The solution might be in front of us. In Scotland, as in England and Wales, we say that we have a leaky pipeline of skills. Annually, we have around 19,000 young people studying construction within the further education sector in Scotland, full time and part time. We also have roughly 6,000 modern apprenticeship starts annually. We estimate that of those 19,000 learners, perhaps 30 per cent get employment within the sector and, within the modern apprenticeship programme, we lose 30 per cent of our apprentices within the first 12 to 18 months. Therefore, about 1,800 young people leave the sector.
The leaky pipeline basically shows us that there is no shortage of young people wishing to enter the construction sector. All the research has shown that there are issues with how people are taught, and with linking them to employers who have the jobs available. With that in mind, the Scottish Government has set up a short-life working group, which we attend with a number of other organisations, such as the FE sector. It is a solution-based working group that is looking at the problem of how to get more FE learners into employment in the sector and how to retain more of the apprentices who leave and do not come back into the sector.
The numbers show a vast pipeline of throughput of skilled individuals with varying levels of qualifications; some are employed but most are not. How do we tap into that talent pool to address the issues that are coming down the track, not just in terms of economic and social policy and the wider construction sector and economic development, but the retrofit ambitions as well? We think that the numbers are there, but that there is a mismatch when it comes to what we are doing with those young people to bring them through and, with the right level of competency, hook them up with an employer. What we are talking about here is the level of competency that an employer within construction requires.
Construction is one of the few sectors in which most employers will probably say no if you ask whether they will employ an individual who has never been anywhere near construction before. Employers are looking for someone who has experience or who has touched on issues around the construction industry, which means they are looking for attitude and aptitude, rather than necessarily hand skills at that stage. However, we know why so many young people leave their apprenticeship: it is because we have an informal recruitment process. We call it a tap on the shoulder, basically. We will employ so and so because we know them, even if they have no experience whatsoever of being involved in the sector. Therefore, it is hardly surprising that, after six months, when they are on a building site or carrying out repairs and maintenance, or in the first year, which is mainly at college, they are turned off and decide that it is not for them and to go and do something else.
On the whole career aspect that you asked about, it is not necessarily about increasing the numbers who want to enter the profession but about increasing retention and keeping people within the sector, providing them with basic skills and then, once they are employed, upskilling them to deal with many of the retrofit issues and trades that will be required. We do not think that the numbers that are required for retrofit and under the climate change plan are about new people. We think that this is about upskilling an existing workforce, which needs to be slightly bigger than it is at the present time.
A number of things have been identified, but we feel—certainly I feel, and the CITB feels—that with a more holistic approach to how young people learn, how we teach them and how we retain them, we would have the numbers. It is about finding solutions for those people and employers to address what we have in front of us.