Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Child Protection (Public Bodies) (PE1979)

Wednesday 5 February 2025 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 10:45–11:00 Petitions 8 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
David Torrance SNP The Deputy Convener · Kirkcaldy
link

Our next petition is PE1979, which was lodged by Neil McLennan, Christine Scott, Alison Dickie and Bill Cook, who join us in the public gallery this morning. Welcome to you all. We are also joined for consideration of this petition by our MSP colleagues Edward Mountain and Ash Regan. Good morning to both of you.

The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to launch an independent inquiry to examine concerns that allegations about child protection, child abuse, safeguarding and children’s rights have been mishandled by public bodies, including local authorities and the General Teaching Council for Scotland; to examine concerns about gaps in the Scottish child abuse inquiry; and to establish an independent national whistleblowing officer for education and children’s services in Scotland to handle such inquiries in the future.

11:00

We last considered this petition at our meeting on 6 March 2024, when we agreed to write to the Minister for Children, Young People and The Promise, the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman and the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland. Copies of the responses that we received are included in the papers for today’s meeting.

Members will note that, although the SPSO suggested that there is merit in exploring an independent national whistleblowing officer role for education and children’s services, its experiences with the establishment of the national health service whistleblowing service demonstrate that it is not a straightforward process and “would require careful design”.

The response from the Children and Young People’s Commissioner echoes that sentiment and notes that, although she supports the exploration of a potential whistleblowing officer role, it is not a role that could be fulfilled by her office, nor does she have any evidence of children and young people wanting the commissioner to take on such a role.

We received two responses from the minister, the first of which refers to the Scottish Government’s determination

“to ensure that robust child protection measures are in place across Scotland”,

through implementing updated national guidelines.

The minister also indicated her willingness to meet with the petitioners. I understand that that meeting took place on 4 December and that the minister committed to keeping the petitioners updated on her work to support more robust and consistent investigations of specific cases. As the minister noted in her second response, and in response to recent questions in the chamber, that work includes engaging

“with Association of Directors of Education in Scotland representatives about the issue of how safeguarding concerns ... are investigated at local level”,

as well as establishing a national public protection leadership group

“to discuss ways public protection process in Scotland can and should improve”.

We have also received several submissions from the petitioners, which welcome the constructive and thoughtful submissions from the SPSO and the CYPCS. They highlight continued concerns about fragmented investigation systems and the power imbalance experienced by those raising safeguarding concerns, and the need to ensure that those with lived experience of such issues are part of designing an independent whistleblowing system.

The petitioners’ most recent submission comments on their meeting with the minister. Although they

“welcome any action that strengthens the protection of children and young people”,

the petitioners remain concerned that the Scottish Government has, so far, failed to address “fundamental points” such as public confidence in child safeguarding when systems, networks and personnel involved in historical and current allegations of abuse continue to be in place.

That is quite a lot of information. I ask my colleagues Edward Mountain and Ash Regan whether they have anything to say before we begin the discussion.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you, convener. I always like to come to the petitions committee because of the wide range of subjects, but this petition is particularly personal for me. It revolves around the question of safeguarding children. The simple question that we seem to be faced with is: what price do we put on safeguarding children, and do we think that what we are doing at the moment is right?

If I may, convener, I will briefly allude to a story that I have been dealing with in my constituency. It relates to a child who was approached by a teacher who was making sexual comments and innuendo to that child. The child made a complaint and left the school before they had finished their schooling. The complaint took a very long time to go through the Highland Council, and the consequence was that the teacher was found guilty. However, there were complications in that some of the investigation was prolonged by the fact that the teacher in question had had a relationship with one of the people who was investigating, and the outcome was that the child failed to complete their education.

It is actually worse than that, because it was all a secret story that resulted in the teacher being dismissed and saying, “I’ve done nothing wrong” to members of the public and the child being unable to defend themselves because nothing was made clear. I believe that Highland Council misrepresented and did not carry out its safeguarding responsibilities for that child. The council ended up marking its own homework and keeping the results quiet and not publishing them. The long-term consequences happened purely to the child.

I struggled with that and with the parents having to deal with that, because it seems so wrong. I find it difficult to accept, which is why I absolutely believe that we need an independent inquiry and an independent national whistleblowing officer, so that parents can make sure that their children are actually safeguarded in schools. At the moment, in my humble opinion, the situation favours the employee, because the employer is investigating and has a responsibility for protecting the employee, however bad they have been, from the outcomes of any inquiries.

I raised that issue with the General Teaching Council in Scotland and I did not get an acceptable outcome, which is why I believe that the committee ought to consider the matter further and push the Government harder. Frankly, it does not know who will do the role. There was a question about cost, which is unacceptable. What cost do we place on safeguarding people? What cost do we place on safeguarding our children? Frankly, I do not think that the cost is too high, because we need to get it right.

