We move on to item 3, and ask for a briefing from the Auditor General on the report "Financial overview of the NHS in Scotland 2007/08".
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Financial overview of the NHS in Scotland 2007/08”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Mr Black 15
- Nick Hex Audit Scotland 6
- Hugh Henry Lab 5
- Barbara Hurst 5
- Sandra White SNP 4
- Willie Coffey SNP 3
- Cathie Craigie Lab 3
- Nicol Stephen LD 3
- Murdo Fraser Con 2
- George Foulkes Lab 2
- Stuart McMillan SNP 1
The record
49 contributionsThank you, convener. If I may, I will just introduce the report. As the committee knows well, I bring a report each year to Parliament on the financial performance of the national health service in Scotland. In addition, every second year we prepare a report that looks at NHS performance in the round as well as at its finances. Last year, a wider performance audit overview looked at the finances and the performance.This year's report is more restricted and considers only financial performance, so I emphasise that it does not have the same level of detailed information as the one that we produced last year. I have suggested on several occasions in my reports and to the committee that the NHS in Scotland should consider preparing its own annual report on its performance. I am therefore delighted to report that, last month, the chief executive of NHS Scotland published for the first time an annual report on the NHS.The commentary on financial performance in my report is drawn mainly from the final reports of the auditors that we have in each of the 14 NHS boards, the nine special boards and the Scottish Government health directorates. It is also drawn from various other sources of information, such as our public performance reports.I will quickly run through the four parts of the report. Part 1 describes the financial performance of the NHS in 2007-08. I am pleased to tell the committee that the overall financial position was good. The NHS in Scotland spent £10.1 billion and ended the financial year with a £26 million underspend against its budget, of which £24 million was revenue and £2 million was capital. The boards and special boards generated a £76 million underspend, but that was offset by a planned overspend of about £50 million by the Scottish Government health directorates at the centre. All NHS bodies met their targets for the financial year, except Western Isles NHS Board, which failed to meet its revenue resource limit target—although for the first time in five years, the board generated an in-year surplus. As the committee is aware, I prepared a section 22 report on the board's financial position, which the committee discussed at its meeting on 29 October.As I have highlighted in previous years, a sign of good financial health for any NHS body is that it can meet its recurring expenditure—what we might call its day-to-day expenditure—from its recurring income in the year. I am pleased to report that this year, NHS bodies were generally less reliant on non-recurring funding, which is sometimes called one-off funding, to meet financial targets or to support their financial positions. In total, the underlying recurring deficit for NHS bodies reduced from more than £90 million last year to about £16 million this year.In recent years, there has been substantial capital investment in the health service in Scotland. Capital expenditure more than trebled in cash terms between 2003-04 and 2007-08, increasing from £132.5 million to £438.8 million last year. By 2010-11, the figure will reach not far short of £600 million, which is a substantial capital investment. The health service clearly must ensure that those capital projects deliver the intended benefits. We plan to produce a report early next year on how well the NHS manages its assets: that report will come to the committee.I made several other comments in the report about financial issues relating to the health service. I will draw the committee's attention to three in particular. First—as, I suspect, committee members are well aware—spending per head on the NHS has been higher in Scotland than it is in other parts of the United Kingdom. That trend continued in 2007-08.Secondly, the committee is well aware that, in recent years, the NHS has been working with partners such as local authorities to shift the balance of care from acute hospitals to more community-based provision. However, from the high-level numbers, the health service cannot yet demonstrate that resources are following the shift in the balance of care. It is important that the Scottish Government health directorates develop ways of estimating the costs that will allow them to provide that information in reports.Thirdly, on the important question of efficiency, the health directorates have reported that the NHS in Scotland met its overall efficient government initiative targets between 2005-06 and 2007-08. The service is reported to have achieved £610 million of savings against a combined target of £534 million.Part 2 of the report describes the cost pressures on the NHS. I guess that many of those pressures will be well known to the committee from my previous reports and your previous considerations, but it is important that I highlight them briefly.Pay modernisation continues to be a significant cost to the NHS. The agenda for change project is still