Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Local Services Franchises (Traffic Commissioner Notices and Panels) (Scotland) Regulations 2024 (SSI 2024/229)

Tuesday 8 October 2024 Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee About 09:30 Subordinate legislation 22 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

22 contributions
Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Item 4 is consideration of three Scottish statutory instruments. As the instruments have been laid under the negative procedure, they will come into force unless the Parliament agrees a motion to annul them. No motions to annul have been lodged, and the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee had no comment to make on any of the instruments in its report.

I will seek views on each instrument in turn. Do members have any comments on the Local Services Franchises (Traffic Commissioner Notices and Panels) (Scotland) Regulations 2024? Mark, you were quick with your hand.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Yes. I have a concern about this SSI. Obviously, concerns have been expressed about bus franchising, and I think that it is fair to say that the history of rolling out bus franchises across the UK is a pretty chequered one. I am aware that this SSI comes out of the Transport (Scotland) Act 2019, but there is currently a petition before the Parliament from Get Glasgow Moving, which has raised significant concerns about the process set out in the SSI, particularly the role of unelected officials in deciding whether a franchise can go ahead.

I think, therefore, that we are at quite a critical point. I know that Strathclyde Partnership for Transport is looking into the potential of franchising, and given that it will take significant investment just to do that preparatory work, there is a need for clarity on how this will work and whether there might be any intentional or unintentional biases or conflicts of interest within the panel that is appointed.

As a result, it is important that the committee takes evidence, certainly from the petitioners and those with experience of how similar franchising decision-making processes have been working down south, and that we reflect on that, ahead of Parliament making a decision to let this SSI pass—or not, as the case might be.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you very much. Now everyone’s hands are going up. I call Monica Lennon, to be followed by Bob Doris.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I, too, am mindful of the petition by Get Glasgow Moving that is with the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee, and I agree that we need to take further evidence on the SSI. I certainly have a number of questions that we will not get answers to today from just talking among ourselves.

Indeed, I think that these concerns are shared more widely. I am not entirely sure about some of the things that have happened in England and I think that the legislation in that respect might have changed, but we need to try to bottom that out and understand, too, the role of the traffic commissioner for Scotland in all of this. I would therefore welcome it if we took more evidence and heard from some of the key stakeholders, including Get Glasgow Moving.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

The Get Glasgow Moving petition is really interesting. Initially, it appears that it seeks to redraw primary legislation, if it were to move through Parliament and be successful. Today, however, we are looking at secondary legislation for something that was agreed by the Parliament in 2019. Therefore, although there is a connection between the petition and what we are looking at today, I do not think that it is a direct one.

The Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee will have to be allowed to decide how it wishes to scrutinise and go forward with the petition. The question in my head is whether, if we do not pass this negative instrument or allow it to move forward, there will be any pathway for franchising bus services in Scotland. In that respect, I am very mindful of SPT’s ambitions to improve the bus service via franchising in Glasgow.

That said, I agree with Mark Ruskell MSP that we need more information on how all of this works. It is very reasonable for Get Glasgow Moving to seek clarity on the role of the traffic commissioner and the panel that would be appointed, and the criteria by which they might or might not make decisions.

As I say, there is absolutely a need for more information, but I just want to put on record that there are two moving parts here. The first is Get Glasgow Moving’s commendable efforts to seek a wider scrutiny role for the Parliament with regard to primary legislation that it has already passed, and the second is the secondary legislation that we are looking at and which provides a pathway to bus franchising. The two things are connected, but not directly so. Again, I would absolutely welcome more information from the Scottish Government, and it would be helpful if we could get some clarity on the role of the traffic commissioner, too.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

I agree with Mark Ruskell and Bob Doris. We need to hear both sides of the argument, and it would be good to hear from the Scottish Government, too, as Bob Doris has recommended. It is clear that we need another evidence session before we move forward with this.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Now that we have talked this through, we find ourselves in a difficult situation. The SSI’s commencement date is, as I understand it, 1 November. The next evidence session that we could have would be on 29 October, which clashes with stage 2 of the Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill, and in the middle of all that comes recess. I am not seeking to incite riot, if that is the right description, but if anyone wants to lodge a motion to annul, they have to do so before the committee’s evidence session—that is, on 28 October. I note that Bob Doris wants to speak—I will come to you in a minute, Bob, if I may.

