Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Ferry Services

Tuesday 7 January 2025 Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee About 09:15–11:00 Evidence session 322 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

322 contributions · showing 1–200
Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Our second item of business is an evidence session on ferry services in Scotland. Today’s session is part of the committee’s rolling scrutiny of ferry services, which will be continued over the rest of this parliamentary session.

I welcome representatives from Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd: Kevin Hobbs, chief executive officer, and Jim Anderson, director of vessels. We go straight into questions, and I will ask the first of those. Can you confirm that the Glen Sannox met all the contract specifications that were agreed when it was originally ordered?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Sorry, I have a bit of a throat.

The two main contract requirements are speed and dead weight. The speed was achieved during the owner’s sea trials, and the dead weight was reduced from the original contract dead weight.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

As I understand it, the speed was 16.5 knots minimum at 87 per cent of maximum revolutions per minute.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

That is correct.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

That was achieved.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Was that achieved by reducing the dead weight?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

No, no. The ship itself performed at that speed. The ship was heavier than was originally estimated, which reduces the available dead weight.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So the ship was heavier than it was supposed to be?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Yes.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We lost about 90 tonnes. I will come back with the right figure.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

In the contract, a fine is leviable on the constructor if the ship does not meet the weight requirements—is that right?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Yes.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

What would the fine have been for a 90-tonne—

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I will have to refer back to the contract, but I can do that; I can probably look at the contract while I am here. We have to remember that, obviously, the contract was with the Scottish Government and the yard at that stage, but I can check what the liquidated damages were.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Had it reached the stage at which the ferry could have been rejected?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I would have to check that, convener, if it is okay just to check the figures, because it was probably right on that point. If you will allow me, I can go back and check that for you.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. I am slightly concerned that the ship seems to be heavier. Fines would have been imposed on any other shipyard. Surely, as well, if it is heavier, it will use more fuel, will it not?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Slightly—sorry about my throat—slightly more fuel.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It will use more fuel. When you say “slightly more fuel”, Jim, do you want to be—I mean, I know if I load my car up with—

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I do not want to throw out figures here without referring to the data from the sea trials, which I would have to look at to see what that difference in dead weight is compared with fuel and power. I am happy to come back to you on that.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It would be helpful to understand, if the ferry was plying to Arran, how much extra fuel it would need on each trip as a result of that, because that would give us an idea of the cost per trip, and you could probably work out the cost per year in extra fuel as a result of the ship being heavier—and the extra emissions.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

It is important to note that the dead weight requirement that was set was set for the toughest conditions for carrying maximum freight. The actual dead weight that was achieved was around 791 tonnes. I am sure that that was achieved, but I will check that figure. That is for a fully laden vessel, full of heavy goods vehicles, for the toughest conditions, carrying maximum vehicles, whereas that ship on that route will carry mainly commercial vehicles and a mix of cars. The actual required dead weight for the service is much less than 791 tonnes, if that makes sense.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It sort of makes sense, but it does not make sense, because you reduced the passenger numbers, did you not, as a requirement of—

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

—the Maritime and Coastguard Agency—

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Well, as a contract variation, then as a requirement of the MCA, did you not decrease passenger numbers?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Yes, we did; there were additional staircases.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It was for 1,000 passengers originally, and that went down to—

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Eight hundred and fifty-two.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So we lost nearly 150 passengers—148 passengers. What about the vehicles? That number was 127 including HGVs, was it not?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

The vehicle deck dimensions remained the same from when the contract was signed so, basically, the space that was available for the vehicles remained the same.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So there was no change in that.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

No change.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. Just looking at it from the outside, I am a little confused that we have ended up with a ferry that was not as originally specified but has just been accepted in. Whose agreement was it just to accept what was delivered? Was that yours, or was it the Scottish Government’s?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

That is a joint agreement based on the operational conditions for the ship. The dead weight was set at what we call the design draught of 3.45m, but the ship can operate at 3.7m draught, so the actual available dead weight is actually much greater than 791 tonnes. If operating at a deeper draught in the water, we can carry even more than 791 tonnes, so we do not have any concerns about the operation of the ship and its ability to carry the full payloads of HGVs.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Hold on, now you are adding another dimension. Just tell me this: the ship sits deeper in the water—is that right?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

No, it does not sit deeper in the water. The ship is designed so that it can sit deeper in the water.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

The contract said it was to be 3.45m. What is it?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

It is 3.45m, which gives the 791 tonnes, which was reduced from the contract figure of eight hundred and something—whatever it was.

The original requirement for the ship was a 3.45m draught, which is normal operation, but the ship is capable of operating at a 3.7m draught. That is quite normal for most contracts—it is the same even for the Islay vessels. You have a service requirement and then you have an even deeper draught that allows you to carry more dead weight. However, as you rightly say, if you carry more dead weight, there is a slight penalty when it comes to fuel.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Does 3.7m allow you to enter all the harbours that the ferry could be used at?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Not all of the harbours. The maximum draught was mainly for operating as a freight one on the Stornoway to Ullapool route, so that was why the requirements were set for a greater draught.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Basically, the 3.45m was born of Ardrossan. When CMAL and some of the other stakeholder councils are redeveloping ports at the moment, we are going for deeper ports to try to get them to modern standards, as I am sure you are aware, including for Uig to Tarbert, Harris. As it stands, the 3.45m was the limit to be able to operate the Glen Sannox into Ardrossan at every state of tide, whether neap tide or spring tide. However, as Jim Anderson says, if you are operating to a port that is deeper, the vessel can carry well over 1,000 tonnes of payload.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I will go back to the original question. From what you said, Jim, the ferry did not meet the original specifications that were laid out when it was supposed to be built.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

For the dead weight, yes.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Which is quite a critical thing, I would suggest. Who made the decision to accept that ferry with that built into it? Was it CMAL, Transport Scotland or the Scottish Government?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

That was a joint decision that we made at the regular meetings that we have, where we discuss all aspects of the project.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Who made the joint decision? Us, the operators in CalMac Ferries Ltd, along with the strategic commercial assets division team, Transport Scotland and so on. It is all the same people who attend the room.

