This has been a fascinating discussion. I have been listening not only patiently but with great interest.
The human element is incredibly important. We have touched on that with regard to customers who might have been impacted by the incident at NatWest, and there are people who might have been impacted by the incident at Arnold Clark. Every serious organisation in the country will have cybercrime on its risk register. It is a case of knowing that such incidents will happen as opposed to hoping that they will not happen. I am sure that a lot of investment has been made in that area and that there has been a lot of good thinking on it.
For the past few years—probably since 2021—we have been undertaking research on the issue. Initially, the research was on older people’s attitudes to scamming and fraud, but we have moved on to cybercrime as that has become more prevalent. Our latest research on that, which was published in 2023, showed that, between 2021 and 2023, there had been changes in the type of thing that people encountered. Being targeted through email or text message was the most common method, and there will now be a lot more cases in which, because of developments in AI, as we have touched on, people will not be able to understand that some things are not real, as they will look very convincing. A lot of older people have sensory impairment, such as sight loss or hearing loss, so, if there is a glitch in a system, it will be passive for them. Things can look very convincing.
The last time that we undertook research on the issue, we found that about 20 per cent of people who had been a victim of a fraud-related crime did not report it. They did not know where to go to report it, they did not think that it would be taken seriously and they did not think that anything could be done. I am not sure whether 20 per cent represents a lot of people or not very many, but, in the future, we will want people to become more confident in reporting what has happened to them.
10:45
There might not be a particularly good and easy resolution, because a lot of such cases involve people losing money. As has been touched on, that affects people’s confidence and they might not want to tell anyone that such things have happened. It is quite hard to work out the degree of financial loss, which is perhaps due to how stats are collated and reported. Sorry, ACC Houston—I am not necessarily looking at you and Police Scotland in that regard, but having such information will help us to understand the scale of the problem out there. We know that there is a lot of underreporting, too.
Such crimes can result in financial destitution for people. They absolutely hit an individual’s confidence and self-worth, but there are other detrimental impacts, too. There can be an effect on someone’s health and wellbeing, on their trust in others and companies and even on their interactions with state institutions.
We have found that that is the case among people who are not particularly confident online. I can provide a couple of statistics. About three quarters of older people are online, but that does not necessarily mean that they are particularly comfortable in or skilled at navigating the internet. They can be plugged in but not necessarily able. About a quarter of those people who are online are not comfortable or safe operating online, so that means that a load of people—we are talking about between a quarter of a million and 300,000 over-65s in Scotland—are online but really unsafe. That pool of people are in a potentially difficult spot.
Being a victim of such crime can draw people into isolation, and they might move away from the internet. Some of the information that we have had relates to how we adopt digital technology throughout Scotland. If the only way that older people can interact with the state or services is digitally, and they have been a victim of or subject to digital-related incidents, they will mistrust such services. They will ask, “Is this thing legitimate? Who am I seeing?”
Committee members might have heard me say this repeatedly in different places over the past however many years, but we have to be very careful to ensure that our public services are open so that people can get support by seeing and speaking to real people.
There are two elements that are incredibly important for older people and for anyone who will, we hope, become older. Some issues might come with them, but how do we prevent such issues from happening and protect people in the first place? As a nation, how do we provide people who are online with better digital skills and with access to programmes and systems on their devices that keep them safe by blocking malicious attacks? Can we stop them from even being exposed to such issues in the first place? That would really help.