I can add to that. I agree with what Paul McManus has said. The licences were announced as agreed in March 2024. In the run-up to that, there were at least two years of negotiation. That was two years in which any of the arguments that it is advancing could have been flagged up—you are absolutely correct in that, Mr Brown.
Two things have happened. First, there is clearly a debate to be had about the changing nature of news consumption. That debate is not just happening in broadcast; it is happening in print and other areas of journalism, and it is about the way that organisations adapt to how people absorb news.
Separately, however, Paul McManus is absolutely right to say that this is a short-term decision that will have catastrophic long-term effects if it is allowed to stand. In those two years, I did not hear STV advance the argument, before negotiating and agreeing the licences, about what it is attempting to do. However, it is doing so now that the licences are there—they are over the line—and presumably we are outside the cycle where other people can come in and take over a licence if needs be. We need to be clear why it is doing that.
As you can imagine, STV’s income comes from TV advertising and the production house income. TV advertising can alter significantly quarter by quarter. It is quite difficult to see in advance, although you can make predictions. Last year, STV had the Euros and it had a good year. Next year, it has the world cup, and we can assume that advertising will pick up on the back of that. This year, we are below on the figures, but—who knows?—we could go into the budget and consumer confidence could come back, so advertising income could be restored. There are also the income from productions, but that is viewed from a much longer timescale of around 18 months. You know way in advance when you have a productions shortfall coming through.
In May, the new strategic direction was launched. There was then the profits warning at the end of July and a quite catastrophic drop in share price—I believe that it dropped about a third of its value within a day. The share price has not recovered, even after STV announced the latest set of plans at the end of September.
Do I believe that it went into the licence negotiations making the same arguments about public sector broadcasting? That is possible—it is changing—but certainly, now that we are over the line, the decision seems to be being rushed through and panicked. It seems to be based on the Ofcom review, but it is quite separate from that. I think that it is to do with financial mismanagement and with not seeing what is coming.