which were published in The Herald last summer. I have discussed the issue with Mr Page, and we will continue to engage with the SQA to that end. However, to my mind, no further evidence on the issue has been put forward.

We discussed the issue at length, convener, and I think that you have led quite a lot of the interest in that, politically, which I recognise and have a level of respect for.

If there are other higher history teachers who have concerns, I put on the record that they should get in touch with Qualifications Scotland directly. I know that, on the back of the review that was carried out, Qualifications Scotland has undertaken a number of implementation events in relation to marking, setting the national standard and providing support to markers.

Again, I want to provide reassurance that I acknowledge that there needs to be constant dialogue with the profession. To my mind, one of the lessons that we should learn from qualifications reform is that we have to listen to the teaching profession better. It was always my experience, as a teacher and as an SQA marker, that there was a bit of a disconnect between the profession and the role of the SQA. That has to change in relation to Qualifications Scotland, and that work is being undertaken.

I recognise the committee’s interest in the point that you have raised, and I will continue to engage with Qualifications Scotland’s chief executive and chair on the substantive issues to ensure that there is a consistent approach and that we provide reassurance to children and young people and to parents and carers in relation to the national standards.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

You mentioned that you spoke to Mr Page after his interview. Was that to criticise him for speaking in that way, was it to ask for more information or was it to agree with him?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I think that we had a routine engagement to catch up on a number of different areas, including the points that Mr Rennie raised this morning in relation to accreditation. I do not recall the discussion taking place in the kind of forum that you suggest. It would not be usual for me to seek a meeting with the chief executive on the back of a press interview. We have regular catch-ups. We had a regular catch-up on those issues, and we discussed them in the round.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I have raised the issue before, and I asked a question on it in the chamber. However, we have more opportunity for discussion in the committee when you bring forward pieces of subordinate legislation. The issue in 2024 was, in my view, very significant, but then we had the scenario last year in which there were not just slight gains in higher history but results that went above where they were the year before. What did you think when you saw that?

When I spoke to Shirley Rogers and the new chief executive, just after he was appointed but before the results came out, they thought that we might get somewhere that was a halfway house between that low level in 2024 and the level in previous years. However, what happened was that students got results that were above what they had been before. There was a huge increase. That must have been concerning to you.

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

It is always difficult to make generalisations about cohorts. If you teach cohorts of young people, you see attainment fluctuate from year to year. The exam results depend on the class, the individual pupils and, ultimately, their performance on the day. It is difficult to have that read-across and to predict how a cohort will perform.

It is fair to say that, in this year’s exam results, we saw a dramatic improvement in attainment in history and across the board. That is to be welcomed. If there were issues in relation to the subject qualification itself, the SQA would have considered that in relation to the pass mark. I would be more than happy to come back to the committee on that, but, from my memory—I do not have the detail in front of me today, because it is not directly relevant to the SSIs that we are discussing—I do not think that changes were made in relation to the overall pass mark last year. I will clarify that point with my officials after the committee meeting, but, to my mind, that would suggest that there were no issues.

Of course, I always meet the SQA in advance of the qualifications results day, and we spend a lot of time going through the results and looking at individual subjects. In 2025, we spent a bit of time going through the higher history course qualification results, for exactly the reasons that you mention, convener, and no concerns were raised by the SQA at that time in relation to the approaches that were taken.

We have seen an improvement in attainment, which is to be welcomed. I accept the points that you have made today, but all that I would say is that no information from the SQA has been shared on that issue. However, if higher history teachers or markers have any concerns, I am always happy to hear from them, and I would encourage them to engage directly with Qualifications Scotland.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Page 4 of the Scottish Government policy note notes that Scottish ministers have stated that the regulations are

“compatible with the UNCRC requirements”.

In that case, why are your department and your Government still bringing forward legislation that is not compatible with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

Forgive me, convener, but which legislation would that be?

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am thinking of the Children (Care, Care Experience and Services Planning) (Scotland) Bill, which Natalie Don-Innes brought forward. I know that you recused yourself from discussion of the Promise, but you will be aware of discussions that have been held on the issue in Cabinet. One of the big issues that came out of our consideration of that piece of legislation was that stakeholder after stakeholder was concerned about the fact that the way in which the bill had been drafted by the education department—similarly to what other departments in the Scottish Government have done—meant that elements of it were not compatible with the UNCRC. Given that it is important for you to state that SSIs such as those before us are compatible, why is new legislation that your department and your Government are bringing forward not compatible?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

You alluded to Cabinet conversations, convener, and I have to again put on the record, as you have already noted, the fact that I am recused from discussions concerning the Promise because my wife sits on the Promise oversight board. I am not privy to those conversations and I do not sit at the Cabinet table for discussions that pertain to the Promise.

My general comment—I will defer to Judith Brown on this—is that ministers have to ensure that all legislation that we introduce is compliant with the UNCRC. I can give you only a general view on that, because I cannot give specifics on the Promise bill for the reasons that I have set out. Judith Brown might want to say more in terms of the UNCRC and our engagement in relation to that piece of legislation.

Judith Brown Scottish Government
link

It is correct to say that all legislation requires to be compatible with the UNCRC. I am not sure that there is anything more that I can say in relation to the Promise bill specifically.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I am not asking about the Promise bill—indeed, the relevant minister will appear before our committee shortly.