not fully implemented, and the costs will not be fully known until the process has been completed.Equal pay claims, which I mentioned in my report last year and which are an important issue for the NHS, represent another cost pressure that has not yet been quantified. Again, I must report that the NHS is still not in a position to estimate the cost of those claims, which could represent a substantial commitment in the future.Other cost pressures that the NHS faced in 2007-08 are well known to the committee. They include the increasing costs of drugs, fuel and energy, the costs of service redesign initiatives and the costs of reducing waiting lists. Members will see from exhibit 9 in my report that the rate of increase of the costs of drugs has recently reduced.Part 3 of my report comments on health bodies' governance and management arrangements. For the most part, NHS bodies have sound governance arrangements, but the auditors at Orkney NHS Board and Western Isles NHS Board again raised governance and financial management arrangement issues, which I feel obliged to highlight.Auditors at five boards, including NHS Orkney and NHS Western Isles, also identified particular issues to do with the appointment and associated governance of senior staff. We attempted to summarise those issues in exhibit 12, which is on page 18 of the report.All NHS boards except NHS Orkney have community health partnerships in place. Some boards are reviewing or restructuring those partnerships. The Scottish Government recently announced that it plans to carry out a study of CHPs, starting in January 2009, which I welcome. Audit Scotland plans to undertake a review of CHPs, which will be critical to delivering the new balance of care in the future, but we will defer starting that study until the Scottish Government is well through its work.Finally, we as auditors took a tentative look at the NHS's financial outlook for 2008-09 and beyond. On the basis of the latest information that auditors in the individual boards supplied to us, all boards except NHS Western Isles predict that they will break even in 2008-09, despite an expectation of smaller funding increases than they have enjoyed in recent years and the demanding efficiency targets that have been set for the NHS. The boards expect to face cost pressures that are similar to those that I reported for 2007-08, but new pressures on budgets are also emerging, including the cost of fully complying with the European working time directive for junior doctors. It is encouraging to report that boards are forecasting that they will be even less reliant on non-recurring funding than they have been this year.A picture of further improvement in the financial position of the health service has been presented, but NHS bodies have set themselves challenging savings targets to achieve that. To illustrate what I mean, for 2008-09 six boards have savings targets that are much higher than the savings they delivered in 2007-08.Boards will also need to consider carefully the implications of the introduction of single outcome agreements between the Scottish Government and local authorities and the abolition of the ring-fenced budget arrangements for local government. There might be a risk with delayed-discharge funding, for example, because it is being allocated directly to councils and will no longer be ring fenced. Therefore, there are areas of pressure that we must bear in mind.As ever, I am happy to answer questions, with support from the Audit Scotland team.
link
Another excellent report has been produced. It contains a huge amount of useful information.I want to ask about the revenue underspend of £24 million and the capital underspend of £2 million in 2007-08 that you mentioned. What happens to that money?
It is taken back to the centre in the NHS. If there is an underspend, the money is made available for other purposes.
link
We do not, though, have information about how that money is reallocated.
No—not explicitly.
I will ask a general question. Is the pressure on boards to operate efficiently lessened if they do not feel that they can use the benefits of that efficiency in the future—if the money just returns to the centre?
It is difficult to give a simple answer to that question. Through the financial accountability arrangements and the annual reviews that are conducted between the health directorates and boards, accountability is strong on financial and service performance. The NHS still operates an arrangement whereby significant sums of money are allocated for particular purposes, such as initiatives to tackle waiting times. Not all that money is allocated at the beginning of the year. In fact, the pattern is that the money is released during the year for boards to take up.It is difficult to be exact about the overall level of incentives to perform that that system implies. To the extent that money that was not notified in advance is released during the year, robust financial planning on a sustainable basis is that bit more challenging for boards. However, I do not wish to give the impression that that has been raised with us as a major problem in managing board finances.Do members of the team have anything to add?
If an underspend relates to planned expenditure on a project, boards can agree with the centre to carry forward that money. That is built into the system for planned project work.
