Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Producer Responsibility Obligations (Packaging and Packaging Waste) Regulations 2024

Tuesday 3 September 2024 Net Zero, Energy and Transport Committee About 11:30–11:45 Subordinate legislation 50 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

50 contributions
Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Our next item is consideration of a type 1 consent notification for a proposed UK statutory instrument. On 5 June, the Minister for Climate Action notified the committee of the UK SI. The instrument will involve the UK Government legislating within devolved competence and it seeks the Scottish Government’s consent for it to do so.

The Scottish Government proposes to consent to the instrument, which, as the clerk’s paper explains, would require producers of products to pay the full net cost of managing their packaging at the end of life.

The committee’s role is to decide whether it agrees with the Scottish Government’s proposal to consent to the UK Government making those regulations within devolved competence, and in the manner that has been indicated. If members are content for consent to be given, the committee will write to the Scottish Government accordingly. In so writing, we have the option to draw matters to the Government’s attention, pose questions or ask to be kept up to date on relevant developments.

If the committee is not content with the proposal, it may make one of the two recommendations that are outlined in the clerk’s note. We can recommend that the provisions should not be made at all, or that the Scottish Government take an alternative legislative approach—for example, by bringing forward its own Scottish statutory instruments.

I hope that that is all clear. To help to inform our decision, we have invited the cabinet secretary to stay and give evidence. I am not going to welcome you back again, Gillian, but you are here with us.

We are also joined by a number of Scottish Government officials. David McPhee is doing a third tour of duty in his role as deputy director for the circular economy; Alex Brown is, I think, joining us for the first time as circular economy policy officer; and Carolyn Boyd is on her third tour of duty, too. Thank you for joining us.

I now move to questions from members, with the first question coming, I believe, from Jackie Dunbar.

Jackie Dunbar SNP Aberdeen Donside
link

Thank you very much, convener, and welcome again, cabinet secretary.

I have just a quick question. Has the Scottish Government been in contact with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities on this matter? Are you able to tell us whether COSLA is satisfied with the proposal or does it have any outstanding concerns regarding the cost of recovery for local authorities?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

We have absolutely been in touch with COSLA throughout the whole process. I am really pleased that the UK Government has brought forward these regulations, and I hope that the committee will agree that they really represent a step change in the management of waste; instead of its being a burden on the taxpayer and on the public purse, there will be a vehicle for the manufacturers of products to pay for the management of their packaging waste. I think that it will mean a number of things, and I think that COSLA is supportive of it.

What effectively will it mean? It is expected that £1.2 billion a year will come to local authorities UK wide, and with the consequentials, that will translate into £120 million a year for Scotland. That is what is anticipated; it might be more or it might be less, but that is what it is anticipated will come to local authorities from the scheme administrator as a result of its handling of waste packaging.

What that will mean, initially, is that authorities can invest that money in improving their recycling processes without—and this is crucial—putting the burden of dealing with the waste on council tax payers or on the funding that they get from Government. Initially, there will be two streams of funding, because authorities will have to put in place a certain amount of adaptation with regard to the waste management that we ask them to do. Effectively, though, the money that will come to them as a result of EPR is going to help them to significantly improve their waste management.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Thanks, Jackie. I think that Douglas Lumsden has some questions.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

I just want to double check something with regard to an issue that Jackie Dunbar raised. Will the extra money that comes into local authorities from EPR be seen as additionality? Because of the money coming in from EPR, will the Scottish Government look to rein some of that back in and reduce their block grant?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

Local authorities will receive the full net costs of managing packaging through EPR, taking account of efficient and effective service provision. That might mean that, over time, the money that councils decide to spend on the waste management envelope will get taken over by the funding coming from EPR. As a result, it will come down to councils’ decisions about how they manage their funding.

I am not going to look into the future and say what the finance secretary of a future Government might do about council settlements—indeed, I do not think that you would expect me to do so—but the idea is that there will be additional money coming from EPR and then, as a result of councils’ spending decisions, they might be in a position to release money that they would otherwise have spent on waste management to spend on other areas. What that will mean for future council settlements is not something that I am able to answer here and now, because obviously that will be up to a future finance cabinet secretary to decide.

