Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Scottish Parliament (Disqualification) Order 2025 [Draft]

Thursday 26 June 2025 Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee About 09:00 Subordinate legislation 14 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Martin Whitfield Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

Good morning, and welcome to the 12th meeting in 2025 of the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee. I have received apologies from Ruth Maguire, so I welcome Rona Mackay, who is attending as a substitute.

Our first agenda item is consideration of the draft Scottish Parliament (Disqualification) Order 2025. I welcome Jamie Hepburn, the Minister for Parliamentary Business; and, from the Scottish Government, Kenneth Pentland, elections team; Ailsa Kemp, head of the parliamentary liaison unit; and Jordan McGrory, solicitor.

Minister, would you like to make a short opening statement?

Jamie Hepburn SNP The Minister for Parliamentary Business · Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Yes, convener, and my thanks to you and the committee for the opportunity to discuss the order.

The order is an established item of business in advance of each Scottish Parliament election. Section 15 of the Scotland Act 1998 sets out the circumstances in which a person is disqualified automatically from membership of the Parliament—for example, by virtue of their being a judge, civil servant or member of the armed forces. In addition, section 15 provides an order-making power to disqualify specific office-holders from membership of the Parliament, thereby allowing for separation between the legislature and the holders of various public offices. That serves to reinforce their independence from one another.

In preparing the draft order that disqualifies specific office-holders, we consulted widely with policy officials and sponsor teams in the Scottish Government and with Parliament officials on the entries for offices supported by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. With the help of officials in the Scotland Office, we gathered responses from the United Kingdom Government and the other devolved nations through devolution leads in each UK department.

The draft order that is before the committee updates the list of disqualified offices to reflect relevant appointments that have been abolished, renamed or created since the making of the Scottish Parliament (Disqualification) Order 2020. A total of 30 new disqualifications were added, 21 were removed and 28 amendments were made to existing disqualified offices. I highlight the fact that 12 of the amendments simply reflected changes in the names of bodies from “Her Majesty’s” to “His Majesty’s”. For example, HMRC has now changed from being Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs to His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs.

To give you an example of an addition, we have added the new Patient Safety Commissioner for Scotland, following the Parliament’s decision to establish the role earlier in this parliamentary session. Given that the commissioner is supported by the SPCB and is expected to be politically impartial, it is important to ensure that an individual is not able to hold that role while being an MSP.

This list is extensive, given the breadth of the public body landscape across the UK, but members should not see the order as a constraint on the wide talent that is available to the Parliament, as people in a disqualified office can, of course, opt to step down from such a position and seek to bring their experience to the Parliament if they wish.

As the committee will be aware, the order was originally withdrawn and relaid. That followed the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee highlighting some bodies in the list that had changed name and so were no longer correctly captured. Those amounted to less than 1 per cent of the overall list, and it is important to recognise that the errors highlighted did not relate to Scottish bodies or office-holders, so the chance of such individuals seeking to become an MSP were slim. Regardless, I am grateful to the DPLRC for highlighting those errors so that we could make the necessary corrections in advance of coming to this committee.

Ailsa Kemp, Kenny Pentland, Jordan McGrory and I are happy to take any questions that you might have.

Martin Whitfield Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

Thank you very much. I have a couple of questions and reflections, which you have already hinted at. Our sister committee—the DPLRC—identified some errors in the original draft order. As you said, they affected less than 1 per cent of the list and were rectified.

In your opening statement, you talked about the outreach to ensure that the updated list is as accurate as possible. Could any steps be taken to improve that? It seems to require others to come and feed in to that list, albeit that they are invited to do so. Do you have confidence in the oversight that your part of Government holds with regard to the creation of that list?

Jamie Hepburn SNP Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Broadly speaking, yes. To go back to the point that I made earlier, a very small number of bodies were inaccurately referred to, and those details did not emanate from within this Administration. However, that is not to pass the buck, as we should, of course, try to get those things right. I reflect that that is one of the virtues of parliamentary scrutiny—inevitably, the DPLRC might pick up on something and we can then act to ensure that the list is up to date.