From an operational point of view, the ship meets its requirements with that 791 tonnes of dead weight. When you sign a contract for those ships, you always allow a certain margin for all of that, because it is the most critical area of a ship’s design anywhere you go on the planet—it is about getting good control of that weight. A certain margin is always built into that.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I understand that, which is why the penalties are £5,000—or a certain number of pounds per tonne that is over, as I understand it. However, I am trying to work out whether, if the ferry had been built by anyone other than Ferguson Marine, those penalties would have been imposed.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

All contracts are taken on a case-by-case basis.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So, maybe, maybe not. I am not sure that I am any clearer on that, so I might have to come back to you.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I have some very brief questions on the same front. The dead weight of 791 tonnes was the target in the contract. Is that correct?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

That was less than the contract; the contract figure was 800 and something. I will refer to the contract in a minute.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

You are just going to check whether that was within the flexibility in the margins.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Yes.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

If that is the case, it would be within the specification in the original contract. We do not know that yet, but you will check on that this morning, is what you are saying to me.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Sorry, say that again.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

If a dead weight of 791 tonnes was within the permitted flexibility, it would have met the contract specifications as originally outlined, because built into that was a degree of flexibility. Is that correct?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

The 791 did not meet the contract specification. However, from an operational point of view, it was more than enough. The contract specification was set slightly higher.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Is it correct that the contract did not have within it a tolerance level and that it had to be on the nose?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Yes. When we say we made a decision jointly, we did make a decision jointly, which was off the back of knowing what that particular route needed.

If we pull a silly figure from out of the air that the dead weight was to be 200 tonnes, the ship would have been rejected, because it would not carry anywhere near what it needed to carry.

However, when you look at the heat maps of what is carried to Arran by any of the ships today or any that are likely to be required in the future, the 791 tonnes would still meet the requirement for that ship to be fully laden and still be within 3.45m.

09:30

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Is that on the basis of the routes that the ship is intended to operate on?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Correct. However, if it goes to another port—let us say, as Jim has mentioned, on the Ullapool to Stornoway route—the ship can have a draught of 3.7m. The original spec said that the vessel could carry 1,271 tonnes, and we would be about 90 tonnes short of that. There is plenty of margin within the ship to carry what it needs to carry on the routes that it is going to operate on.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I will ask the question another way, as those just become numbers. All I want to know is that the ship is being delivered now—

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Correct.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

It is at variance from the original specifications.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Yes.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I would like to know where the restrictions are and where the ship can now be used. Are there more limitations on those vessels because of the current specifications, rather than the specifications that were set in the original contract? I am happy to get those details in writing but, ultimately, that is just numbers, and numbers alone are meaningless. What is meaningful is whether or not those two vessels can now technically do less if, at some point in the future, they were to be redeployed elsewhere to do other tasks.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

In broad terms, a 90-tonne reduction in dead weight equates to two articulated, fully laden lorries. How you can operate depends on which port you go in to and how deep that port is.

Broadly, what we are saying is that, for the purposes of the ship being delivered and for the route that it is going to be on for the majority of the time or the alternative routes that it may be deployed on from time to time as a cascade, it will do what is necessary. It will carry what is required.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

That is helpful, but I ask you to reflect on the basic point that I am making. Unless this is their bread and butter or their business, anyone listening to this meeting just wants to know whether the two vessels will be less effective on their current routes. We have a clear expectation that that will not be the case and that they will do exactly as was always intended, but they could be redeployed for other purposes within the fleet at some point in the future. Are there more restrictions on what they can or cannot do because of the variation in specifications?

Mr Hobbs said that there will technically be two fewer articulated lorries. That explanation becomes meaningful to someone, rather than the numbers that are flying about. It would be helpful if, either here this morning or in writing, we could get a meaningful explanation on that because, quite frankly, most people are just hearing gobbledygook. That would be helpful.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I can give some figures. Take an HGV, fully loaded—44 tonnes is the maximum that is permitted. If we take 14 times 44 tonnes, that gives us 616 tonnes. If we had 14 fully loaded HGVs on the ship, and the availability is 791 tonnes, we would have 791 tonnes minus 616 tonnes, which gives you the additional dead weight for your stores, your fuel and so on. From an operational point of view, we are more than comfortable with the 791 number.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Okay. I do not want to pursue that any further other than to ask a more general question, which is not related to dead weight. After signing contracts for vessels to be delivered, is it normal or routine that those who win those contracts will, at some point during the construction phase, approach their partner and say, “We believe that there is a case for a contract specification variation,” and then seek agreement with those who have given them the contract in the first place? Is that unusual or is it routine?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

It is not unusual to have amendments to contracts in a shipbuilding contract.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Can you say a bit more about when that has happened in the past?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

