Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Charges for Residues Surveillance Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2024 (SSI 2024/218)

Wednesday 25 September 2024 Rural Affairs and Islands Committee About 13:00–13:15 Subordinate legislation 36 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

36 contributions
Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Item 6 is consideration of a negative instrument. At last week’s meeting, the committee agreed to defer consideration of the instrument in order to take evidence from the Minister for Agriculture and Connectivity before we disposed of it.

I welcome back to the meeting Jim Fairlie, Minister for Agriculture and Connectivity, who is joined by Scottish Government officials Jesus Gallego, senior policy advisor, animal health and welfare division, and Keith White, solicitor.

I invite the minister to make some introductory remarks.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I thank the committee for giving me the opportunity to clarify the intended consequences of the instrument, taking into account the comments that were made by the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee, and by this committee at its meeting last week.

The primary aim of the instrument is to ensure full cost recovery for services relating to the surveillance and inspection of animals and animal products for residues of veterinary medicinal products relating to the national residues control programme, or NRCP, which is managed by the Veterinary Medicines Directorate, or VMD, across Great Britain.

On anticipated costs, the policy note accompanying the regulations states that the annual cost of delivering the NRCP currently costs around £5 million per year, which is forecast to reach around £8 million per year by 2028. The increase is due to a rise in the costs of procured services that are necessary to deliver the programme such as sampling, testing and consumables.

Without the proposed revisions to the current charges that NRCP participants pay, it is forecast that there will be an underrecovery of the costs of the programme by £1.2 million in the current financial year, and the deficit is expected to rise to £3 million per year by 2029.

It should be stressed that the increase in cost is the estimated cost across Great Britain, so Scotland will contribute less to the overall increase, given that there is a smaller concentration of participants here. Currently, more than 500 companies across the various sectors are included in the NRCP.

I want to pick up Rhoda Grant’s point at committee last week about whether an island impact assessment was considered. As this is not a new policy, strategy or service that is likely to have an impact on an island community that is significantly different from the effect on other communities, it was considered that, on balance, no assessment is required.

By way of conclusion, I reiterate that the NRCP is a statutory programme and is designed to help protect human health by identifying unsafe residues of banned substances, veterinary medicines and contaminants in products of animal origin before they enter the food chain. The NRCP helps to protect human health. It also provides assurances to the UK’s trading partners about the quality and safety of exported food products of animal origin. The programme helps to support international trade, which is worth around £12 billion to the UK economy per year.

I am happy to take any questions, with my officials.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Thank you, minister. Do members have questions?

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

My concern in relation to an island impact assessment is that I believe that the regulations could have an impact.

The minister will be well aware that people have been talking for a long time about micro-abattoirs and the benefits—both animal welfare and economic—there would be if island communities, and smaller communities away from markets, were able to have abattoirs. They would be able to sell their own meat locally, the tourism industry would benefit, because there would be local produce available, and people could sell online. It would make for a huge economic boost.

Anything that adds to not only the cost but the bureaucracy of the process pushes all those things further and further away, and my concern is that the regulations might do that. They might just add another hurdle to get over. I am not suggesting for one moment that we are making great progress with having abattoirs—in fact, some that we have are already under threat—but the regulations could, first of all, dispense with those that are there and, secondly, stop us from getting others.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I concur with what you have said about abattoirs, particularly in island areas, and if we could do more to help that situation, I would absolutely get on board with that. However, the SSI is about protecting human health and ensuring that nothing has been added to animals and animal products. Abattoirs already have to comply with the measures, so bureaucracy wise, the SSI will not make any difference.

I get that there will be a cost increase—and percentage wise, it looks like a lot—but as far the cost to a small abattoir is concerned, I think that, given that it applies on a cost-per-animal basis, it will not be enough to put that abattoir over the edge, as it were. As a result, there was no need for a separate island impact assessment.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I guess that what I am trying to say is that, at the moment, abattoirs are clinging to the edge by their fingertips. We are struggling to get others in place—which is what we really want to happen—and the cost increases just push the direction of travel the wrong way. Is there anything that you can do, especially for island communities but also for other communities that are a long way from the centre—we have been talking about Skye abattoir and so on for a long time now—to mitigate the challenges that are posed not only by the cost increases but by some of the other challenges, if we are to be realistic about making that increase in provision a reality?

