Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Surgical Mesh and Fixation Devices (PE1865)

Wednesday 19 February 2025 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 09:45 Petitions 9 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

9 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Welcome back. We continue our consideration of continued petitions.

PE1865, which was lodged by Roseanna Clarkin and Lauren McDougall, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to suspend the use of all surgical mesh and fixation devices while a review of all surgical procedures that use polyester, polypropylene or titanium is carried out and guidelines for the surgical use of mesh are established.

We are joined for our consideration of the petition by Katy Clark and our former committee colleague, Carol Mochan, both of whom have previously been concerned with the issues raised by the petition. Good morning to you both.

We most recently considered the petition nearly a year ago, last March, when we agreed to write to the Cabinet Secretary for NHS Recovery, Health and Social Care and to the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. At this point, I should probably remind colleagues that I am a member of the SPCB.

The SPCB’s response sets out the process for appointing the patient safety commissioner for Scotland. The post was first advertised in March 2024, although, as members might be aware, it remains unfilled and was readvertised on 7 February.

We have also received a response from the Minister for Public Health and Women’s Health, which highlights the expectation that, regardless of where mesh removal surgery takes place, local health boards should provide any necessary aftercare that patients might require. The response also highlights that

“A patient should decide upon their treatment with their clinician, following meaningful discussion and sharing of all necessary information”,

and that those discussions should be documented.

On the issue of natural tissue repair, the minister tells us not only that a “significant number” of hernias are repaired without mesh in Scotland, but that Government officials are working with surgeons who have a specific interest in hernia repair and have begun to identify individuals who have the skills to take forward surgical hernia repair that is consistent with the Shouldice technique, on which the committee took oral evidence from the Shouldice folk in Canada back in February 2022—PE1865 is a long-standing petition.

We have also received two submissions from the petitioners. The first draws our attention to an article in the Journal of Abdominal Wall Surgery on hernia repair surgery in adolescents and suggests that a similar approach, whereby consideration is given to the risks of hernia recurrence and mesh complications, should be adopted for hernia repair in adults. The petitioners believe that hernia surgery should be considered as principled surgery, with surgeons being trained specifically in the Shouldice and natural tissue repair techniques as well as mesh techniques. In their second submission, Roseanna and Lauren restate the call for a centre of excellence to be established as a means of ensuring that informed patient pathways are available for natural tissue repair and mesh removal.

Alongside that call, the petitioners continue to advocate for an independent review of the use of mesh, and they have provided a brief summary of their meeting with Terry O’Kelly, who is the Scottish Government’s senior medical adviser, whom the committee previously heard from, and representatives of the Scottish Health Technologies Group, which has only strengthened their calls for an independent review to be carried out.

I will invite Katy Clark and Carol Mochan to contribute before the committee considers how best to proceed. However, it is only fair to say—I say this as someone who has been closely associated with the issue for more than a decade—that the committee is not certain how to take this particular petition forward. Important issues have been raised. There has certainly been some advance in respect of the Government’s approach to the use of Shouldice techniques, which was a bit of an uphill push, but which the committee, with our introduction of the Shouldice evidence, helped to make happen. However, we are a little unsure as to what more we can usefully do, given that the parliamentary session is now beginning to wind down from the point of view of our ability to consider petitions.

I am keen to hear from Katy and Carol before we make any determination. It has been decided that Katy will speak first.

Katy Clark Lab West Scotland
link

I am grateful to have the opportunity to make a contribution. I have met some of the petitioners on a number of occasions, including this week. The lead petitioners are both constituents. One of them has suffered quite severe complications as a result of the hernia mesh procedure; the other is the daughter of a deceased person who was also a constituent and who underwent the hernia mesh procedure. They are working with a range of campaigners across Scotland—and, indeed, the rest of the United Kingdom—who are collating information about the complications.

The submission that I made to the committee very much focuses on data. As the convener said, we had the opportunity to meet the minister and, as a result of that, we had a subsequent meeting with medical advisers and officials. It is clear to the petitioners that there is a lack of data in relation to the extent of the problem.