There could be change orders where you perhaps have had a change of equipment, so that the weight could grow naturally. If there is some added item on the ship—a winch or something like that—there might be a 10-tonne penalty. When you look at any change order for a ship, whatever that might be, there could be a time aspect for the yard to do some additional work. There could be a weight concern or a weight penalty that we would also have to consider. That is why, when you set your dead weight requirements, you always make sure that you have some margin.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Okay. I have no further questions. However, when we are having an exchange in the future, I urge you to make it meaningful to members of the public. For example, saying that there could be two less fully-laden articulated lorries on one of those vessels at another port, if it was deployed elsewhere, and that, in the context, that is pretty minimal would be helpful, because, with the numbers that are flying about, it looks as though this is way off course in terms of the dead weight. Again, it would be helpful to have something in writing that puts that in plain speech rather than doublespeak.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

What everybody needs to know is that the operator, us as CMAL and the Government more widely had a discussion about whether it was acceptable, and it is acceptable for that route. It will have no negative effect on what can be carried on that ship on the primary route.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

That is good to hear, and that is not lost on me. I had supplementary questions because we just had numbers flying about, which became meaningless to me, quite frankly.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

It is not a simple, straightforward subject matter. That is why people study naval architecture.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Jim Anderson, to save you looking it all up, I think that I have the figures to hand. The vessel was meant to have a dead weight of 878 tonnes, with a tolerance of 10 tonnes. There were penalties of £5,000 per tonne for falling below that weight, up to a maximum of £250,000, which would have meant that it was 50 tonnes below the weight, down to 818 tonnes. At that point, the boat should have been cancelled, according to the original contract, because it did not meet the specification.

What I was trying to drive at is that the boat can carry less than was originally agreed—less than the contract was set up for—which means that it is not doing what it was expected to achieve. That, therefore, raises the question of whether you have value for money, in my mind—especially now, as you can have fewer passengers and fewer vehicles. It appears to me that we have ended up with a boat that does not meet the original contract, however it has panned out. We have not got what we paid for, and we paid considerably more than we thought we were going to have to pay. To me, the whole thing seems to be a complete confusion. I am going to leave it there, because I think that I have made my point.

Kevin Hobbs, I think that you specifically asked for the anchor chain to be retested during the trials—unless I have got that wrong. Interruption. I am being told that it was Jim Anderson who asked for it, so my knowledge of that was wrong.

Jim, you asked for the anchor chain to be retested, and there was going to be a quick fix, which would allow it to be workable by February this year, which is after it goes into service. We were told that anchor chains are not that vital but that they are part of a safety feature. Has it been fixed or will it be fixed before the vessel starts carrying passengers?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I hope that I can clear this up. During the first builder trial—the builder being Ferguson—the ship was taken out to sea before the final outfitting was done, to demonstrate that the propulsion system was working. That was a great thing to do after all those years, and it was really successful. At that point, nothing was formally presented, but this then happened during the owner trials, just recently, towards the end of the year. The anchors were lowered during the first sea trial, which was in February if I remember rightly. What we are interested in is whether we can safely lower the anchors if we have to do that for whatever reason. Some issues were observed when we were retrieving the anchors at the time—nothing too great—but, by the time that we got to the owner sea trial, we could see that the anchor chain was slipping more and more. Therefore, it was identified that we had to make a modification to the system.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

It will be modified. The update that I got just yesterday was that that will be in early February. We do not have the actual date yet, but early February is when the gypsies will arrive. As soon as we have the definitive date for that, we will plan the best time to carry out that work, alongside CalMac from the operations point of view.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. I think that the latest that we have heard is that, subject to the toilets being fixed, the vessel will come into use on 13 January. It will then have to come out of service again to get the anchor fixed. How long does that take?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I asked that question yesterday. I am not quite sure, but I would put that kind of job at about two days.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It would be helpful to know how long it will take, so that people know what is coming down the chain to them. If you asked that question yesterday, you would not be surprised that I asked it today.

Douglas Lumsden will ask the next question.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

I want to ask about warranties on the Glen Sannox components. I presume that most of those components are now out of warranty, because they were ordered a long time ago. Is that correct? How would warranties normally work, and how will claims be handled in relation to Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

As you rightly point out, the majority of the warranties for the components on the vessel are out of date, because the vessel was built over a period of nine years as opposed to two-and-a-half or three years.

Effectively, there is an overarching warranty on all shipbuilding contracts given by the shipyard, which means that the shipyard effectively stands over any warranty issues. Normally, if a component part breaks and is under warranty, the shipyard will go to the manufacturer and ask for it to be replaced or repaired. In this instance, it would be up to Ferguson’s to effect that repair, because the warranties are now out of date. Ferguson’s has to stand over the warranty of the physical build—the physical hull and the way it has been built—which is the same in any shipbuilding contract, but warranties for the component parts within the ship, which would ordinarily run for six or 12 months after first being used in service, have lapsed.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

Even though the parts have not really been used in service, they have still lapsed.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Correct.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

How long would the manufacturer normally allow for them to be delivered and then brought into service?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

When the procurement team in a shipyard places the orders, it specifies to the original manufacturer when it anticipates that the ship will be in service. In this case, that would have been about three years after the contract was signed, in October 2015. Ordinarily, you would have a six or 12-month warranty after the ship entered service, but the fact that the build took another six years on top of that means that, in the main, the warranties have lapsed.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

