I will start off. Neil Langhorn can talk you through the detail of the extent to which the draft plan matches up with what we said in our letter about what a good plan would look like, but I will start by giving you an overview.
The first thing to say is that, like Clare Wharmby, we believe that there are some good things about the draft plan. There are strong statements about the urgency of the need to tackle climate change, the economic benefits that flow from that, the need for an organised just transition and our international obligations on climate change. It is also good that the draft plan follows the recommended budgets that were set out by the Climate Change Committee, and it mostly follows its recommendations about pathways. In its 320 or so pages, there has clearly been a lot of effort to try to do better than what was done in the climate change plan update, in terms of the level of detail. However, as Clare Wharmby says, it is still missing the who, what and when, so we cannot quite disentangle that detail.
The frustration is that there are overall numbers for packages, which would suggest that, for individual policies, figures have been developed and have been added up to give the total that we are presented with for each package of six policies, but we are not being shown the individual numbers, timescales or costs. The information must be there, but we are not being given that level of data.
Another good thing about the draft plan is that it contains some high-level cost and benefit estimates that are really helpful. It clearly shows us that investment today will save us money in the future, because climate change is coming and we need to both adapt and change our economy. According to the study that is quoted in the plan, that investment will head off a £17 billion loss of gross domestic product in 2040. Of course, there is less cost information for individual policies, though. Overall, those figures suggest that climate change is the ultimate case for the use of preventative spend. We must spend today to get ourselves in shape for what is to come, otherwise we will face a very large bill in the future.
In the letter that we sent to you in March, one of the things we said right up front was:
“It is imperative that there is sufficient time for scrutiny of the next draft CCP and incorporation of feedback before its finalisation.”
I know that your committee was also concerned about the issue of how much time will be available. We do not seem to have learned the lesson from last time. In 2021, when the CCPU came before the Parliament, four committees worked hard on it, making 166 recommendations. I thought that that was a great example of the Parliament doing proper scrutiny on a piece of strategy. However, because there were only about 20 days between the end of the scrutiny period and the election, the final version that the Government published was the same as the draft—it basically ignored all 166 recommendations. It wrote a letter saying, essentially, “Well, we have thought about them, and they will be taken into account in the next CCP.” However, there is no mention of that in the draft plan. Perhaps lots of them have been taken into account, but, if so, that is not highlighted.
We are in the same situation now, in that we have about 20 days between the end of parliamentary scrutiny and the Parliament going into recess and then being dissolved for the election. The Government has said that it will produce the final version by the end of those 20 days, so there is very little time for it to read what you have said and actually do something meaningful about it. That is frustrating.
What can the Scottish Government do about that? We are in a difficult situation, which we cannot entirely fix, but I hope that the Government is reading all the submissions as they come in, watching sessions such as this one and revising as it goes, rather than waiting for you to produce the ultimate answer to what should happen. I hope that it is pre-empting some of what you will say and is producing another draft, so that, when it produces the final version before the election, it will have incorporated a lot of what people have been saying. However, even if that happens, that will still mean that there is a need for this committee, like your predecessor committee, to write a stiff letter to your successor committee saying that you have undertaken an important piece of work and that, because your recommendations might not have been fully dealt with, it is important that the successor committee and the whole Parliament consider scrutiny of the implementation of the climate change plan to be a key issue for the next session.