To pull back a bit from the question, venison sales are, as was referred to earlier, the only income stream for deer management, with the exception of the hunting element to supplement the income—or to ameliorate the loss, so to speak. It is a smallish percentage of the available income—probably 20 per cent.
The British Association for Shooting and Conservation did a study about two years ago in which it calculated that the cost of producing a kilogram of venison from culling a red deer was £2.58. The price that we typically get per kilogram is between £1.50 and £2, and that price applies to all species of deer. The cost of culling a roe deer, which is a smaller deer, in the Lowlands is actually over £7; the conversion costs are very much the same.
The net cost of culling deer, which falls entirely on the producer and is not relieved at present by any subsidy, is considerable. In other words, we are being encouraged to increase our cull, but that just increases the shortfall in the deer management business, because every deer that is culled is an extra cost. We have talked about incentives, but that is a disincentive to increase culling. I am not saying that the disincentive prevents culling in many cases, because people do the job where there needs to be population management. However, the disincentive certainly does not have a positive effect.
Rhoda Grant mentioned imports of venison. Currently, the overall output of Scottish venison is something like 3,500 tonnes. It is true that we import about 1,000 tonnes and that we export about 1,000 tonnes. That sounds a bit half baked, but there are reasons for that. Our exports tend to go to Europe, where people like the stronger-tasting venison that is produced around the time of the rut, which is when most of the males are culled.
What we bring in is brought by the processors—largely to meet market demand. Seasonality does not work for them when they are dealing with multiple retailers, so they want venison throughout the year. In order to have continuity of supply, New Zealand venison, for example, is brought in to meet the main processors’ on-going orders. That is why there is a rough trade-off between what comes in and what goes out.
If we shoot an extra 50,000 deer, as Nature Scotland is pressing us to do—the cull size is increasing all the time—that would add 1,000 to 2,000 tonnes of venison to the mix. Therefore, it is essential that we have markets that will take that venison. To compare venison with other red meats, the first point is the quality difference, because it outperforms all other red meats when it comes to healthy eating. However, if you set it against beef, cattle and white meat, it makes up a very small element of meat production. It is a small industry that is spread very widely across Scotland, and the infrastructural aspects are a big cost that other industries do not bear.
It has been said before, but deer management is basically a net-cost exercise, and that point is the absolute core of the venison trade. Scottish Venison has a big job to do if it is to grow the market and close the gap in relation to value over the coming years, which is a really important aspect of increasing the cull size. The whole deer sector is linked, and the deer economy is closely related to the value of venison.
I cannot remember what the other part of your question was.