However, that is the mechanism that will be put in place. Essentially, EPR is all about producers having responsibility for waste management—in this instance, of packaging, although other regulations that I hope we will be able to agree to might come forward from the UK Government, extending EPR to other types of waste.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

I guess from that answer, however, that a lot of local authorities will not be getting too excited. They will feel that extra money will be given on one hand and taken away on the other, because you cannot really give them assurance that it is additionality.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

The thing is that you cannot give assurance about future budget settlements at all, Mr Lumsden, as you know. I am not in a position to say what will happen in future with regard to council tax settlements. However, it is about the fundamental principle that, with regard to waste management, the four nations of the UK are, as a whole, moving towards the responsibility for paying for the handling of waste coming not from the public purse but from the producers of the items that we use.

I do not know whether David McPhee wants to come in.

David McPhee
link

To confirm that point, the aim of the policy is not to pay local government to deal with waste twice—not that Mr Lumsden is suggesting that. It is not about their having money to deal with waste and then getting extra money to do so, but about the fact that the waste services for packaging will be paid for by the producers. Local government will therefore have enough money to deal with waste through getting the net cost of providing an efficient and effective service, which means that the pressure is broadly taken off the public purse to allow that money to be spent in other ways.

As the cabinet secretary has said, we cannot say what future settlements will be. However, the point is that that cost will always be met by the producers, therefore taking that burden off local government, which means that funding is essentially available for other services, and local government no longer has to look inside its budget settlement and ask, “How do we deal with packaging waste?” because that is paid for through the packaging EPR. The idea is that the burden is moved towards the producers rather than the public purse.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

Okay. I will move to the next question. Have Scottish businesses or stakeholders raised any specific concerns with you about the impact of the EPR on packaging?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

Initially, there were obviously a lot of questions around what it might mean for them and a discussion about what influence they would have in the design of the EPR. The administrator put together a steering group, because it was important that businesses had an influence on how the EPR would be designed—obviously, this is a UK instrument that is coming to us to agree on. It allowed members of that steering group to perform an advisory role.

Indicative producer base fees were released in August and gave businesses indicative accounts of what they can expect to pay per tonne under the EPR. Those have been dealt with at the four-nations level, because the business community has been involved in the design of the EPR from the get-go.

It might be important to say that I am genuinely looking forward to seeing how businesses and producers of goods and packaging adapt to that. I think that what we will see as a result is an improvement in our packaging, as they will not want to pay a lot of money for the soft packet plastics and so on. I am excited to see how that will develop. I think that we will see a revolution and innovation in the way that packaging for our goods is manufactured and designed, because businesses and producers will want to take the waste plastics away as much as possible. I hope that the fact that this is getting moved across all four nations means that they will see a market for better packaging—not only are there market opportunities for those producers, but they are also looking at how to bring down waste at source.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

Have we learned from other countries already? Has that behaviour changed and has packaging changed?

David McPhee
link

Alex Brown might want to comment on that, because she is more of an expert than I am. The packaging EPR is not unique to the UK; that approach is taken throughout the world.

11:45

To return to the cabinet secretary’s point about business being involved in the conversation, it is difficult to talk about business as one homogeneous group—there are people who disagree, to varying degrees, with how the regulations will be implemented. Broadly, we have engaged closely with the bodies that oversee producers in order to understand their position. They bring expertise, because all the producers work abroad. Many companies are multinational. They know how these things work and have fed that information in to the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and ourselves. They will be involved with the scheme administrator set-up in order to make sure that best practice is brought in as much as possible.

Obviously, within that there will always be producers that want to go to X, whereas the Government will want to go only to Y. I will not suggest that we all agree and that we are all completely happy; there is compromise within that conversation. However, businesses have been involved in the development of the scheme administrator and the policy more generally, and they are working with us. Businesses have raised concerns about it being a public sector administrator, but that was defined by the way in which the scheme is currently set up. Conversations continue with businesses about how we can address that and how we can look forward and make it more in line with other countries in that respect. We continue to engage regularly with business.

DEFRA is taking the lead on that engagement, but, at a Scottish level, we are speaking to organisations that represent businesses to help us to understand how the policy can work most effectively for them. Most of the business organisations that I speak to recognise why the approach has been taken. They may not agree with every element, but they recognise it and are looking to respond to it. They are looking to innovate and move forward. There is good engagement in that respect.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There are a few other questions, which I hope will be short and receive short answers. Sorry—I should not have said that before your question came up, Ben.