I presume that that is the same for both vessels.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

It is even worse for the Glen Rosa, because its build will probably take 10 years.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

Have any parts been taken from the Glen Rosa and used on the Glen Sannox?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I do not have a definitive list, but that has happened. It would happen with a normal contract, too.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

Have those parts all been replaced on the Glen Rosa?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

The Ferguson’s procurement team has the replacement of those parts in hand.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

There are not hundreds and hundreds of parts that have gone wrong. By any stretch of the imagination, you could not say that the Glen Rosa has been denuded of all of its equipment. It is just the odd piece of machinery that has not worked properly. Instead of waiting for the manufacturer to manufacture a new piece, it makes sense to transfer a serviceable component from the other ship, so that that vessel can enter service as quickly as it can.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

The key components that are under warranty are probably the propulsion system and the liquefied natural gas system—obviously, they are both the same thing.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

There are warranties against almost everything: pumps and so on—you name it.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

Is there anything that is obsolete in these vessels now, because of the time that the build has taken, which it might be hard to get replacements for?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

An exercise was carried out to look at what was considered to be obsolete in the way of bridge equipment, which tends to be more software-related stuff rather than a pump or an engine. As you know, electronic systems tend to have a certain shelf life. That is the world that we are living in—after five or 10 years, manufacturers change something and bring in something new.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

So, components have had to be changed, even though they have not been used, because they are obsolete already.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

As I said, an exercise was carried out to look at what was considered to be obsolete. The obsolete elements were mainly bridge equipment.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Monica Lennon will ask the next question.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Good morning. We were recently told by Ferguson’s that it cannot provide a final cost or delivery date for the Glen Rosa. After all this time, how can it possibly be the case that those details are still up in the air?

09:45

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

There have been a lot of changes in the yard over the past few years, as everyone in the room is well aware. Last year, a new project management team was put in place, and a new planning team was put in place towards the end of last year.

I and the tripartite group have been asking when we can get sight of the plans for how the lessons learned from the Glen Sannox can be applied to the Glen Rosa and we can be provided with some established norms that demonstrate to us and all parties how the shipyard is going to execute those plans. At the moment, we do not have sight of those plans. We have been promised them by the end of this month, but at the moment we do not have them, so there is nothing that we can use to measure the yard’s efficiencies, if you want to put it that way, as we go forward.

The new planning team came into place towards the end of last year and a new project manager took over in quarter 1 or quarter 2 of last year, so there has been a bit of a revolving door in the business.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Are you feeling confident? It seems to me that you do not sound confident.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Am I feeling confident about what? Do you mean about being able to deliver the ship?

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I am asking whether you are confident about delivery. From what you have said and what we have heard, it is unclear when CMAL expects the Glen Rosa to be delivered and at what cost. Are you able to give an update or any clarity on that?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Until we get sight of a plan from the shipyard, we will not be able to measure how it is going to execute that plan.

Let us take the length of cables that need to be installed in the ship, which is a simple thing that we can measure. We know that around 260km or 270km of cable will need to be installed. We need to see some clear evidence on the strike rates that the yard will achieve on the installation of cables, pipe systems and so on. That means that we need to see the plans. If, say, 250km of cable has to be installed, there has to be a strike rate every week and every month for how much the yard can install and how much it can terminate. As yet, we do not have those plans to comment on. We are expecting to have them by the end of this month.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

At the end of the month—I think that we were told that we would have them by 31 January. I think that that was also in the letter to the committee.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Okay, so nothing has changed. Are you confident that the plans will be published at that time?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I cannot say that for sure at the moment.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

That is a pity. I will hand back to the convener.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Can you clarify something for me? Who is the client? Is it CMAL, Transport Scotland or the Scottish Government?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

The Scottish Government—SCAD.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Scottish Government economy took over the contract from us in December 2019, which was when Ferguson Marine (Port Glasgow) was incorporated as a company.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So, you are just a passenger on this journey.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We would like to think that we are more than passengers, to be honest.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Well, what you are saying is that the Scottish Government has the ultimate say. You do not know the details because you do not have them. If I was the client and I was buying a ship under a normal contract, I would make absolutely sure that people reported to me so that I knew exactly what was happening with the £150 million that I had invested—at the end of the day, that is what will be invested in the Glen Rosa. It appears to me that you are not in that position. I am trying to work out what role CMAL has. I asked that question when I was on the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, and I am posing further questions on the issue now.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We are still directly involved. We have the same management system and relationship in place as we do for the four ships that are under construction in the Cemre Shipyard in Turkey. The only thing that is different is that we do not own the contract. However, we still have eyes on the ground, and we are still supervising, inspecting and producing patrol remarks, owner observation reports and so on. It is the same system. We are still the people who ask the shipyard technical questions about the plans and provide a level of technical know-how.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

So, you are not an arm’s-length organisation; you are a feature on the arm’s-length organisation.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We are directly involved.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We are directly involved.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

From day 1 of the new world of Ferguson Marine (Port Glasgow), we have been effectively contracted by the SCAD team, which is part of Scottish Government economy, to be its eyes and ears on the ground, because neither that division nor, indeed, Transport Scotland, has people who build ships. That is why we exist.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I hear that, but in 2006 or thereabouts, when CMAL was set up, it was meant to be an arm’s-length organisation to organise the ships. It now appears that you have been subsumed as part of the arm of the Government, which questions the whole issue of why CMAL was set up.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Only on that contract.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Only on that contract? But you have just said that it is the same for the Turkish ones.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

No, I said that how we go about our business is the same and that the only other thing is that we do not own the contract.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We are the contracting party for all other ships but not for that ship, because of the circumstances in which that shipyard found itself.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. That is even more confusing.

