That is a complicated question with a complicated answer, and I will rely on support from my colleagues.
The environmental impact assessment system continues to operate in relation to relevant projects and plans in Scotland, and we have no current plans to adopt an EOR approach to environmental assessment. However, the UK Government is considering such reporting as a new approach for environmental assessment to replace the EU-derived system, using powers in the 2023 act. The UK Government consultation document, which was provided in March 2023, implies that the new EOR system will result in more efficient and effective processes for environmental assessment, but it does not set out details of how that would be achieved in practice.
The new UK Government has yet to confirm—or reconfirm, as it were—a commitment to making the change to EOR. We expect it to set out its proposed approach in 2025, and we will then consider that new approach.
Transitioning to a system of environmental outcome reports would be a long-term and complex change, and a decision to contemplate such change would, therefore, require careful consideration.
There is still some uncertainty as to what differences there might be between the system that we currently use and the potential implementation of an EOR system. We await further information from the UK Government. We are here today because Mr Michael Gove, through the then Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, made a commitment back in 2023 that when the bill that became the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023 was passed, it would include essentially the return to the Scottish ministers of a power that was equal to the original power that we had through the EU to make changes if we chose to do so.
I make it clear, for the benefit of the committee, that if we were to begin the journey to EORs, which I imagine would depend in part on what the UK Government might do, there would be a huge amount of engagement and consultation with stakeholders in the development of such an approach.
After all that complexity, I guess the simple answer is that, with regard to the difference in approach, there are elements on which I cannot give an answer right now. The question that the committee could put to me, therefore, is this: why are we pursuing order under the Scotland Act 1998 when EORs are not yet fully developed?
First, the process needs to follow that sequence so that the discretionary power is available for the Scottish ministers to use, should they wish, once EORs are fully understood. Secondly, that is the design by which the UK Government and the Scottish Government decided to devolve and transfer those powers, and the new UK Government has essentially agreed to pursue that approach. There would have been some doubt as to whether the new UK Government would have followed in Michael Gove’s footsteps.
I hope that that answer is not too long-winded, but I imagine that, to an extent, the committee might look at the order before it and ask what the implications are. The answer, I would say—unless my colleagues tell us otherwise—is that, at present, it essentially transfers the discretionary power, subject to extensive consultation if that power were ever to be used.