I will keep my remarks as brief as I can, in the light of the reasons for the meeting and the committee’s existing familiarity with the Scottish statutory instrument and its amendments.
It is important to say that our review and its conclusions responded to concerns that were raised by members of the committee and beyond. Our purpose was to ensure resilience by enabling people whose circumstances mean that wood-burning stoves and wider bioenergy systems should remain available and eligible choices of heating system. We listened to stakeholders in workshops and discussions that were held with those who were considered likely to be most affected. We also listened to the views that were expressed in the Parliament, including during the members’ business debate in May, in which you spoke, convener.
I do not intend to minimise the questions and concerns about air quality, which are the focus of today’s meeting, when I observe that none of the members who spoke in the debate in May raised any such issues. I say that simply to underline that the focus of those who wish to see the change that we have proposed has been to ensure resilience where it is needed. I believe that the SSI delivers that.
I take fully on board the concerns that have been raised by stakeholders over recent days, which are summarised in the committee’s paper. However, those concerns—which are as applicable to use of such heating systems in existing homes as they are to their use in new builds—need to be addressed through the most appropriate channel and process. It is therefore worth stressing again that the measure that the Government has laid before the Parliament—the amendment regulations—will, contrary to much of the speculation in the media, have no impact on existing houses with a stove, as was the case with the preceding measure that the SSI amends.
Undertaking further analysis and consultation to explore possible solutions and avoid unintended consequences would risk there being a potentially lengthy delay to the SSI, and it would risk causing tremendous confusion among those who have pleaded for such a change. Instead, I propose that we use the forthcoming review of the “Cleaner Air for Scotland 2—Towards a Better Place for Everyone” strategy as an opportunity to identify areas in which further progress might be needed.
In that context, the Government takes seriously the questions that have been raised about burning wood in urban areas by some of the people who have been in touch with the committee. However, I emphasise that there is no evidence that that is a significant feature in urban houses—at least, not in new builds in urban areas, and new builds are the subject of the measure that we are discussing. Scotland enjoys good air quality compared with that in much of Europe, but we are not complacent, and the review of our cleaner air strategy will focus on continuing to target action to protect human health.
Therefore, I believe that the review will present the most appropriate and effective means of ensuring that the health-related concerns that have been raised with the committee are addressed. I will be discussing the next steps in this area with the Acting Cabinet Secretary for Net Zero and Energy.
I hope that my remarks have provided some context for members and have been helpful. I am happy to respond to questions.