The next question will be from Bob Doris.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Oh, it is back to me again.

If we look at the small vessels replacement programme, there is around £185 million wrapped up in phase 1. Six bidders came forward for that, and I guess that those bids are currently being considered. We are keen to know how those bids will be assessed and the criteria that will be used. For example, what weight will be given to factors such as price—in other words, the reliability of what the overall cost will be to the public purse—and the quality of the bids. Quality is a very subjective word. I am keen to know a bit more about how a bid will become successful on the basis of price and quality and about other criteria that may lead to the final outcome of the contract—or contracts—being awarded.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I will start and then I will hand over to Jim, if that is okay.

As you know, the small vessels replacement programme involves seven small vessels being replaced. That is phase 1. There is a phase 2, which involves another three vessels and is not out for bidding at the moment. We follow the procurement rules that Scotland has in place, and we go through the Public Contracts Scotland tender process. That is a two-phase process for these particular vessels. So, you have an SPDS, which in old money is a PQQ, and that was—

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Sorry, but TLAs are great if you understand what the acronym means. Could you talk in full terms?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Okay. Let us boil it down. Basically, there are two phases to the bid. The first is a pre-qualification. We go out internationally and ask shipyards to show interest, and we have a pro forma that they fill out.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Has that been done? I am told that you invited six to bid.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

That was done. There was a lot of interest in terms of people opening the document, but, ultimately, at pre-qualification, we received 13 compliant bids. We narrowed that down to six, which is where we are now, and we invited those six shipyards to tender the ITT. The ITT return date is—

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

What is the ITT? As it is the first time you have used the term, could you—

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Invitation to tender.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

The invitation to tender return date is 24 January 2025. At this point in time, the activity going on within the PCS tender website is the six shipyards that are involved asking us general and technical questions prior to them formally putting their bids in on 24 January. From 24 January, that is when the assessment starts.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

That is context, because, although we may not have known the acronyms, we kind of knew the amount. It is more about how price, quality and other criteria are considered once those bids are finalised and put in for consideration.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

The figure of £185 million was mentioned. Just be aware that that is not all to do with the ships—that is the overall contract. There are also some modifications to some of the ports and there is the need to attain the right amount of electrical capacity at the ports to be able to charge the vessels overnight, so there are three distinct elements within that £185 million figure.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

That is really helpful. Thank you.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

For the invitation to tender, or the ITT, the quality aspects of the tender make up 60 per cent. I will just check my figures—yes, the quality part is 60 per cent and the commercial part is 40 per cent. Within the quality part, we set the shipyards a whole host of questions to provide us with information in the tender response that we then evaluate. There is a big, long list. I do not think that you want to hear me read out every single question, but a huge part of it is about looking at the quality of the bid, the shipyards’ capabilities, their resources, their project management plans and all that kind of stuff.

With these ships all being electric vessels, the bulk will be in the equipment that is going on them. The steel is relatively straightforward. I do not know whether anybody is familiar with the small vessels that go to the likes of Millport and all the rest of it, but they are small ships. The steel is pretty much the smallest part of the whole price of the ship, whereas the biggest part will be in the propulsion, the battery systems and so on. That will form a significant part of our evaluation. We call them the makers, and the maker’s performance and the maker’s specification is a huge part of our evaluation. All the other things that we have been discussing so far, performance-wise—the speed, the power and the dead weight—will be evaluated.

In response to our ITT, the shipyards say, “This is the type of ship that we would propose for you, and here are the levels of performance, the type of equipment and the levels of service and support that we can provide.” There are a whole host of questions that we ask from a quality point of view.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I will be careful with my next question on quality, because every bidder must be dealt with consistently and equitably as part of the process.

In relation to quality, a bid on paper can be very different from what is delivered in the shipyard. In relation to the demand to build, is phase 1 of the small vessels programme more straightforward, given the other questions that we have been asking about other ships under contract? Does the track record of individual shipyards in delivering such vessels in the past come into play when determining who wins an award? Also, how can you compare the bidders when two of the bidders have never bid for work with you guys before—so they are new entrants from your point of view—while the other four bidders have an on-going relationship with you?

How do you balance the quality on paper with what the quality will be on delivery? Anyone can put on paper that the vessel or vessels will be good quality, but it is delivery that counts, within the cost envelope. How do you disaggregate that when determining quality?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We have a lot of market knowledge and we know a lot of people in the business. That is taken care of at the first stage that Kevin Hobbs described—the single procurement document, which is the old pre-qualification questionnaire.

At the first stage, when we selected the six bidders, we satisfied ourselves that, based on the information that the six bidders gave us and the types of smaller vessels that they have delivered in the past, they have the experience and capability to build those smaller types of ships for us.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Also, during the invitation to tender period, Jim Anderson and I have visited each of the six shipyards to assess their capabilities. As you rightly say, Mr Doris, what is put down on paper might not be what is there in reality, so we have visited every single shipyard. It is a bit bizarre to walk across the road to a shipyard that you are currently building ships in, but we have been to Cammell Laird in Liverpool and even to Asenav in Chile.