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

The fundamental thing that we have to remember is that this is a statutory programme that we must carry out order to protect human health. The testing system is about making sure that no residues go into the human food chain.

I completely take on board all of your points about how difficult this is, and I have already agreed to meet other members to talk about what more we can do to help the more remote—again, I want to stop using that word—island communities with regard to slaughtering provision. However, I do not think that the increase in charges will be the clincher here. In any case, we have to carry out the programme to ensure that we are protecting human health, as much as anything else.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Could I be included in those discussions? After all, I represent an area where the issue is crucial.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

This discussion sounds a bit similar to the one that we had on the previous regulations. Minister, have you done any assessment of the impact on smaller abattoirs or processors?

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Not on an individual basis, no. We looked at what we needed to do in order to achieve full cost recovery on the programme of surveillance of veterinary residues.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Do you know by what percentage the price of an average test for cattle will go up?

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I think that it is about 64 per cent.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Surely that will have a significant impact on some of the smaller abattoirs. Everybody will agree on the need for the inspections—and that situation is not changing—but we are talking about a significant rise in costs that might have an impact on smaller processors. In fact, one plant that I have been in contact with has suggested that its costs will increase by almost £20,000. That is not inconsiderable—indeed, it could put them over the edge.

The point is that we are making a decision today on whether to make any recommendation on the instrument, and we want to be sure that the Government has considered the potential adverse impact on small abattoirs. We know that we have a critical mass situation in Scotland, with our abattoirs, auction marts and so on worried about the cliff edge and the number of cattle that are going through. What were the Government’s considerations on that issue?

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I will let Jesus Gallego answer that question about what considerations happened on the ground, as it were.

13:15

Jesus Gallego Scottish Government
link

The consultation document contains a worked example for a typical slaughterhouse, but it is for a typical large slaughterhouse. The estimate in that example is around 100,000 cattle per year. However, because the charge is on a per headage basis, it can be applied equally to any size of slaughterhouse. Therefore, for a typical micro-abattoir on an island slaughtering, say, two cattle heads per week—or 100 per year—the increase of 20p per year will mean £20 per year in total. The amounts that we are talking about in that scenario are very small, simply because the throughput is very small. The amounts for the large slaughterhouses are very large, because their throughput is very high.

We did not look specifically at an island-versus-mainland comparison, but we know that most micro-abattoirs in Scotland happen to be on the islands. The fact is that you can estimate the cost based on the size of the abattoir, not necessarily on its location. Generally speaking, though, even though the percentage increase from 50p to 70p per cattle head seems very high, the increase per year for a very small abattoir is very small.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I call Rachael Hamilton.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

The same consideration will apply not just to abattoirs but to game processing plants, milk producers, fisheries, aquaculture products and so on. I note that Salmon Scotland responded to the consultation. My point about this SSI is that it is disappointing that, although most of the responses came from GB-wide stakeholders, there was only one Scottish response. Salmon Scotland’s response speaks to some of the concerns that the committee has raised in the past about the engagement process and ensuring that people are not taken unawares by the potential for increased costs.

As my colleague Rhoda Grant, in particular, has pointed out, we are in a difficult trading environment, with costs rising as a result of inflationary pressures. What efforts are being made to ensure that, in this scenario, there are no cliff edges?

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

Again, I go back to the point that Jesus Gallego made: the charge is based on headage going through the abattoir, so it will be consistent with the throughput of a particular slaughterhouse.

Jim Fairlie SNP Perthshire South and Kinross-shire
link

I just want to reiterate that this is a statutory programme that we have to carry out in order to protect human health, which applies across the whole of the UK. As the £3 million excess that we are looking at affects the entire food sector in the whole of the UK, it should have minimal impact. I have to say that we had very little in the way of responses; people have not been responding to the Government to say that there is a real problem with this.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Just to be clear, most people wanted the sector-based and tailored option. You have talked about headage of cattle, but how is that equated? Is it according to, say, litres of milk? With a game processing plant, is it a brace of pheasants? How does it work?

