I am very happy to appear before the committee today to discuss petition PE1758, which calls for an end to greyhound racing in Scotland. Animal welfare is an important issue for the vast majority of people in Scotland. It is also an issue that the Scottish Government takes very seriously, and we are committed to the highest standards when it comes to the welfare of all animals in Scotland.
The Scottish Government recognises that there is support for action to address the welfare concerns associated with greyhound racing. This is why we agreed to include greyhound racing in the animal licensing consultation that we ran last year, when we sought views on the regulation of greyhound tracks in Scotland.
Our consultation confirmed that action on greyhound racing is strongly supported, with approximately half of respondents supporting licensing and half responding that they were not sure about it. Those who were not sure about licensing were of the opinion that it did not go far enough and that only a ban would be effective in protecting greyhound welfare. Over and above the consultation responses that we received, over 1,100 campaign responses were also sent to the Scottish Government animal welfare team, with campaign signatories calling for greyhound racing to end entirely.
This morning, I am sure that we will discuss the evidence for and against the prohibition of greyhound racing in Scotland and I welcome the opportunity to engage in those discussions. I advise the committee, however, that at this time the Scottish Government is not persuaded of the need to ban greyhound racing in Scotland. In particular, we are not convinced that such a ban is a proportionate and fair response to the animal welfare concerns arising from the practice.
As the members of this committee know, in Scotland we now have only one active greyhound track—at Thornton stadium in Fife. Thornton runs as an independent track, in that it does not operate under the rules of the Greyhound Board of Great Britain. Attendance at Thornton both by those who are racing dogs and those who are spectating has been declining for many years as interest in the sport wanes and as public opinion against greyhound racing shifts. Although on-site gambling is still a traditional part of race nights at Thornton, it takes place on a considerably lesser scale than occurs at Greyhound Board of Great Britain venues, where races are often televised, competition is intense and gambling happens on a commercial scale.
The central argument for prohibiting greyhound racing in Scotland is the published Greyhound Board of Great Britain statistics on greyhound deaths and injuries attributed to racing. The Scottish Government agrees that the statistics presented are unacceptable and that any greyhound injury or death is something that must be addressed. However, it must be recognised that currently we do not have verifiable, comparable data for Thornton stadium. The statistics for greyhound injuries and deaths relate to those incurred as part of the much larger-scale greyhound racing that takes place in England. We must therefore caution against making assumptions about the current situation in Scotland and legislating to ban a sport, however contentious, without a sound evidence base for doing so.
As far as the Scottish Government is aware, no complaints have been made to the Scottish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals about the activities at Thornton stadium and no enforcement action has been taken due to animal welfare concerns against the operators of the venue. Again, I would stress that these factors must be borne in mind when considering the case for the proportionality of a ban in Scotland.
I will end there and I am happy to take part in the conversation as we go forward.