PE2009, which was lodged by Caroline Gordon, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to ensure fair access to Scottish universities for residents in Scotland and the United Kingdom by reviewing university business models and Scottish Government funding arrangements.
As we have been when we have considered the petition previously, we are joined by our MSP colleague Michael Marra. Good morning.
We previously considered the petition at our meeting on 6 March, when we agreed to write to the Commissioner for Fair Access, the Scottish Government and Universities Scotland—on Mr Marra’s suggestion, I think. We asked those organisations whether data from each university on how many Scotland-domiciled students are accepted on to each course annually could be published.
The Commissioner for Fair Access, Universities Scotland and the Scottish Government all noted that publishing that data alone could be misleading and raised concerns about the complexity of sharing complete data that would be useful to prospective students. The commissioner’s submission explains that
“A low count of entrants does not necessarily imply that it is more difficult to gain entry, just as a high count of entrants does not necessarily imply that it is easier to gain entry.”
Universities Scotland noted that
“The use of contextual admissions and minimum entry requirements ... adds a level of complexity”
to the data picture. Its submission states that that
“would need to be captured and reflected in any student-facing data ... so that the applicants ... are not misinformed.”
The Scottish Government’s submission states:
“It is for the universities themselves to decide: how to distribute the places between faculties; the courses they offer; and how many of the total funded places will be available on each course.”
Universities Scotland’s written submission states:
“the number of funded undergraduate places available to Scottish-domiciled applicants for academic year 2024/25 sits above the pre-pandemic, high watermark level.”
The petitioner’s written submission highlights the growing financial challenges that universities face, and she believes that widening access initiatives look
“like a sticking plaster on a gaping wound”.
Her submission urges the committee to call for the publication of admission figures so that they can be analysed to
“consider what needs to change”.
On the face of it, the options for the committee to take the petition much further forward are limited. However, given that Mr Marra has been invariably creative in his contributions to the committee, we wish to hear from him before we take any final decision.

