The fair work measurement framework was refreshed through the research, which found that, of the 45 indicators, 19 had improved, 10 had worsened and 14 had fluctuated or remained broadly stable. Some areas were quite positive. The report noted that there had been a significant decrease in the proportion of employees earning less than the real living wage—the proportion sat at 9 per cent in 2022. The gender pay gap had almost halved from 6.4 per cent in 2016 to 3.7 per cent in 2022. Involuntary self-employment had fallen from 3.7 per cent in 2016 to 2 per cent in 2022. The ethnicity employment gap had fallen from 16.3 percentage points in 2016 to 11.7 percentage points in 2021, while the ethnicity pay gap had reduced slightly from 7.5 per cent in 2016 to 5.9 per cent in 2021.
We were therefore able to identify some positive findings in the report, but quite a lot of things had moved in the wrong direction. Between 2016 and 2021, the number of people self-reporting stress, depression or anxiety that was caused or made worse by work more than doubled. The percentage of employers that provided training to their employees fell from 73 per cent in 2017 to 70 per cent in 2021. Access to flexible working had improved slightly, but about three quarters of workers still had no access to flexible working. The disability pay gap increased from 13.7 per cent in 2016 to 18.5 per cent in 2021. The use of zero-hours contracts increased from 2.2 per cent in 2016 to 3.4 per cent in 2022, which we found quite disappointing, because addressing that issue had been a key focus for the Scottish Government and was part of the fair work first approach.
The movement in relation to the real living wage was very positive, as the Government had put a lot of focus and emphasis on that area, but progress had not necessarily fed through in every element that it had put emphasis on, so we were concerned about some of the findings.
In the same report, we developed the international fair work nation framework. The idea was that that would help us to answer the question of what it means to be a leading fair work nation. We tried to benchmark Scotland’s performance against that of a range of countries that were already doing well across a range of indicators. We picked countries that had a good story to tell in that regard. We took indicators from the fair work measurement framework and compared them at an international level. The indicators were chosen primarily on the basis of data compatibility, so lots of indicators in our domestic framework were not able to be compared internationally because the quality of data was not available.
The framework benchmarked Scotland’s performance against that of Denmark, Belgium, Austria, Finland, Iceland, Ireland, the Netherlands and England. The comparator countries were chosen because they offered a stretching but realistic benchmark for Scotland and they incorporated a range of similar-sized countries with a similar gross domestic product, with comparable data being available.
The framework includes 14 indicators, of which 13 are drawn from the fair work measurement framework and one—low pay—is unique to the international fair work nation framework. It is quite difficult to compare wages directly, but we felt that it was important to have a measure of pay, because that indicator is often used to compare international performance.
We found that no country led on all indicators, but a range of countries are doing better than Scotland across a range of indicators. We felt that fair work could not be measured using a single indicator; a country needed to be doing well across a range of indicators.
In some areas, Scotland’s performance was comparatively positive. For example, on permanent employment rates, Scotland was placed first out of nine in the framework; on youth unemployment, it was second out of nine, with the gap between the leading fair work nation being 0.9 percentage points; and on work-related ill health and disease, it was second out of nine, with the gap being 1.8 percentage points.
Scotland was mid-table on a range of indicators. On the gender economic inactivity gap, Scotland was fourth out of nine; on the gender pay gap, it was fourth out of nine; on workplace non-fatal injuries, it was fifth out of nine; on low pay, it was fifth out of eight, based on data availability; on trade union membership, it was fifth out of nine; on underemployment, it was sixth out of nine; and on involuntary part-time work, it was sixth out of nine.
Scotland’s performance was comparatively poor across a range of indicators. On the disability employment gap, Scotland was sixth out of eight, with the gap between it and the leading fair work nation being 23.2 percentage points; on involuntary non-permanent work, it was seventh out of nine, with the gap being 25 percentage points; on collective bargaining, it was seventh out of nine, with the gap being 59.9 percentage points; and on skills underutilisation, it was eighth out of eight, with the gap being 20.6 percentage points.
We noted that, although we were doing well against indicators such as permanent employment, we were doing very poorly against indicators such as involuntary insecure work. That told a story about the labour market in Scotland. A lot of people were in permanent work, which was good, but quite a lot of people were in insecure work that they did not want to be in, and the penalty for that seemed to be quite high.
We also found—