Mr Black said that the NHS budget is £10 billion. The annual underspend to which Murdo Fraser referred totals £26 million, which is 0.26 per cent of the budget. That is interesting, but the saving is quite small. Perhaps the clinical negligence provision offers more opportunity to make funds available—I have mentioned that several times before. Page 16 of the report shows that the NHS sets aside £125 million for cases of clinical negligence. Pay-outs in the past 10 years have peaked at only £8 million, apart from last year, when the figure rose to £20 million, but that was anomalous. Why is so much—£125 million—held in the coffers, when the evidence is that we have paid out only about £8 million in each of the past 10 years? Perhaps the opportunity exists to reinvest some of that money in front-line care.
It is important to bear in mind the distinction between the amount that is paid out and the amount that is provided for claims that will be required to be paid and for contingent liabilities, which are potential claims. It is fundamental to good financial management to provide for expenditure that will definitely occur and to recognise liabilities for other spending. That lies at the heart of the difference between the amount that is paid and the amount that is provided for.Historically, claims for clinical medical negligence in Scotland have been low in comparison with those south of the border. However, the trend has been for an increase. It is not entirely clear whether that is due simply to the one-off settlement of a small number of cases, as the report says, or to a longer-running trend. We need to keep the issue under review.The issue is not a problem for individual boards, because they pay into a central pot as a form of insurance scheme. The cost of clinical negligence is shared among all the boards, so it does not hit the finances of any board more than another.
I absolutely appreciate everything that you said. I am just interested in the scale of the difference between the cost and the provision. As I said, pay-outs have peaked at about £8 million per year, but the NHS sets aside £125 million for claims. Although I appreciate that there is a need to do that, the difference is so huge that some attention needs to be paid to it.
I am not sure that we can comment on the appropriateness of the provision. Can Nick Hex help?
The provision is meant to cover not just the coming year but future years. It is not just £8 million or £20 million for a particular year; the money will cover all cases in the pipeline, quite a lot of which might take more than a year. We are aware of the number of cases, but as the Auditor General says, we cannot say whether the provision is adequate.
I will leave it at that.
The report is excellent; it looks like good news for the health service and patients.Agenda for change and equal pay come up all the time—Robert Black mentioned them earlier. I note that all health boards should have gone through the agenda for change process by 31 December 2008. Agenda for change is constantly being raised with me, and I am sure that other members hear about it, too.Murdo Fraser asked about health boards' savings going into the central financial pot. Can health boards use savings to pay for agenda for change or equal pay, or are there certain criteria for the use of extra money?
As I said in my opening remarks, the NHS has some pretty challenging targets for future efficiency savings of more than £600 million for the next few years. That money is available for reinvestment, but it is not possible to earmark future savings for any particular activity.As we said in our report, the Scottish Government's latest estimate is that agenda for change will cost about £634 million to the end of 2007-08. You are therefore right to say that it is a significant issue for the NHS.
I know that you might not be able to answer my questions but I am looking for some comfort for nurses and others about agenda for change. Your report notes that only four health boards are fully committed to agenda for change. It seems sensible that the staff should be the first to receive any efficiency savings, rather than that money being put into a capital project.
All boards have made provision for agenda for change. Even if they have not settled in the current financial year, they will carry money forward to do so.The uncertainty is around the level of appeals and the equal pay claim. We know of a case—a discrimination challenge—involving agenda for change in England. That is where the uncertainty lies, not in the accruals for paying existing staff.
Thank you for that clarification.
It is not all good news. Paragraph 86 says"it is not yet clear how the SFT will work or how the NHS will be able to access capital funding from this source",and paragraph 87 says"It is not yet clear how the SFT intends to secure the private investment for these and future capital projects."Do you or your colleagues have any indication about how the Scottish Futures Trust will work?
No. Unfortunately, I cannot supply you with any more information than what is in the report.
Is there nothing on the horizon?
I do not have any information on that at all.
On the lead-in for project development, are any concerns emerging about the lack of clarity on how funding will be provided?
We have not looked at the issue in any detail. I am sorry, but I find it difficult to answer that question.
Pages 23 and 24 of Audit Scotland's report, from paragraphs 71 through to 74, refer to savings. Paragraph 71 states that "In order to achieve their financial positions for 2008/09"boards have identified £170 million of savings, split between recurring and non-recurring savings. Did your team do any work to identify where boards are making those savings? There is a case study from Glasgow, but can you draw information together in a chart to indicate which services are being affected?
