Good morning. As, I am sure, you can all appreciate, it has been a difficult balancing act to arrive at a Scottish pubs code that fulfils the intention of the 2021 act and meets the regulatory principles while, at the same time, fully addressing the concerns of stakeholders who, on certain matters, are not in agreement.
The task has been made more difficult by the legal challenges to the act, including the interim interdict orders that were in place, which meant that further targeted consultation has not been possible over an extended period of time. The legal challenge concluded only in March 2024, when the United Kingdom Supreme Court refused the petitioner’s application for permission to appeal.
As you know, stakeholders have concerns about the regulations—in particular, about the Scottish pubs code. I have been made aware of real concerns among tenants and pub companies about varying aspects of the code. That concerns me greatly.
I want to be clear that, had it not been for the legal requirement for Scottish ministers to lay the code by the deadline that is set out in section 4 of the 2021 act, which now requires me to lay the code as soon as is reasonably practicable, I would have withdrawn the regulations. I am not able to do that, so I have decided to create space and time for further dialogue on the Scottish pubs code within the tied pubs sector. I will do that by bringing forward an amending instrument, which I intend to lay this week, which changes the coming-into-force date of the code to 2025. That will provide time for Scottish ministers to carry out a further focused and targeted consultation on the Scottish pubs code. I intend to then introduce a further SSI making amendments to the Scottish pubs code.
I will keep the delay to a minimum and will engage with stakeholders to ensure that we can bring the legislation into force as soon as possible. I have already committed to introducing an amending SSI in response to technical issues that were raised by the Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee.
My intention is to engage fully with stakeholders on specific matters, so that the code delivers more effectively the improvements that the sector wishes to see. The purpose of the code is to improve the position of tied pub tenants. Therefore, it must not be—or be perceived to be—to the detriment of tenants. I should be clear, however, that I need the sector to work with me on this and to do so pragmatically. The Scottish pubs code needs to be fair and proportionate. My aim is for consensus, as far as that is possible.
The shape of the code has largely been predetermined by the 2021 act, which was approved unanimously by Parliament. We will not be reopening policy debates on what the act should have contained or whether legislation should be in place, or, indeed, on the full content of the code. I want to focus on key areas of concern.
I apologise to the committee for the somewhat unorthodox approach that we are having to take. However, I want to give my commitment on the official record that my officials and I will work with representatives of tied pub tenants and pub-owning businesses to improve the Scottish pubs code over the coming months, with a view to a revised code coming into force as early as possible. I expect that to be no later than early 2025.
Once in place, the code will be monitored and enforced by the Scottish pubs code adjudicator. Furthermore, the 2021 act requires that the work of the adjudicator and the code be reviewed within two years, and every three years thereafter. We are obliged, therefore, to continue to ensure that the code is proportionate and in keeping with the obligations of the act.
I welcome any questions, but I hope that the committee will bear in mind my comments in my opening statement and the likelihood that I will be reconsidering points that you have raised.