PE2102, which was lodged by Anna-Cristina Seaver, calls on the Scottish Government to require anyone who is found guilty of rape or sexual assault to be registered as a sex offender. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to abolish the option of an absolute discharge in cases where the accused is found guilty of rape or sexual assault and to introduce a statutory minimum sentence for those offences, which includes the convicted person being registered as a sex offender.
We last considered the petition on 7 May 2025, when we agreed to write to the Scottish Sentencing Council, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice and Home Affairs and the Lord Advocate. The cabinet secretary’s response notes that sentencing judges will be aware that a consequence of an absolute discharge is that the offender will not be subject to notification requirements and that that is a factor that they will consider. The submission notes that courts have the option to admonish rather than absolutely discharge where they consider that no punishment is warranted, but the crime should be recorded and the offender should be made subject to notification requirements. The secretary also notes that the COPFS has the power to appeal against an absolute discharge if it considers that it is unduly lenient.
The Scottish Sentencing Council’s response highlights an instance where the Crown did appeal an absolute discharge. The Scottish Sentencing Council’s response highlights the development of sentencing guidelines for the courts on certain sexual offences, including rape and sexual assault. The draft guidelines make no provision for an absolute discharge as a disposal within the proposed sentencing ranges for either offence. Accordingly, any court that wished to impose one would be taking a decision not to follow a guideline and, under the relevant legislation, would be required to state its reasons for that decision.
The Lord Advocate’s response reiterates points that were made by the cabinet secretary and Scottish Sentencing Council. The submission also sets out details of relevant cases. I should note that people may find some details in the submission distressing.
Do members have any comments or suggestions for action?
11:00