We are unable to comment on that because, as I said, the report is a high-level review of finances in the past year, with no more than a general indication of some of the future challenges that are out there. We plan to undertake further work in the area in the coming year. I ask Barbara Hurst to give an indication of our intentions.
We plan to kick off a study early in the new year that will examine efficiencies across the public sector. We will consider not only the 2 per cent efficiency targets but how public bodies are gearing up to make efficiency savings and whether those are recurring or one-off savings. We hope to publish the report in late summer, so it is a case of jam tomorrow for the committee. We will examine how not only health bodies but local government and central Government bodies make efficiencies.
Paragraph 73 states that boards have highlighted the risk that they may fail to achieve the planned savings for 2008-09. What is the fallback position? I understand that, if an organisation is asked to make a saving of 1 or 2 per cent, that money does not go to the organisation, as it is expected to make the saving within its budget. When do alarm bells ring? When are decisions made to alter the budget allocations to deal with any problems?
It is very difficult for us to comment in-year, because the position within individual boards can change markedly as the year progresses. Any comments that we offer on such matters are always tentative and we are reluctant to give figures. We decided that, on the basis of the information that we acquired from NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, we could put in an example of the challenge that boards face. I said in my opening remarks that the savings that a number of boards are expected to find in future are greater than the savings that they managed to deliver in the past. That is one high-level indication of the pressure that will be on board finances against the overall position of their managing their finances rather well. Can the team help on the efficiency savings question?
One of the issues that we looked at in the Western Isles was Government monitoring. Cathie Craigie asked about alarm bells ringing. The Government has a robust system in place to monitor how boards are doing in meeting their budgets. She is right to point out that the savings are built into the budget at the start of the year, so this is all tied in with boards not exceeding their revenue resource limit, through which they manage their financial position throughout the year. A system is in place, and the auditors keep an eye on the situation. We do not necessarily look at the financial position in the round until the year end, but we are aware that the Government keeps an eye on it.
link
Paragraphs 33 and 34 of the report are on sickness rates and efficiency savings. There is quite a contrast between the average sickness rate for NHS boards and the rate at NHS 24, which is 9.06 per cent. Is there a reason why the sickness rate at NHS 24 is so high compared with the rates at other bodies?In addition, I note that the sickness absence savings target has been extended to March 2009. Is any progress being made towards achieving the target and reducing sickness rates?
NHS 24 has always struggled with sickness absence. We can understand some of the reasons for that, because the staff work in a stressful environment. There has also been a conscious policy for NHS 24 to recruit staff, particularly nurses, who are subject to health constraints such as bad backs or whatever. The rate appears to be high, but there are some underlying reasons for that.The 4 per cent target across the piece is a challenging target for the health service, because it is a public service in which there is a risk of occupational health issues. The health service certainly does not want staff who are sick to go in to work. All that we would say is that the 4 per cent target is challenging, and I think that the health service knows that.
The rate for NHS 24 sticks out like a sore thumb compared with the others. It would be interesting to find out whether NHS 24 is examining the matter. I understand that a good percentage of its staff are employed on a part-time basis, and those people might have other jobs. I accept your point that people who are physically unable to do jobs on wards might work at NHS 24, but NHS 24 also employs people from other backgrounds such as the civil service and call centres. Do you know whether NHS 24 has analysed how many of its employees work there as a second job rather than as their main job?
Correct me if I am wrong, but I think that, when we considered the matter in more detail, we found that NHS 24's sickness rate was not that different from call centre sickness rates. Although it looks odd compared with the others, it might not be odd compared with the rates for comparable services.I would be surprised if NHS 24 were not examining its rate of sickness absence, but I cannot give you an absolute assurance because I do not know whether it is doing so.Sometime next year we will start a study of emergency care services, and of course NHS 24 is key to that, so we will pick up the matter as part of that study.
