I will go back to your first question. We have been talking about this being a long time coming; just for context, I was about 14 or 15, and still in high school, when the measures were first announced, and I am now 25. Therefore, I cannot quite comment on how the participation process has gone, but I very much welcome the fact that Young Sea Changers Scotland has been invited here to participate in these discussions.
To be honest, I do not think that the proposals, as they currently stand, meet our requirements at a national and international scale, partly because of the requirements set out in the Marine Strategy Regulations 2010 and the Fisheries Act 2020 for ecosystem-based approaches. Whole-site measures have been applied in five of the sites, but, for the remaining 15, only part-measures have been applied. You cannot protect just parts of ecosystems, because active pressure on the remainder of those sites will affect the ability of the part of the ecosystem that is protected to thrive and recover as best it can. That ability will be hampered. If we are to have the sort of recovering and thriving ecosystems that these measures set out to achieve, we need a whole-site approach.
That said, I do congratulate the Government on putting the measures for the whole-site approaches in place, because they are very welcome. They also take our protected seabed coverage up to over 60,000km2, which is very impressive. I recognise, too, that the partial protections were put in place after dialogue with the fishing industry, which is obviously crucial.
However, if we are to meet international and national requirements, the measures fall short, because I do not believe that they are taking the entire ecosystem-based approach that they should be taking, and which the JNCC recommended. It identified that bottom-towed fishing gear, whether trawling or dredging, has the highest potential impact on the ecosystems. We are talking about deep-sea, very fragile and slow-growing systems, with slow mobility, and their ability to recover from damage and pressure is much different to some more inshore ecosystems, which can rebound quite quickly when protection is put in place.
Obviously, as Professor Harrison has said, we still lack some knowledge and science about these areas. That is why we have what is called the precautionary approach, which allows us to put in place protections to safeguard those ecosystems against potential pressures. Those protections give us the time to understand things better, because it is much harder to discover and make sense of what is there if it is too late and it has already gone.
I note, too, that this is Scotland’s climate week. Our deep-sea habitats are very important for storing carbon, and the release of that carbon as a result of the impact of bottom-towed fishing gear goes against our climate targets. If we are to achieve those targets and mitigate climate change, whole-site approaches should be prioritised.