Ben Macpherson SNP Edinburgh Northern and Leith
link

It is okay. Much of what I was going to ask about has been covered by Douglas Lumsden’s questions on engagement with business. Unless the cabinet secretary and her officials have anything more to say about that, I am happy to move on.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Cabinet secretary, is there anything that you want to add?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

No. I think that we have covered it comprehensively.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am curious about how this relates to where we currently are with deposit return schemes. I presume that the EPR regulation also incorporates bottles, cans and glass. I am interested in looking at that and getting your views on it. Do you see there inevitably being a DRS across the UK in the run up to 2028?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I do not want to go too much into DRS, but I will give you an update. Obviously, DRS regulations will be completely separate from the EPR regulations. It is another area in which we are working very closely with the other three nations of the UK, and we have signed up to work with the UK Government on DRS regulations. When the new UK Government came in, I wrote to it to reiterate our stance on DRS.

I will hand over to my official to talk about the interaction between the EPR regulations and DRS.

David McPhee
link

DRS items are not included in the packaging EPR regulations for the reason that DRS has to be set up by industry, so businesses will be spending their money to get ready for it. Any items that are included in the DRS at the moment are not included in the EPR, because producers will be focused on that. However, there is a backstop in that, if the DRS is not up and running by—I think—1 January 2028, all the items that are in the DRS will come into the EPR regulations. That is an incentive to businesses.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I want to make it clear that every one of the four nations wants the DRS to be up and running well before that.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

To be clear, if there is no DRS, businesses will have to pay through the nose for EPR post-2028. A wine and spirits company, for example, that is using glass extensively may be looking at the lack of a DRS scheme for glass right now and thinking, “Well, we’ve got out of that.” However, come 2028, if there is no DRS for glass bottles, it will have to make a payment through the scheme to enable local authorities to collect all of its glass. There is no way to get away from paying for the cost of collection; it is just a case of which mechanism it might go through. Is that a fair assessment?

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

What do you think will happen with the DRS, given the context of the EPR being brought in with a backstop of 2028?

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

On that, we have written to the UK Government to reiterate the position that we had signed up to with the previous Government before the general election. We had said that we would work in lock step with the other nations to roll out the DRS. In the same vein as the previous discussion around vaping, I have been in touch with them about moving ahead on that on a four-nations basis. I will keep you updated on that, but our position remains that we want a DRS working as soon as possible.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That is great. When will the draft circular economy 2030 route map be finalised? Lorna Slater provided an earlier version of that, which the committee saw in January. It would be useful to know when that whole picture can be finalised and brought forward.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I think that we are on record as saying that we aim to publish that by the end of the year, so nothing has changed in that respect.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

Douglas, is your question specifically on this matter? If not, I will take Bob Doris’s question next.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

My question is not on this either.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It can be a short question anyway.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

It will be, convener. There will potentially be £120 million per annum going to Scottish local authorities from a system administrator, who is to be appointed. That is very welcome. On parliamentary scrutiny in relation to all of that, do you anticipate that the system administrator would come to this Parliament to explain how they arrived at the breakdown for all 32 Scottish local authorities, to ensure that they are getting an appropriate share of the pot of cash that is created across the UK? What thoughts has the Scottish Government given to ensuring that the data that we get and the cash that local authorities get will be accurate and appropriate for each local authority?

Our committee papers state:

“The SA will then distribute that funding to local authorities. It will calculate the ‘net efficient disposal costs’ (efficient disposal costs in an assessment year, less waste income for that year)”,

which is partly because certain aspects are reserved. The explanation goes on. I will not go on, convener, but it can get quite complex.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I want to say a couple of things before I directly answer your question. One of the issues that we brought to the table when we were talking about the regulations was the fact that a lot of our local authorities cover rural parts of Scotland and we do not want them to be disadvantaged in relation to urban local authorities. Therefore, we managed to get “must” changed to “may” in the regulations and that kind of thing, in order that that is taken into account in looking at the funding that is given as a result of the activities that are happening at a local level. Rurality is taken into account. Highland Council is in a completely different situation to Glasgow City Council with regard to how it manages its waste. That adaptation was made to ensure that the process did not disadvantage a lot of rural councils. I think that the Welsh Government was very sympathetic to that for similar reasons.

On your substantive point about the scrutiny of how the money is spent, allocations will be given to councils, so we will be able to scrutinise how that money is deployed at a council level. However, on the system administrator coming here to give evidence, it will be a UK-wide system administrator role, but I would say that it is probably good sense for them to engage with all four Parliaments to ensure that they are scrutinised as much as possible. Of course, the Scottish Government will want the data as it relates to our local authorities, and it will be essential that we have that.