Ms Brown, are solicitors in the Scottish Government aware that almost every witness we spoke to on that specific bill reiterated concerns that they had expressed about bills from other departments of the Scottish Government, which were that legislation is being introduced that might have to be changed at stage 2 because, when it is presented by the Government, it is not compliant with UNCRC? I note that we have before us a quite simple and straightforward SSI that ministers tell us in their policy note is compatible with the UNCRC.

Judith Brown Scottish Government
link

For all SSIs, we are required to produce an impact assessment in relation to the UNCRC and to be satisfied that they are compliant. That is what has been done for these two SSIs. I am afraid that I am not sighted on the Promise bill.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I will move the discussion away from the Promise bill, because I understand the complexities that the cabinet secretary is, quite rightly, faced with in that regard. However, we heard the same concerns in relation to—I think—the Housing (Scotland) Bill and other pieces of legislation. Surely solicitors in the Scottish Government, cabinet secretaries and ministers must be hearing the same evidence that this committee and other committees are hearing, which is that bills are being introduced that—as witnesses tell us—are not compatible with the UNCRC. Is every witness from those different spheres wrong and the Government right? Is the Government taking on board those concerns? If so, what is it doing about them?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

The Government always listens to concerns that are raised by stakeholders. The general point is that ministers are not able to take forward bills that are not compliant with the UNCRC in general terms. I am sure that, in relation to the specifics of the Promise bill, the minister will be listening to and engaging with stakeholders. I know that she will appear before the committee following my evidence session today, so you might want to pursue those matters with her directly, given my recusal from discussion of that bill overall.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Will officials come back to us on that? You will have seen that we mentioned the issue in our stage 1 report on the Education (Scotland) Bill. It has been highlighted in other committees. We are coming to a period when a lot of legislation will come through the Parliament. If we, as Opposition MSPs, have to keep amending legislation, it would surely be better if it could be changed before it is even introduced. Could we get a commitment that the Government will look at the legal aspects of the concerns around UNCRC compatibility?

09:45

I stress the point that the issue is about not just one bill that is being discussed at this committee; witnesses have said that they made similar points about other bills in other committees earlier in the process. Given your policy note, I felt that I had an opportunity to raise the issue today, and I will also do so with the minister. As I said, will officials come back to us on that?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

We can take the general point away. A couple of issues have come up today that I will write to the committee about. If we can loop the point into our response, I am more than happy to reassure you about our approach.

Willie Rennie LD North East Fife
link

On a different subject, one of the criticisms of the old SQA was that it was slow to update national qualifications. Ken Muir referred to it as sometimes intransigent and said that it did not engage with the teaching community. What assurance have you had from the Qualifications Scotland leadership that it will be swifter at developing and updating new qualifications, particularly to ensure that it is aligned with the curriculum for excellence?

Jenny Gilruth SNP Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link

I agree with Professor Muir’s observations. Some of the engagement with the profession was pretty challenging, which led to the challenges that were experienced during the pandemic. The backdrop is that those challenges did not happen in a silo. We should be mindful of the issues with engagement with the qualifications body that many teachers experienced before the pandemic.

The wider point is about the work on the curriculum improvement cycle, which is being led by the teaching profession in relation to Education Scotland. We must not divorce that from the overall approach to qualifications. In the summer recess, I attended a helpful session in Glasgow with a number of teachers who have been engaged in leading that work and leading qualifications reform.

To answer Mr Rennie’s point, the curriculum improvement cycle is the approach that we will take as a Government to ensure that our qualifications system keeps up to date. In recent years, the system has not been at the cutting edge when it comes to ensuring that our qualifications are updated and that we respond to societal changes accordingly. The curriculum improvement cycle is the way in which we will update and change our qualifications. I made that commitment in the chamber a number of years ago, and it came directly from a recommendation that we had received from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development on the exact point that Mr Rennie has raised. The curriculum improvement cycle work is being led by the teaching profession, and it will inform the qualifications update that Education Scotland is leading.

I also note that we have appointed a secondary headteacher in the schools unit at Qualifications Scotland. To my mind, that approach will improve engagement with the teaching profession. We now have in place a bespoke approach to engagement with schools that is being led by a secondary headteacher. That is really important because it sends a clear message to the teaching profession, particularly the secondary teaching profession, that we know that engagement in the past was not as it should have been and that engagement and how it is led will improve. The committee might want to engage directly with the schools unit on that engagement and on how it is currently working with the profession in practice.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There are no further questions from members, so I invite the cabinet secretary to move motion S6M-19851.

Motion moved,

That the Education, Children and Young People Committee recommends that the Education (Scotland) Act 2025 (Consequential Provisions) Regulations 2026 draft be approved.—Jenny Gilruth

Motion agreed to.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The committee must now produce its report on the draft instrument. Is the committee content to delegate to me as convener the responsibility to agree the report on behalf of the committee?

Members indicated agreement.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Again, there are no further questions from members, so I invite the cabinet secretary to move motion S6M-19852.

Motion moved,

That the Education, Children and Young People Committee recommends that the Official Statistics (Scotland) Amendment Order 2026 draft be approved.—Jenny Gilruth

Motion agreed to.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The committee must now produce its report on the draft instrument. Is the committee content to delegate to me as convener the responsibility to agree the report on behalf of the committee?

Members indicated agreement.

Douglas Ross Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Cabinet secretary, I thank you and your officials for your attendance this morning. Before we move to our next item, I will briefly suspend the meeting to allow for a change of witnesses.

09:49 Meeting suspended.

09:52 On resuming—

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on these motions that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 34
  2. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 70

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.