Since the Paris agreement, we have emitted globally just over one third of a trillion tonnes of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. Therefore, the carbon budgets have reduced by that huge quantity since then.
As James Curran points out, we have an improved understanding of the science, including on the issues of aerosols and on some of the other feedbacks. When we now look at the carbon budgets that are available for global warming of 1.5°C and 2°C, they are smaller than we thought that they would be. They are smaller because we have squandered our opportunity by putting lots more emissions into the atmosphere.
We are now almost at 1.5°C. Globally, we could probably emit 130 billion tonnes of CO2. That is three years of current emissions. To stay at 1.5°C globally, we need to reduce emissions by between 20 and 25 per cent per annum. In other words, that is not achievable. For the much riskier 2°C, we could probably emit around 500 billion to 600 billion tonnes of CO2. That would require an 8 per cent reduction every year.
There is on-going failure at the global and national levels. There are no leaders on climate change. No nation is showing progress. When you add all that together, we are in a much more serious situation than we were than at Paris or at the time of the Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Act 2019.
This sounds harsh, but I slightly disagree with Mark Winskel in the way that he framed his response by saying that there was some positive news. We must remind ourselves that the climate does not care about renewables or efficiency. It cares only about CO2 and other greenhouse gas molecules. Unless we eliminate the use of fossil fuels and dramatically cut emissions from agriculture, the temperature will simply keep rising. Reducing the amount of fossil fuels still means that the temperature rises. We have to stop using them, and then, very slowly, the temperature will stabilise and start to come down.
All that we have done so far at the global level is reduce the size of the steps we are taking backwards, because it is a cumulative problem. A much more honest reflection is that we are not making progress; we are only going backwards. Even the small steps that we think are moving us forward are not—they are just smaller steps backward than they might otherwise be.
The other thing that has changed significantly is that we understand some of the impacts. Take the Atlantic meridional overturning circulation or AMOC. Changes to that could have dire implications for Europe, especially for Scotland. Scotland would be more in line with Labrador. In the winter, it would be more like -15°C. If you consider that in terms of the housing quality in Scotland, people would be dying in their houses.
If you go back around 10 years, people did not think that there was a high chance of AMOC—the gulf stream is part of that, which is the language more commonly used—reversing or stopping. Now, there is a significant risk of that occurring and there are no plans in Scotland, the United Kingdom or the rest of Europe to deal with what the implications of that would be.
On the legal side, we now have bodies such as the International Court of Justice giving their advice on 1.5°C. Without going into any details, I know that there are cases to take other countries to court for their production and on-going sales of fossil fuels.
We have a whole suite of things there. The science is basically telling us that we are going to hell in a handcart very quickly. Emissions are still increasing—they are not decreasing. Even in countries such as Scotland, the UK or the rest of continental Europe, we are just playing with emissions, which are dropping by the odd per cent or two every so often. We also have a legal framework that says that we must stick to 1.5°C, which we have virtually gone past.
I am sorry to say that, in 2025, there is no good news. There is less bad news, and we can polish that if we want to—or we can just stare directly at the challenge that we face and say, “What do we need to do to respond to a climate emergency?” The Scottish Parliament declared a climate emergency in 2019. The draft climate change plan before us is not an emergency plan. At the moment, Scotland, like every other country, is polishing failure.