Jesus Gallego Scottish Government
link

I can take that, minister. For cattle, sheep and pigs, it is per headage. For most of the other commodities, it is per weight—that is, per tonne, per 100 tonnes et cetera.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

How is that equated and worked out? How do the sectors know how much they will be charged? For example, a small game processing facility might have only a tonne of output.

Jesus Gallego Scottish Government
link

In the case of game, the charge is £1.04 per tonne. Estimates of the costs are made sector by sector and, interestingly, wild game is the only sector in which the charges are not going up at all—in all the other sectors, the charges are going up.

The national programme is based on collecting, in total, around 30,000 samples in all sectors across the whole of Great Britain, but they are split between commodities and so on, based on risk. Some samples are more efficient to collect than others. The Veterinary Medicines Directorate apportions the costs based on the cost of each sample. For example, it is much easier to collect samples from establishments that have a permanent presence, such as abattoirs, than it is to collect them from places where people would have to go specifically to do that. The consultation showed that the industry supported each sector being considered on its merits, rather than an approach being taken across the board. That resulted in there being no increase at all for some sectors, such as wild game.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I am very interested in the issue. I do not think that there will be a motion to annul the regulations or anything like that; we are just interested in scrutinising them.

I notice that you have the costs handy. What are the costs for milk production?

Jesus Gallego Scottish Government
link

The current cost is £0.0276 per 1,000 litres. This year, the cost will go up to £0.0373 per 1,000 litres, and, from 2025, it will go up to £0.0405 per 1,000 litres.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Okay. The only thing that I will say in relation to there being no business and regulatory impact assessment because the Government says that there will be no “significant, effects on ... business” is that, if a dairy business or the owner of a game processing plant were here, they would probably say something different. I just want to put that on the record.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I have a couple of questions. Who evaluates the delivery of the service in Scotland? What is looked at in the evaluation? Prior to considering increasing the costs, was any additional work done to look at whether the service is being delivered efficiently? Were any mitigation measures considered before it was decided to increase the costs for industry?

Jesus Gallego Scottish Government
link

We evaluate the programme. The Veterinary Medicines Directorate produces an annual report on the conclusions of the programme. For example, we have to present our conclusions to the European Union in order to maintain our export approval. We are also involved as customers when the contract for laboratory services is procured. That contract is outsourced.

A large proportion of the costs come from sampling, which is completed mostly by competent authorities. In our case, that tends to be done by either our staff or contracted staff from the Animal and Plant Health Agency, for example. A large proportion of the costs relate to staff costs and staff time, so the costs are going up due to inflation.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

The lack of vets or anything like that has not had an impact; the increase is simply down to staffing and laboratory costs.

Jesus Gallego Scottish Government
link

It is generally down to costs that are associated with staffing, outsourcing labs and consumables.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Is there still a requirement to test for some residues? Does there need to be a review of that? There might have been an issue with some antibiotics, chemicals and pesticides in the past—I am thinking of dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane, or DDT, or other things for which there needed to be testing—but is there scope for reviewing what residues need to be tested for to ensure public safety? That might result in a reduction in costs.

Jesus Gallego Scottish Government
link

The national control plan is reviewed annually. It is a risk-based control plan that is based on findings from previous years. Some things cannot be changed because of international obligations, but, yes, there is scope for reviews.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

That is most helpful.

We move to formal consideration of the instrument. As no member has any further comments, does the committee agree that it does not wish to make any recommendations on it?

Members indicated agreement.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I thank the minister and his officials for attending the meeting. That concludes our business in public.

13:26 Meeting continued in private until 13:26.

  1. 09:00 Pre-budget Scrutiny 2025-26 Committee business · 304
  2. 11:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
  3. 11:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 174
  4. 13:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 36

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.