I am more than willing to hear any suggestions about our processes. For example, one of the differences between our approach and that of Westminster is that Westminster has a more general, broader power, whereas we detail specific office-holders. There are advantages and disadvantages to both approaches. I suggest that the advantage to the way in which we do it—compared to setting out the broader terms under which any office might be disqualified—is that it is very clear who is disqualified. The downside to our approach is that you might not capture everyone or might get caught out by the mere fact that office-holders or various organisations no longer exist. However, we are more than willing to consider any alterations that the Parliament cares to suggest.

Martin Whitfield Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

Are you still confident that the specificity in this order is the right approach, rather than the more general one, which potentially leaves it open for an individual to question whether they are covered?

Jamie Hepburn SNP Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

As I have said, there are advantages and disadvantages to both approaches. If you are asking my view, on balance, I think that the approach that we take is slightly better. Although it is a slightly more onerous process, which we must constantly revise because of the points that I just made, I think that there is an advantage in having the specific details of who is disqualified.

Martin Whitfield Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

Might there be an advantage to having a table or a snapshot in the order to explain the changes from the previous one, or are you content that each order sits on its own to take us forward? You have given us the figures—the total number of those that are in and those that are out—but do you see an advantage to capturing them in a table in the order itself, so that people could see the changes?

Jamie Hepburn SNP Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I would need to check whether we would be able to do that in the first instance. I see the advantage in doing that if we are able to. If we are not able to, we might make that clear in another way, by directing people towards other information that we make available.

I have the list in front of me—it is extensive, so I do not intend to read it out in its entirety. Thirty entries were added, 21 were removed and 28 entries were amendments of name, designation and so on. We could perhaps look into the matter. The fact that I have the figures in front of me suggests that we could probably do that fairly straightforwardly. I do not know whether we could specify that information in the order, but I am happy to take a wee look at the matter.

Martin Whitfield Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

That is fine. I am more than happy that the publication of the order puts those entries sufficiently on the public record—it saves your having to go through the whole list.

I have a final question. What test is applied in relation to why disqualification will take place? You hinted at the matter when you mentioned the new body, in which a position would clearly be seen as a conflict. This is not a test, but can you articulate the test that is applied to decide whether a position should fit into the disqualification order?

Jamie Hepburn SNP Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I can indeed, convener. It is fairly well established and understood, and it has been in place for a while. It is broadly consistent with the wider UK approach as well.

The broad criteria for disqualification are

“Offices for profit in the gift of the Crown or ministers”

—that would include

“salaried, pensionable and certain fee-paid posts”

but exclude

“posts attracting expenses alone.”

There is an exemption for

“offices where the remuneration is less than £10,000 per year”,

which are not normally disqualified.

There are

“Certain positions of control in companies in receipt of Government grants and funds, to which Ministers usually, though not necessarily, make appointments”

and

“offices imposing duties which with regard to time and place would prevent their holders from fulfilling Parliamentary duties”

—in effect, it is felt that they would have too much on their hands, as they already have a burden of responsibility that would not really allow them to be a member of the Scottish Parliament.

Of course, we are going through the consideration of dual mandates, and the issue fits in that territory. There are other offices whose holders are required to be—or certainly seem to be—politically impartial.

Those are the broad criteria that we apply. If there is a question as to whether they are comprehensive enough—or, indeed, whether they encompasses too many people—we are always willing to look at them again.

Martin Whitfield Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

That is very helpful. I am grateful, minister. Do other committee members have any questions?

Rona Mackay SNP Strathkelvin and Bearsden
link

I have a tiny question. I apologise if I missed this in the detail, but when was the list last updated?

Jamie Hepburn SNP Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

It is updated in advance of each and every Scottish Parliament election. The last update was done in 2020.

Martin Whitfield Lab The Convener · South Scotland
link

As there are no other questions from the committee, we will move on to the debate on the motion.

Motion moved,

That the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee recommends that the Scottish Parliament (Disqualification) Order 2025 draft be approved.—Jamie Hepburn

Motion agreed to.

  1. 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 14
  2. 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
  3. 10:15 Cross-Party Groups Committee business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.