If it is okay, I want to come back slightly on a couple of things that David McColgan mentioned. As the industry lobbyist in the room, I never realised that I was so powerful.
The first thing that I would say is that the approach can be iterative. We support the regulations; indeed, there are similar regulations in other parts of the UK, which give us a baseline. That means that, by October next year, the three nations in Britain will all have the same approach. For retailers of scale and the majority of the retail industry—even smaller retailers—the supply chain will be similar, and we will now be working from that baseline. We can then look at the next thing.
We are not saying that we should never have regulation again; obviously, that is not reasonable. Public health issues have been raised, and they are real. The regulations will not deal with every public health issue, but they are a good starting point, and they are also something that we can do quickly. We are supportive of that, and we are happy to continue the discussion.
As for meal deals, I think that the Government’s proposals on meal deals were meant to be aimed at lunch-time volume, or multibuy, sandwich deals. That is one type of promotion. However, the measure was framed in such a way that it covered a whole gamut of things—everything from a volume promotion of things in the freezer area to a dessert deal or a barbecue deal. Some of those deals involve foods high in fat, salt and sugar, and some do not. One of our members went away and dug into the issue properly, but they stopped when they got to 3 million combinations of items. That does not mean that we cannot do this—it is just very complicated and complex.
If we had included meal deals, we would have needed a definition, as the term is not legally defined at the moment. That stuff all takes time, but that does not mean that we cannot do it. Indeed, I imagine—I hope—that Government officials are working on what some of that might look like. However, the “how” is quite difficult, even if you accept that it is a good idea.
Our members probably have different views on that—they have a very broad range of views. We probably do not have a coherent view; after all, some members would be commercially advantaged if such regulation came forward, because they do not offer such deals, or they offer them in a way that has less of an effect. However, some retailers would lose part of their business, because they do only a lunch-time meal deal.
There is a complexity to the issue that probably deserves examination. We have talked about secondary legislation not always being the appropriate approach, and this is probably a good example of an issue where you need quite a lot of input. However, I can speak only for the retail part, not the follow-on issue.
09:30
Secondly, the multibuy provisions cover pre-packaged food, not fresh food or food prepared at a certain point. That, too, will have an impact. It addresses one quite narrow area of the food environment—the easiest area—but there is, absolutely, a way in which it can push further.
Thirdly, on the scope of the regulations, they apply to shops with an area of more than 185m2—that is, 2,000 square feet—or those that have more than 50 employees. A chunk of businesses will therefore be unaffected. Some of them are responsible retailers and will probably have enacted similar things, just as there are lots of retailers that have not done BOGOF deals for years. However, some will not enact them. Some businesses based in the communities that probably have the most need for the regulations will be unaffected, because the Government and the Parliament have, broadly, taken a view that the onerous burden of implementation should not be applied to the smallest businesses.
However, not taking a level-playing-field approach will have a public health impact, too—that is a consideration that is perhaps not always made. Again, some businesses that are not retail businesses that sell food will have an impact on that environment; we represent some of them, too, so we are in there.
Finally, we think, philosophically speaking, that temporary price reductions are good. They encourage competition, including between brands and between retailers, and in our view, that keeps prices down. We think that keeping prices down for customers is good, and we think that competition between retailers keeps prices down across the market.
I want, finally, to say a little about that food environment. If you look at price—