We have visited each of the shipyards and spent between a day and two days assessing their onsite capabilities, looking at the projects that they are currently doing and witnessing the quality of the work that they are doing for others.

10:00

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Just to be clear, a significant hurdle has already been passed by all six bidders that are still in the game, so to speak—those that are about to put in finalised bids.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Yes.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

So, you are comparing the quality of all six bids, but your belief is that all six bids will be of high quality. Then you have to determine what is best for the public purse.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Yes.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I have a final question about that. All the bidders will want to make sure that they are fairly treated. There will be a lot of commercial confidentiality in relation to each of the bids, because quality relates to the overall financial cost of the bid that they will put in. Are all the bidders getting equal access to all the data, the information, the paperwork—all the things that I can only imagine are really important—to the nth degree to the same extent as one another, so that it is a fair, open and transparent process?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Nobody has been given any special reliance on that. Basically, there is a package that goes out in the invitation to tender, which everybody gets—it is exactly the same. When questions are asked on the PCS tender framework, they are visible to all bidders, so that everyone is not asking the same question all the time. If a bidder turns up on day 1 and starts asking about how we want them to deliver the vessels because they are remote from Scotland, or stuff like that, that is very clearly visible, and everybody can see the answers that we give.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Even at this late stage, if I was acting on behalf of one of the bidders, and I was seeking additional information from you, I could request it, but the answer would be given to all six bidders. Is that right?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

It would be broadcast, yes.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We have a series of supplementary questions on that subject. I will turn to the deputy convener, Michael Matheson, first.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Good morning. Jim Anderson, I was struck by the point that you made about the small vessels. Given that they are all going to have electric powered propulsion, you said that the real technical aspect is around the battery systems and the electrics that will go with them. Do you specify that as part of the bidding process, or does each of the bidders come forward with their own proposals on how they will deliver it within the vessel specification?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We do not specify any particular makers. We set a performance level in the specification for what the ship must achieve every day. We give all the information to all the bidders about the seven vessels, the routes that they will operate on and information on those routes—the time at port and when the vessels will be under way at full speed. The bidders go away with that information and then they design a ship and work out what the energy requirements for that ship will be.

We have already done some work, so we know where the specification should sit, but we ask the bidders to tell us about the ship that they would deliver for us. For this type of ship, it is all about the energy consumption on board the ship. All the bidders go away and look at that, and calculate how much energy they have to install in the ship—that equates to batteries. They then have to think about the type of batteries that they will propose to us—to CMAL and CalMac—that will perform for us over the 10-year lifetime of the ship. So it is for the yards to come back with their proposals to us.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

How well established in the United Kingdom or the international market is the construction of electrical powered small vessels of this nature?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

It is very well established now. Away back in time, we had the early experience of the three hybrid vessels: it was 2009 when we embarked on that project. We got a lot of information from the hybrids—they were not fully electric, but they had a battery element. There are now many ships of this type and size that are all-electric, so the technology is well proven now.

I have to remind everybody that there is a price to be paid for all the new technologies that we are looking to use to reduce our energy and carbon emissions. In the case of the batteries, everything now has a lifetime. That is the kind of world that we all live in now. If you maintained it, an old internal combustion engine would last for 30-odd years. Now, these kinds of technologies are forever changing, and we just have to accept that.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

With the Glen Sannox and the Glen Rosa, we had the issues with LNG, new technologies being reviewed and so on. Is it your view that there is a well-established international market for electric propulsion vessels of this size and that there is good international benchmarking on what we need to do to ensure that the vessels work and are operationally effective? From your knowledge of assessing that, are you confident that you have that information and that the yards should be able to bid for contracts with a good grounding of operational information from vessels of this nature that are already operating?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

The broad answer is yes. As Jim Anderson mentioned, the MV Hallaig, the MV Lochinvar and the MV Catriona were hybrids. Unfortunately, we have been overtaken by many fully electric ships in places such as Norway, Sweden and Denmark, so it is a well-known technology. In fact, as a clarification, despite what you probably heard at the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee and in other areas, LNG is not a new technology, either. Thousands of LNG engines and ships were in operation when the contract was signed in 2015, but there has been a narrative—which, I am sure, you are very aware of—that says, “Well, this is completely new technology, so it is really difficult and really hard.” That is simply not the case. We are not groundbreaking in terms of LNG or battery-operated vessels.

There has been one learning that has come out of what has happened in Norway. The first fully electric ship was called the MV Ampere, which had some sisters. To provide a bit of context, I note that those were electric-only vessels. Where Norway has gone and where we are going is that there will be a small diesel generator on board, because island communities rely on daily services and we are worried about power outages. If there are power outages—which there are from time to time in remote areas—we cannot have a situation in which the crew turn up in the morning to the batteries not having been powered up because there has been a power failure, a storm or whatever. In the context of this particular project, there is an element of diesel, but it will be used only in extreme circumstances when, on a given day, the lifeline ferry service would fail if the power to the vessel overnight had failed.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

That seems a sensible approach to take, particularly if that is the lesson that has been learned from the situation in Norway.

