You are right that we live in quite different times from when I was studying economics, when it was about abolishing boom and bust, and everything was nice and stable. We could look ahead, spending was growing and everything was fantastic. We are now in a different place, so you are right that there is more uncertainty, but I would separate out several different things in all of that.
In some core elements of the budget, it is relatively straightforward to set aside broad trajectories or multiyear spending commitments, and it is important to prioritise areas where we might want to do that. For example, it is helpful to give relatively small organisations indicative funding and clarity over that. That is a small share of the overall budget and it does not cost too much to do that.
The second thing, however, which is where the medium-term elements kick in, is that, rather than our saying, “This is the exact amount in pounds, shillings and pence that you should expect to get,” the overall trend that is pushing through could be really important in shaping decision making in an area over the next four to five years. Social security is a good example of that. We can work to project not just the commitments that the Government will need to make next year, but whether we think that those commitments will increase over the next few years. The two-child limit is a good example, because we can model and say what is coming as additional expenditure next year and whether that will increase or decrease over the forecast horizon.
The Government can set out its overall trajectory for where it is heading as an organisation with its pay policy—for example, whether it is planning to commit to pay rises that are above the rate of inflation, which locks in some commitments over the medium term. For example, is it committing to expanding, maintaining or shrinking the workforce? The Government could set those commitments and broad trajectories.
We can highlight where some of the broad trends in public expenditure are going, and you are right that those trends change with elements of UK policy. For example, if the UK Government is going to spend more money on security and defence, and if it is not going to borrow or increase taxation to do that, we can highlight that the money will have to be found from spending elsewhere, which presents a risk to the Scottish Government’s budget in the next four to five years.
I share some of your scepticism about whether an exact budget could be set five years out, but we can do a lot more if we are able to be much more expansive about the broad trajectory and the factors that are driving spending and commitments.
10:15