Ash Regan Alba Edinburgh Eastern
link

I thought that it might be useful to bring to the committee’s attention things that have been going on in the City of Edinburgh Council that are similar to what Edward Mountain has talked about.

I cannot go into details, but a very concerned constituent came to me to explain serious mishandling of whistleblowing and potential breaches of safeguarding of children that had been going on historically, which I believe are still unresolved. That is in Edinburgh, but I can see that the issue goes further across the country. There appears to be an unacceptably high level of safeguarding failure in the system.

We are talking about children, so I suggest to the committee that, as Edward Mountain set out, the cost should not be an issue. I do not think that the failure in the system is being adequately addressed by the current procedures and processes. I believe that certain public bodies are being defensive in the way that they interact with the Parliament and the Government.

Over the past week, we have seen that the Government, unfortunately, does not have a grip on what is going on across Scotland. As Edward Mountain did, I urge the committee to think seriously about the requests in the petition and take them forward.

David Torrance SNP The Deputy Convener · Kirkcaldy
link

I thank both colleagues for their contributions. Do members have any suggestions or comments?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness and Nairn
link

I am persuaded by what both of our visiting MSP colleagues say. I profoundly believe that the current system is inherently flawed, as the petitioners have maintained throughout the lengthy sequence of correspondence that I have read in preparation for this meeting.

We have a lot to learn from the Romans, including the first principle of natural justice: nemo iudex in causa sua—which means that no one can be a judge in their own cause.

The current basis of complaints in the health world and in education—for example, the GTC, which has been mentioned—is that the organisations deal with complaints against their employees, but it seems to me that their first instinct is usually to defend the system—the employee—against the complainant. It is almost a genuflection, and I have seen it time and again for 25 years.

I am grateful to the petitioners, because they have highlighted the existence of an inherent flaw. Child safeguarding is probably the most sensitive and important area that we could possibly conceive of, as both of our colleagues have said.

I find the cost argument to be utterly unconvincing. The petitioners have pointed out that the cost of the child abuse inquiry is likely to be £300 million. It seems to me that, in the future, we should try to tackle the cost of the existing system rather than worry about the cost of a national whistleblower’s office that will be minuscule in comparison with the cost of the damage that has resulted.

I strongly support the petition and I think that we should write to the minister. If colleagues are similarly minded, I feel that we have a sufficient evidential basis, particularly given the lengthy exchange that has taken place between the minister and the petitioners. There is no point in my rehashing it, but it is full of cogent relevant facts and material that the minister has not addressed in any way. Some of the very modest, minor work that the minister says is going on, such as making inquiries about what is happening at the moment, should have been done long ago, when the petition was first lodged. It is a bit late now.

There needs to be a whistleblower. We should not shilly-shally or dither and swither around but should instead urge the Government to get on with it and make that recommendation to the committee. Given that numerous members have registered their concerns about the issue, our impression is that there is widespread concern across the parties. Therefore we should get off the fence and recommend that there be a whistleblower. That should be considered in conjunction with the petitioners and others who can provide useful information about the whistleblower’s role, their remit and how the process would operate. As I have said, the costs would be very modest in comparison with the existing costs.

David Torrance SNP The Deputy Convener · Kirkcaldy
link

Do other members want to add anything?

Foysol Choudhury Lab Lothian
link

I agree that we should write to the Minister for Children, Young People and The Promise to recommend that the Scottish Government explore the merits of an independent national whistleblowing officer for education and children’s services. We should also seek an update on the action that the Scottish Government is taking to support more robust and consistent investigation of specific child safeguarding cases across Scotland, including what consideration has been given to addressing perceived conflicts of interest for local authorities between their responsibilities as employers and their duty of care to children and young people.

We should seek information on what engagement the Scottish Government has had with its UK counterparts following the Home Secretary’s announcement that measures to make it mandatory to report child abuse will be introduced as part of the UK Parliament’s Crime and Policing Bill, including what consideration the Scottish Government has given to introducing a similar measure in Scotland. We could also write to the General Teaching Council for Scotland to seek an update on the Professional Standards Authority’s review of its fitness-to-teach process and on the wider work that it is undertaking to review the fitness-to-teach rules, including whether any consideration is being given to perceived conflicts of interests over the role of local authorities as part of that review.

David Torrance SNP The Deputy Convener · Kirkcaldy
link

Thank you, Mr Choudhury. Are colleagues agreed that we will take those actions?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 90
  3. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  4. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  5. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  7. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  8. 11:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 1
  10. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 7
  11. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.