Good morning. As you mentioned, convener, this is a joint briefing with the Accounts Commission on additional support for learning in Scotland’s state-funded schools.
The briefing considers how well the Scottish Government and councils are addressing the demand for additional support for learning. In 2024, over 280,000 pupils—40 per cent of all those who attend state-funded schools—were recorded as receiving ASL, and the proportion in the most deprived areas was almost double that of the least deprived areas. However, there was significant variation across Scotland’s council areas.
More than 90 per cent of pupils who received additional support for learning spent all their time in a mainstream classroom, which reflects the inclusion principles set out by the Scottish Government in the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004.
In 2024, 3 per cent of pupils attended a special school. The number of pupils receiving ASL since the introduction of the relevant legislation in 2004 has increased almost eightfold. The reasons for that significant level of growth, which are complex, include: the 2004 act’s inclusive approach to ASL, as it recognised more types of needs; changes in data recording; and, fundamentally, an increase in the awareness of children and young people’s support needs.
We found that the Scottish Government did not plan effectively for the potential impact of that inclusive approach. A lack of good-quality data means that it is not possible to determine the scale, complexity and nature of additional support needs across Scotland. Therefore, the Scottish Government and councils urgently need better information in order to understand pupils’ needs and the resources that are required to support them.
Existing outcome measures show that the gap between pupils who receive ASL and other children and young people is wide. For example, pupils who receive ASL are likely to do less well in exams and are more likely to experience exclusion or be absent from school. More appropriate ways of measuring the range and achievements of pupils who receive ASL, which go beyond exams and assessments, remain at an early development stage. The current data gap means that it is unclear whether all the rights that children have to an education that fully develops their personalities, talents and abilities are currently being met.
Four years on from Angela Morgan’s independent review of additional support for learning, “Support for Learning: All our Children and All their Potential”, we have seen limited progress in tackling the key ASL challenges. Given that 40 per cent of pupils are now recorded as receiving ASL, providing additional support for learning is increasingly a core part of what all teachers do in Scotland’s classrooms.
In our view, the Scottish Government and councils must now fundamentally evaluate how ASL is planned for, resourced and assessed. The four of us on the panel are very much looking forward to answering the committee’s questions.