On your point about LNG, it is also my understanding that it is not a new technology. It might have been a new technology to some of the people who installed it at that particular point, but it was not a new technology in shipping in general. That is helpful.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

I will move slightly away from that issue. Mr Hobbs, you mentioned the fact that improvements at harbours will be needed to allow the use of the new technologies, but improvements at harbours will also be needed to ensure that there is shore-to-ship power for diesel vessels. Will you give us an indication of how the project in Aberdeen with NorthLink Ferries is going?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Very well. We initiated a project about a year and a half ago. One of the big challenges with regard to power is the grid itself; it is not necessarily the technology around it. Broadly, you have to have power at the port, so you need to get cables to the location where the ship will be charged. You then need a bunch of transformers to get the power into an energy that the ship can accept, and, because of the increased energy that is needed compared with our original diesel-electric hybrids, you also need cable management systems at the ports.

As far as Aberdeen is concerned, the power is available at the port side. That has been done. The transformers are there, although they are still waiting for some small items. The piece that is not there at the moment, but which will be delivered during January, is the cable management system, which handles the cables to offer them up to the ship so that the ship can connect.

I was with the team up in Aberdeen the week before Christmas, and we are hoping that we will have a fully functioning shore-side power connection by no later than Easter of this year.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

That sounds like good news. The other projects that are at an early stage include the replacement for the two northern isles freight vessels. Can you tell us what stage that project is at, because it is obviously extremely important for Orkney and Shetland?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We should have all the final concept design ready to go within this month. We have to populate the outline business case, and that will be done within quarter 1 of this year. In the latest budget, although I accept that the Parliament has not passed it yet, money has been set aside for us to initiate that project. We have internal discussions—we had them yesterday, actually—and we would need to go out to tender no later than June of this year to achieve a contract award by March of 2026, or within the next financial year. We are ready to go.

We are talking to Aberdeen harbour, we are talking to Lerwick and we are also talking to the operator, so everything is connected.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

That is another good reason to vote for the budget, I would say.

Some of the most put-upon folk in recent times because of ferry movements for repairs have been the folk in Uist, particularly those at Lochboisdale with the MV Lord of the Isles. A replacement is also due for that. What stage is that at, please, Mr Hobbs? Can you offer any good news for folk in Uist?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Again, the outline business case has to be finalised, but the actual concept design was finished in December. The outline business case will run more or less in parallel with how I have described the northern isles freighter flex vessels. That is basically ready to go.

With any of those projects, there are three elements to consider: port A, port B and the ship in between. We have the concept design ready. Some restrictions and changes are required for the MV Lord of the Isles replacement because there is a restriction at Mallaig that means that our common platform of ship, which is the Islay ship, will not fit into Mallaig. It is 95m long and the concept design is for an 85m-long ship. We are talking with Mallaig as we speak and we will carry out a ground investigation this year and make the detailed design to replace the Lochboisdale facility, which is nearing life expiry, and relocate it to a small island called Gasay, which is just opposite the Lochboisdale facility.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Sorry, Mr Stewart, I will certainly let you ask your final question, but just be careful. You have already stood on the toes of a couple of members who wanted to ask the questions that you have asked out of sequence, which is not clever. I will let you go on with the next question.

Kevin Stewart SNP Aberdeen Central
link

Will the MV Glen Rosa and the MV Glen Sannox provide better services for the people of Arran compared to the current situation with the MV Caledonian Isles and the MV Alfred? Are they better ferries?

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

They are much better ferries, and I think that people will appreciate that once they come into operation next week. Teaming up the MV Glen Rosa with the MV Glen Sannox was not the original plan of course, but that is what is going to happen and it means that the capacity is increasing. The one area that is still not resolved is the redevelopment of Ardrossan. That is the outlier in that project.

10:15

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I want to ask about phase 2 of the small vessel replacement programme, which was recently launched by CMAL. Can you outline the key stages of the process and any timelines and details, as well as the expected budget requirement?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

If you go to our website, you will see that we are going to carry out a series of public engagement events near the Sound of Barra and the Sound of Harris in the week commencing 20 January, when we will be kicking off more formally. That will be the start of the project. Our internal planning has us completing all the work—gathering information on service requirements, service needs, and so on, which will lead to a concept design and a business case—by the end of the year. From then, we will be looking at what the available funding might be.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

At the moment, the funding for the small vessel replacement programme is not in place. As I said earlier, there is white smoke for the northern isles freighter flex vessels, the MV Lord of the Isles and some port projects, which have been brought forward from the next, say, five years. The programme was due to start on 1 April 2026, but it has been brought forward into 2025. If the budget is passed, those projects will go ahead. The small vessel replacement programme is logically outside that, because we will not be ready to go out to tender until the financial year that will start on 1 April 2026.

We will be pushing hard for any of our projects for which concept designs are in place, and for which we want to present outline business cases, to be the prompt for the money to be available—or not, as the case may be. As the asset-owning agency, we push every day of the week to get as much money as we can to replace the current fleet and upgrade the harbours.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

What kind of estimates are you working to? I appreciate that you are still at a very early stage with the concept and building the business case, but could you give a rough idea of the budget requirement and put a figure on that?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We would really like to have the business case completed by the end of this year. If funding is available, that would allow us to move into the procurement phase, which typically takes 10 to 12 months. That would take us towards the end of 2026 before we could be in a position to put in place a contract.

