link
To ask the First Minister what impact the chancellor’s autumn statement will have on Scotland. (S6F-04479)
Official Report · Chamber
First Minister’s Question Time
link
To ask the First Minister what impact the chancellor’s autumn statement will have on Scotland. (S6F-04479)
link
As I indicated a moment ago, yesterday’s budget will have financial consequences for the Scottish Government’s budget. I welcome the decision to remove the two-child limit, which the Scottish Government was already planning to mitigate in March next year.
There will, of course, be consequences for the public. Their energy bills will not be cut by the £300 that was proposed by the Labour Party. Energy bills will still be, on average, £340 a year higher than the Prime Minister promised that they would be.
link
Yesterday’s United Kingdom Government budget came after weeks of chaos, dithering and U-turns by the chancellor, amid an on-going cost of living crisis, the downgrading of UK economic growth every year until 2029 and public finances being in a worse state now than when Labour came to power.
Does the First Minister agree with the Scottish Chambers of Commerce that the budget’s net effect will be to further dial up pressure on businesses, risking our reputation as a magnet for global investment? Does he share my concern that, while thousands of Scottish oil and gas jobs are at risk from Labour’s tax policy after this budget, energy bills next April will still cost £340 a year more per household than the Prime Minister promised a year ago, while UK unemployment has risen by 282,000 on Labour’s watch?
link
On Mr Gibson’s last point about unemployment, that is now significantly lower in Scotland than it is in the rest of the United Kingdom. I welcome that indication of good performance in the Scottish economy. Indeed, that good economic performance in Scotland was recognised by both Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s in their assessments of Scotland’s credit rating.
In addition, the decision not to abolish the energy profits levy will have disastrous consequences in the north-east of Scotland, and the Labour Party will have to own those consequences—we will make sure that it does.
In relation to energy prices, individuals were promised a cut of £300 to their energy bills, but that is not happening under the Labour Government.
link
Rachel Reeves yesterday made the same mistake as John Swinney, with a “Benefits Street” budget that increased tax on workers, pensioners and savers. The Scottish benefits bill is set to soar to close to £10 billion by the end of this decade. How does John Swinney intend to pay for that?
link
The Scottish Government will set out its budget in January, which will, of course, following the pattern of all the budgets that we have set out, be a balanced budget. Because of all the years of balanced budgets under the Scottish National Party Government since 2007, Moody’s is able to say that Scotland benefits from “prudent financial management”, and Standard & Poor’s is able to say that Scotland benefits from “prudent financial planning”. I would have thought that those assessments from credit rating agencies—those independent voices that comment on economies around the world—would be of some solace and comfort to Mr Hoy and give him something to be cheerful about. Given that we have such strong financial planning, even Mr Hoy should be satisfied with our performance.
It would be churlish not to welcome the about-turn on the two-child benefit cap—it is better late than never. That, of course, benefits children and their families, but it also puts money into the local economy, because that money helps people to pay inflationary food and energy bills. It is a good thing all round.
link
Yes, and it also complements the work that the Scottish Government is doing on the Scottish child payment, for example. We are putting money directly into household finances, which enables families to spend locally, to have more control over their resources and to be better able to support their families. That is exactly the type of impact that will be felt in Christine Grahame’s constituency, as it will be felt in constituencies the length and breadth of Scotland.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.