I have previously advised the committee of freedom of information requests that were submitted to health boards. We did not get information from many health boards, but the information that we got was concerning. The petitioners are concerned about the basis on which work is proceeding. Frankly, the data that we have does not truly reflect the scale of the number of people who have complications. That was the focus of the written representation that I made to the committee.

I wonder whether the committee would be willing to engage further with the Scottish Government on the issue, as it is clearly not an issue that will go away. The petitioners and many others continue to suffer the consequences of the hernia mesh procedure, and the campaign will continue. It would be appropriate for the Scottish Parliament to be engaged with that in order to ensure that an evidence-based approach is taken and that work is undertaken to gather such evidence.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Has the subsequent meeting that you mentioned taken place? Am I correct in picking up that it has?

Katy Clark Lab West Scotland
link

Yes, that is correct. That meeting took place before Christmas. I attended it, along with the petitioners.

Carol Mochan Lab South Scotland
link

I thank the committee for inviting me to attend the meeting, because, as members know, I have previously spoken on the issue, and I want to ensure that people are fully aware of the extent of the situation involving people who have undergone the mesh procedure.

I echo the points that have been made by Katy Clark and the petitioners in their submissions to the committee. I support their point about the lack of data on the number of patients who are experiencing complications as a result of the use of mesh. It is concerning that we do not know whether we are capturing that data, which is important. The submissions highlighted the fact that the data that is currently being relied on is inconsistent, incomplete and often outdated. We should all take that issue very seriously. I will not repeat the point that the convener made about that, which was well made. It is clear the minister has taken the issue seriously.

Although the Scottish Health Technologies Group report is interesting, there is good reason to think that the data sets that it used are, as one of the petitioner’s submissions highlights, “narrow and incomplete”. Action could be taken to look at that.

In addition, the absence of follow-up data is worrying. We do not know whether any follow-up work is being done, although a commitment has been made that such work will be done. The full extent of mesh-related complications is also worrying. Given that complications might not be immediately apparent after surgery, could we have a system in place that would allow us to look at that?

I echo the points that Katy Clark made, and I request that the committee keeps the petition open and perhaps writes to the Government regarding a review of the current data sets, so that we can continue to support the work of the petitioners.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you. Do colleagues have any thoughts? I am between a rock and a hard place on this one. There is probably not much more that we can do in this parliamentary session, and I am minded to move to close the petition. However, I might be prepared to defer closing it, and to indicate to the Government that although we are moving in that direction, we would like to have further confirmation on the points that have been raised about data, in particular.

If colleagues are content, we could approach the Government to get a specific response on that. However, we should be mindful of the fact that, notwithstanding any response that we got, we are probably nearing the point at which we would have to say that any future work on the issue would be best served by the lodging of a fresh petition in the next session of Parliament. I think that I would feel most comfortable if we agreed to go down the route of giving the Government a further nudge on the aspect that arose from the work of the Scottish Health Technologies Group, as amplified in Katy Clark’s written submission and the oral submissions of our colleagues.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness and Nairn
link

The evidence that we have heard from our colleagues today indicates that there has been a lack of response from health boards. I do not know why that is, but that is the situation. Because that is the case, Katy Clark sought to obtain relevant information but has not received it. Were we to close the petition today, the petitioners could easily and legitimately lodge a fresh petition, calling for the data to be analysed. Rather than have all that delay and extra work, we might as well keep the petition open so that we can ask for the information that Katy Clark has, quite rightly, sought. I am aware of the evidence that Clare Adamson gave on behalf of her constituents. Plainly, those who are affected have been affected very profoundly.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Do we agree to keep the petition open on that basis?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 46
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  4. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  5. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  6. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 1
  9. 10:30 New Petitions Petitions · 2
  10. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 8
  11. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  12. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 4
  13. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 3
  14. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.