Exhibit 3 on page 8 shows that, at the end of 2007-08, the NHS boards, as opposed to the special boards, were still carrying a deficit of about £35 million. That is projected to decrease to about £16.5 million by the end of 2008-09. How are those figures agreed with the health directorates? You mention an underspend of £24 million by the NHS in Scotland, and I think that the NHS boards had an underspend of £50 million in 2007-08. How should we interpret that in the context of the continuing deficits? Would the deficit be £85 million if NHS boards had not underspent by £50 million, or is that a simplistic way to look at it?
Perhaps Nick Hex can take us through the figures.
I can, if you would like me to disentangle them. Exhibit 3 shows the underlying financial position for the board—it is not the year-end position, which is highlighted in appendix 1 and which shows where the board finishes in terms of its financial accounts. As you can see, all the boards apart from NHS Western Isles achieved their revenue resource limit.Exhibit 3 essentially strips out any one-off funding that the board receives and any one-off payments that it makes during the year. We are simply trying to match up the recurring funding that the board receives with the recurring expenditure that it makes, to show how the board lives within its means. As you rightly point out, we have shown that the NHS boards—the territorial boards, as it were—have a total underlying deficit of £35 million, but that is offset slightly by the special boards, which have an underlying surplus of £18 million. That deficit has reduced significantly for the NHS boards from about £103 million last year.Things are moving in the right direction. Increasingly, the boards are more financially sustainable, in that they do not have to rely on one-off funding to bridge that £35 million gap and break even, as they would have had to do in the past. I do not know whether that helps.
I could carry on for some time, but I will stop there. It points me in the right direction, which is helpful.
With regard to the issue of the underlying deficits as a percentage of recurring income, the figures for NHS Orkney and—to some extent—NHS Shetland are worrying. You state at the top of exhibit 3:"The three island boards and NHS Highland have the biggest underlying recurring deficits as a percentage of their recurring income."The committee has identified that issue before. We have pondered whether there are issues with regard to the size and the relative expense of maintaining an infrastructure for those small boards, as well as attracting the expertise. The committee can deliberate on that later, so I will leave it aside, but is there a particular worry about NHS Orkney, and perhaps NHS Shetland, that needs to be considered?
It is difficult to say at this stage. The auditors are keeping an eye on it, and we are aware that NHS Orkney in particular has some issues that it needs to address. I do not want to say anything about the future position of those boards, but they will need to be carefully monitored. I am not sure whether Nick Hex would like to comment on the detailed analysis, bearing in mind that all this will be in the Official Report, as I keep reminding my staff.
I do not think there is anything to add.
The figure for the underlying deficit in NHS Western Isles in 2007-08 is £2.5 million, and it is £1.1 million for 2008-09. Does that mean that NHS Western Isles is expected to make a surplus of £1.4 million in 2008-09, or is that too simplistic?
Again, it is about trying to convert some of the one-off funding on which the board has relied in the past into recurring funding—or rather, about the board trying to live within its means. Part of that relates to efficiency: if the board can achieve recurring efficiency savings, that helps to ensure that it can live within its recurring budget.
You mentioned that you were going to consider the finances of public bodies. In paragraph 88, you talk about the new international financial reporting standards, which you say"will have significant implications for NHS bodies as it is more likely that they will be required to show PFI assets on their balance sheets."Will you elaborate on that? What will NHS bodies have to do? Will the new set-up have financial implications for them?
The introduction of the international financial reporting standards—and bringing assets on balance sheet—will be an issue not only for the Scottish Government but for the UK as a whole. Discussions are on-going about how the new reporting standards will be treated. My understanding is that provisions will be made at the level of health boards to cover that. Unfortunately, I am not fully sighted on the latest UK-level policy decisions on the issue.
All we can really say is what is in that paragraph, which is that we are aware that the new reporting standards may have an impact. It will be down to the individual bodies and the auditors to decide whether some of the new capital schemes will be included on their balance sheets. That may imply some additional costs, depending on how those schemes are shown. Various accounting issues are tied up in that, which are probably too complex to explain here. However, I am not aware of any significant developments since that paragraph was published.
Thank you for your contribution. The discussion has been useful. We will come to our deliberations on the issue later in the agenda.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Dec 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Wednesday 10 December 2008 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- Section 23 Reports Committee business · 167
- Section 23 Reports Committee business · 49
- Section 22 Report: Response Committee business · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.