Three members feel that more evidence is needed, and Bob Doris, too, has suggested that that might be the case. Is this something that we could deal with in writing prior to the committee meeting? That would allow us to get evidence and then make a decision on whether we need to take evidence on 29 October. Do Mark Ruskell, Monica Lennon and Douglas Lumsden, who have all made the suggestion, feel that an evidence session is required anyway? I am interested in hearing your views on that.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I think that it requires an evidence session, yes.

Monica Lennon Lab Central Scotland
link

I agree. I know that the committee has a big workload, but I think that this is important.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

I think that we need more information. However, could a motion to annul be lodged and then withdrawn, once we hear the evidence?

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Indeed it could. My understanding is that a motion to annul can be lodged in advance and then not moved on the day.

I am just thinking of timetabling. I am looking at the deputy convener and whether he has any suggestions. I think that writing to people would be helpful, and it might be suitable to warn them off with regard to the meeting on 29 October.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I have no problem with taking further evidence on the issue, but my overarching concern is that if we were to annul these regulations, there would be no pathway for bus franchising. If the view is that the existing and, indeed, additional safeguard that was put into the legislation at the time is not enough—that is, the provision relating to the traffic commissioner, which was put in because of an issue with regional transport planning authorities doing this on their own and whether they would get it right—the only recourse that we will have will be to primary legislation in order to legislate for something different.

I am just mindful of that issue. There needs to be a pathway for bus franchising, which I am a fan of—indeed, that is why it was in the legislation. If there were a motion to annul and the committee were to agree it, there is a risk that we would have no pathway to franchising in Scotland. From my understanding of what we have heard, primary legislation would then be required, which I suspect would put things back by years.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

The deputy convener has made a reasonable comment about the potential unintended consequences of not passing this secondary legislation. Clearly, we are at the very least going to correspond with people—we still have to establish what else we might or might not do—so I am keen to find out, perhaps from the Government, how easy it would be for the Scottish Government to listen to on-going concerns if the instrument were to be passed. After all, the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee will be doing a piece of work separate from what we do. I wonder whether, theoretically, the Government could lay a supplementary negative instrument at a later date, depending on whether it feels that there has been a weight—Inaudible.—more about the process in relation to that.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Can I make a suggestion on a way forward and see whether it meets with the committee’s approval? First of all, I think that we should take evidence in writing. If we were going to do that, I would invite committee members to submit to the clerks any questions that they would like answers to. The clerks could then send them off, and we would give a tight timescale to ensure that we got responses before 28 October to allow people to make a decision.

We could then have a short evidence-taking session on the morning of 29 October. It would mean an earlier start, but we would probably have to get the cabinet secretary in as well as any witnesses recommended by the clerks. We could take the decision on the instrument then. As far as I am aware, we have no leeway on the final date, because the SSI has to go through the Parliament. I am looking at the clerks as I say that, and they are confirming that to me.

Are we happy with that as a reasonable way of dealing with the matter?

Jackie Dunbar SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

I have a question. How can we do this and a stage 2 on 29 October?

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

That is an extremely good question, and I do not know the answer to it. I do know that we have a final date for lodging stage 2 amendments—I am just looking at the clerks, who are confirming to me that that date is 23 October. I will have a pretty good idea of how long that item will take once I have looked at the groupings with the legislation team, and we can then work our way through the timings. Given the timescale set by the Parliament, we might have to do what we did last week and look at meeting while Parliament is sitting.

I know that that is not a great solution, Jackie, but I see no way round it if we are going to give the matter proper scrutiny.

Jackie Dunbar SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

I hear what you have said about 23 October, convener, but we cannot really make a decision today if we do not know what is going to happen until then.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Indeed. We are slightly hamstrung by that date, and we also do not know whether the questions from committee members will be answered satisfactorily enough so that they feel no need to have an evidence session on 29 October.

I am afraid that I see no way round it. I know that there are all sorts of problems with this. It is not my intention to put this to a vote, but we have a situation in which three members appear to be uncomfortable with things; I have not disclosed my position; and there appears to be three members who are relatively comfortable with it.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Well, I am just assuming that. It might be a bad assumption.

Nevertheless, I think that we need to take evidence and I am suggesting that as a way forward. We can have a brief discussion of timescales when we go into private session to ensure we have enough time to do this.

I know that it is not a perfect solution, but is the committee happy to move forward with it?

Members indicated agreement.

Jackie Dunbar SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

I am content more than happy, I would say. I still have reservations.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

I note that the committee is content to move forward with it.

  1. 09:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 09:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 47
  3. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 22
  4. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  5. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  6. 09:30 Environmental Standards Scotland Climate Change Targets Delivery Improvement Report Committee business · 185

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.