At the moment, from a budgeting point of view, we are looking at somewhere in the region of £60 million for phase 2 for the vessels. We still have some work to do, because we are just commencing with phase 2, on what the shore infrastructure costs might be for the shore power for the routes. We are really just kicking off, but the cost for the vessels is in that kind of area.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I imagine that we do not have the numbers for the port side of things and power. I speculate that the cost would be in the region of £80 million to £100 million for the overall project for the three vessels and the associated works.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

That is helpful for today. Could you say a little more about the public engagement work that is about to get under way and engagement with the trade unions? What consultation will there be about crewing levels and shore-side infrastructure? I remind the committee that I am a member of the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers parliamentary group and of Unite the union.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We do not have any dates in the diary yet, but we will deal with the trade unions very early in all this. We have done that with all the other previous projects—we have had pretty regular discussions with the unions. We do not have dates yet, but that will happen in the very near future.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

That is good to know.

I have a question about the four large vessels that will be built in Turkey. What actions will be taken by CMAL and Cemre to ensure that the four large vessels that are being built in Turkey do not slip and cost increases are minimised?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

As we advised the committee in our update at the end of last year, delivery dates for the ships have been extended. Our current assessment is that the four vessels are about four months apart in production.

I will fly to Turkey this evening and will be back next week. We have a regular on-site presence there. Our site team includes people who are working on the electrical and mechanical elements, outfitting people, steel workers, the CalMac crew and the chief engineer. We have seven people involved daily in all aspects—including technical aspects and inspections.

The next big milestone for the Isle of Islay will be sea trials—the yard is heading towards that. At this point, I do not want to give a definite date for the trials, because there are so many systems that we still have to get over the line. Everything has to go smoothly, and I want to come back and report that we have all the systems over the line and that everybody is working hard together on the ships. A successful sea trial would give us an indicator of how much work is still to be completed on the ship.

Everybody is working very hard on the vessels. Yes—the dates have been extended from the original dates, but we are looking forward to getting some much-needed tonnage into the fleet this year.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Some rather extraordinary outlying events have hit during the past couple of years, which has not been helpful to anybody in the shipping world. I will go through them.

There is war in Ukraine and the steel plant that used to service the whole of Turkey with marine steel, which was in Mariupol, was blown to pieces.

There was also an earthquake in Turkey, and unfortunately tens of thousands of people died as a result of that. A lot of people had relatives in the area, and although the shipyard there was not officially closed, there were a lot of people missing for a long time, recovering their loved ones.

Then, of course, there is the Red Sea situation that has turned the whole container market on its head. Instead of everything coming through the Suez canal and being delivered to Israel, Egypt and Turkey first, everything is coming round Africa now. The ships are starting their milk rounds of deliveries in northern Europe then going back into the Mediterranean, which is unhelpful.

There is a series of issues that are indicators for why the project is running late. It is very difficult to criticise people on the back of external factors and geopolitical problems.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Thank you, Kevin. It is important to put that on the record. You have certainly outlined some significant challenges.

Can you say a word about the future of the project? Jim—you outlined the importance of having an on-site presence, so good luck with your travels today. What are the main tickets on the risk register that could put projects at risk because of delay and cost?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

The smallest of items can set back a project—for example, unavailability of specialist engineers from the major equipment suppliers. Everyone is so busy with shipbuilding projects, and only a small number of companies supply propulsion systems, engines and batteries.

With all the madness that is going on in shipbuilding around the world, when one project slips somewhere, that has a knock-on effect throughout the shipbuilding industry. We see that as a challenge for all shipyards, not just Cemre. A yard might have planned to have an engineer to come in in week 2 of this year to do some activity, but the engineer might say that it will be week 4 before they can get people there. Despite all the best planning, such challenges can be thrown up.

We might get to a point where there are some small issues with the Marine and Coastguard Agency and the classification society, although there is an almost permanent presence from a classification society—in this case, Lloyd’s Register. The MCA makes regular visits to the shipyard in Turkey, and our site team is there all the time.

One small thing can add four weeks to a project. The ship could be pretty much finished in its entirety, but the toilet system could suddenly develop an issue late in the day. We track all the risks, but there could be just one small thing out of tens of thousands of things in a shipbuilding project that need to be considered. A ship is pretty complex when you think about it—almost like a floating village or a floating city.

We are aware of most of the risks that we have to look out for, and we think ahead. We have a really good working relationship with the shipyard, the classification society, the MCA and CalMac. Without doubt, I say that all the best efforts are being put into the project.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

Thank you. I am sure that we will return to the themes of risk and resilience many times, but I will hand back to the convener.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you. Mark—you have the next questions.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have a follow-up question. I think that you have allowed a 3 per cent contingency for the four large vessels that are currently being constructed in Turkey. It was good that you put on the record some of the pressures and strains that exist at the moment. Is that 3 per cent figure adequate, or do you expect that it might need to go up? Will you need to use it?

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

I updated my budgets over Christmas and new year, and we are still well within that figure. We are still feeling pretty good about the overall budget cost.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

When will you next be able to update the committee? You are flying out tonight. In your letter of 18 December, you talked about the

“Risks and uncertainties”

around the

“supply of equipment and ... specialist contractors”.

You will have a clearer picture of that when you come back.

Jim Anderson Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

Whether or not I am in a position to update you after this visit, I will be making another visit on the 27th of this month for a longer period. Around that time, I will be able to give a clearer indication of a sea trials date. It is not quite at that stage yet.

Kevin Hobbs Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd
link

We have said before that if there is any significant movement—positive or negative—we will let you know. It is not simply that you will get an update only every three months; when we know that something has gone very well or catastrophically wrong, we will give intermediate updates, as and when required.

  1. 09:15 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:15 Ferry Services Evidence session · 322
  3. 11:00 Great British Energy Bill Bill debate · 91

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.