David McPhee
link

We are working on a four-nations basis, which is why we have one scheme administrator. Obviously, that efficiency is a benefit of doing this at a UK level. Regulations were brought to this committee earlier in the year in relation to the data that we need to collect around EPR, so you can see that there is a process for that. As I said, my understanding—Alex Brown can correct me if I am wrong—is that there will be a public document that sets out how the calculations work, and it will be possible to interrogate that.

The cabinet secretary made a point about ensuring that we take account of our rurality and our specific issues, and we have worked very closely with the UK Government to do that.

It is supposed to be as transparent a scheme as possible, but we have still to get to the point where our local authorities know what they will get under that efficient and effective calculation. There will still be an engagement piece to make sure that we understand what that looks like and that we can test it to ensure that it is being calculated effectively.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

Clearly, we can engage in partnership with local authorities on scrutiny work in relation to that issue, but I asked that question because I wonder whether the quantum of cash that will be available for Scotland has been agreed, because we are talking about levies that will apply to businesses like Amazon, which operate across the UK and internationally. Will the remote and rural weighting kick in once the cash has been established for Scotland or will that weighting be at a pan-UK level, which would give Scotland a larger pot of cash to begin with? Those things become quite important. Also, at a later date, a local authority that felt that it was not getting a reasonable share of the pot of cash might want to come to this committee and ask what we can do about that. That is why I was asking about the scheme administrator. I am trying to future-proof parliamentary scrutiny as much as anything else.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

It is a very interesting question. I am thinking about some local authorities that burn a lot of their waste because there is no other way to dispose of it—those with island communities, for example—and I wonder whether they will be disadvantaged as a result of the proposal. Cabinet secretary, could you address that issue?

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

To be fair, I did not ask about incineration.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

I am not sure that I am able to go into that level of detail, but the point is that the system involves the costs of dealing with the waste being met by the fund, not the other way around. It is not a case of “This is what we collect and this what you’ve got”; it is, effectively, a case of “This is how much it is going to cost us to deal with this packaging, therefore this is the money that is required.”

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

That is helpful.

David McPhee
link

To be clear, the £120 million is not a fixed figure, and neither is the £1.2 billion—those are based on estimates. The process still has to be gone through, and it will build up to a determination of what the costs are. At that point, the producers pay those costs.

Bob Doris SNP Glasgow Maryhill and Springburn
link

I am delighted that, in a few years, we will be in a position to scrutinise all of this anyway. It is a really positive step, but I am thinking about the future situation in which such vast sums of cash are, quite rightly, going to our local authorities, and I expect that Parliament will want to keep an eye on how that money is being used and on whether local authorities are getting a reasonable share of the overall pot of cash.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

I have a brief question. Will importers of goods into this country have to pay the charge as their goods come in? Is that how we will ensure that there is a level playing field?

David McPhee
link

Anybody who sells here will pay the charge.

Gillian Martin SNP Aberdeenshire East
link

As with any regulations, anyone who is trading in the UK is subject to the laws.

Douglas Lumsden Con North East Scotland
link

So, it is not just producers of products who would have to pay, but importers of products, too.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

There are no more questions for the cabinet secretary. Normally I would suspend the meeting to allow the cabinet secretary to depart; however, I am going to push on, because we have quite a lot still to do. I thank you, cabinet secretary, and your various teams, including the longstanding members of your team who have attended all three of our evidence sessions, for coming this morning.

The next part of our meeting is to ask members’ views on whether the committee agrees with the Scottish Government’s proposal to consent to the UK Government making those regulations within devolved competence. Does anyone have views on that, or are we happy to approve the proposal? Bob Doris’s point was interesting, and the committee will want to keep an eye on how that cash is allocated. I am happy to listen to any comments.

As no member wishes to comment, is the committee content that the provisions that are set out in the notification should be included in the proposed UK SI?

Members indicated agreement.

Edward Mountain Con The Convener · Highlands and Islands
link

We will write to the Scottish Government to that effect.

That concludes our meeting in public. We will now go into private session.

11:59 Meeting continued in private until 12:14.

  1. 09:15 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
  2. 09:15 Passenger Railway Services (Public Ownership) Bill Bill debate · 91
  3. 10:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 82
  4. 11:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
  5. 11:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 50

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.