Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 23 Reports: Responses

“Managing increasing prisoner numbers in Scotland”

Wednesday 24 September 2008 Audit Committee Committee business 12 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Under this item, we will consider a response from the relevant accountable officers on the Auditor General's report, "Managing increasing prisoner numbers in Scotland". The responses are very good and very full. It is apposite that Mike Ewart, the head of the Scottish Prison Service, commented this week on contradictions in legal responsibilities and described how he manages competing responsibilities. There is clearly a major problem.Without pre-empting the discussion, I would say that we have asked the questions and have got some good replies, containing useful information. It might now be time for us to pass the matter over to the Justice Committee, which I think is considering the whole question of prisons.

Murdo Fraser Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I agree that the response is comprehensive and helpful. Rather than dealing separately with the issue, Robert Gordon and Mike Ewart collaborated on a joint response, which was useful. As for where we go from here, we are in danger of straying into policy issues and it is more appropriate to pass the matter to the Justice Committee, which is considering the whole issue of prisons, particularly the question of capacity. I endorse your view, convener, that having noted the response, we pass it on to the Justice Committee.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

I am sure that my colleagues on the Justice Committee will be delighted when a new report arrives.

Andrew Welsh SNP Angus
link

It strikes me that some of the responses are loaded with jargon. There are acronyms in every second paragraph. For example, one response states:"The SPS have CJA Liaison Managers who work closely with CJAs in the planning process … Work has already begun to make prison populations more community focused which could assist prisoner access to appropriate support and services. This is the early stages of ‘community facing prisons', one key consideration will be matching prisoner populations with prison facilities within specified catchment areas".What does the phrase "community facing prisons" actually mean? We have received the most jargon-ridden answer that we have received in a long time. The "ICM" process, a "Core Screening process" and a "Community Integration Plan" are referred to. We are told that"Both the ICM Action plan and CIP are ‘live' processes".I presume that that contrasts with dead processes.One response states:"SPS has appointed a new Offender Outcomes Manager for Relationships who is about to take up post."That sounds to me like social work, which local government also organises. I wonder whether there is any linkage of work as opposed to resources being duplicated. We have received vague, waffling answers to most of the specific questions that were posed.There could be a systemic problem. I thought that the NHS was riddled with jargon and acronyms, but its use of those is nothing compared with that in the answers that we have received. I hope that the Justice Committee will take that into account and try to do something about it.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Notwithstanding, an attempt has been made to answer questions about fairly complicated issues. I accept what you say about jargon. The public sector often uses jargon when it tries to describe things, but it is clear that there has been an attempt to focus more on policy issues.You are right. Closer co-operation between social workers and the Scottish Prison Service is needed, and the community justice authorities should attempt to encourage that.The committee has done its bit in the audit process. It is now a matter of passing the report and the response on.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I assumed that jargon and terms such as "proactively", "on an on-going basis", and "Cognisance is also taken" came from Robert Gordon and the facts came from Mike Ewart.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

That might be unfair. All civil servants are pretty well versed in the school of jargon.

Andrew Welsh SNP Angus
link

Policy issues are for policy committees, but it is difficult to consider policy if the answers to questions are vague. Under the straightforward heading:"Assess the effectiveness of HDC in achieving its objectives",the response is that there is an"intention to carry out a review of the Home Detention Curfew Scheme when HM Prison Addiewell is operational in 2009.Since introduction in July 2006 over 4000 prisoners have been released on Home Detention Curfew. 25% of prisoners have been recalled to custody, the vast majority for breach of their curfew terms; less than 1% are recalled for alleged reoffending7.1% of recalled prisoners appeal to the Parole Board for Scotland against their recall to custody. Of that number 60.6% of those appeals against recall are successful."It should not take long to assess that. There is vague and unhelpful thinking in response to a specific question. That points to a systemic problem, which I hope the appropriate committee will investigate and do something about.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

I note the points that you have made, but I think that some of those issues are on the policy agenda.

Mr Black
link

I will provide a little assistance to the committee by linking some of the numbers together, which is what we do best. In "Managing increasing prisoner numbers in Scotland", we mentioned the last projections of prisoner numbers that the Government had. At that time—it was 2007—the Government projected that the number, including home detention curfew prisoners, would reach 8,100 by 2010-11 and 8,500 by 2016-17.In a fairly comprehensive response, we are told that the Prison Service has judged the assessed operational limit, which is the safe limit, to be 8,126. According to the coverage given to Mike Ewart's recent statements, the prison population has now reached 8,137. The point is that, not by 2010 but by 2008, we are over the edge of the assessed operational and safe limit as identified by the chief executive of the Prison Service. That reflects the seriousness of the situation as Mike Ewart sees it. For that reason, I strongly support your inclination to draw the Justice Committee's attention to the report.

Andrew Welsh SNP Angus
link

It is clear that prisons are overcrowded and that there is a massive accommodation problem. If open prisons are to be used to house prisoners because of overcrowding elsewhere in the system, where does that leave the concept of open prisons? That leads me to ask the simple question: what are prisons for? I hope that the appropriate committee will pursue that.

Hugh Henry Lab The Convener · Paisley South
link

Fortunately, that is not a question for us. Others can wrestle with it. Do we agree to note the responses and pass the report to the Justice Committee for its consideration?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Wednesday 24 September 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 3
  3. Section 23 Report Committee business · 36
  4. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  5. Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 12
  6. Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 9
  7. Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 6
  8. Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 1
  9. Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 1
  10. “National Fraud Initiative in Scotland 2006/07” (Government Response) Committee business · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.