link
Our next petition is PE1979, which was lodged by Neil McLennan, Christine Scott, Alison Dickie and Bill Cook, who join us in the public gallery this morning. Welcome to you all. We are also joined for consideration of this petition by our MSP colleagues Edward Mountain and Ash Regan. Good morning to both of you.
The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to launch an independent inquiry to examine concerns that allegations about child protection, child abuse, safeguarding and children’s rights have been mishandled by public bodies, including local authorities and the General Teaching Council for Scotland; to examine concerns about gaps in the Scottish child abuse inquiry; and to establish an independent national whistleblowing officer for education and children’s services in Scotland to handle such inquiries in the future.
11:00
We last considered this petition at our meeting on 6 March 2024, when we agreed to write to the Minister for Children, Young People and The Promise, the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman and the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland. Copies of the responses that we received are included in the papers for today’s meeting.
Members will note that, although the SPSO suggested that there is merit in exploring an independent national whistleblowing officer role for education and children’s services, its experiences with the establishment of the national health service whistleblowing service demonstrate that it is not a straightforward process and “would require careful design”.
The response from the Children and Young People’s Commissioner echoes that sentiment and notes that, although she supports the exploration of a potential whistleblowing officer role, it is not a role that could be fulfilled by her office, nor does she have any evidence of children and young people wanting the commissioner to take on such a role.
We received two responses from the minister, the first of which refers to the Scottish Government’s determination
“to ensure that robust child protection measures are in place across Scotland”,
through implementing updated national guidelines.
The minister also indicated her willingness to meet with the petitioners. I understand that that meeting took place on 4 December and that the minister committed to keeping the petitioners updated on her work to support more robust and consistent investigations of specific cases. As the minister noted in her second response, and in response to recent questions in the chamber, that work includes engaging
“with Association of Directors of Education in Scotland representatives about the issue of how safeguarding concerns ... are investigated at local level”,
as well as establishing a national public protection leadership group
“to discuss ways public protection process in Scotland can and should improve”.
We have also received several submissions from the petitioners, which welcome the constructive and thoughtful submissions from the SPSO and the CYPCS. They highlight continued concerns about fragmented investigation systems and the power imbalance experienced by those raising safeguarding concerns, and the need to ensure that those with lived experience of such issues are part of designing an independent whistleblowing system.
The petitioners’ most recent submission comments on their meeting with the minister. Although they
“welcome any action that strengthens the protection of children and young people”,
the petitioners remain concerned that the Scottish Government has, so far, failed to address “fundamental points” such as public confidence in child safeguarding when systems, networks and personnel involved in historical and current allegations of abuse continue to be in place.
That is quite a lot of information. I ask my colleagues Edward Mountain and Ash Regan whether they have anything to say before we begin the discussion.