We have done a great deal in this area. The first thing to say is that the tribunal, as with other tribunals, is inquisitorial and, although it is not wholly adversarial, which would be more akin to a court environment, it is both inquisitorial and adversarial.
The adversarial component is present in that there are two parties, both of whom are entitled to representatives, to bring evidence and to examine the evidence of other witnesses and make submissions. That is the adversarial element.
The inquisitorial element, and the fact that the tribunal can regulate its own proceedings in many ways, is what makes us unique. We can change the shape of the tribunal to accommodate the facts and circumstances of the case. When I started as president, there was no real rhythm to the number of days that it might take for a case to be decided. It could be anywhere from two to five or seven days. It seemed to me that we needed to reduce the amount of time that people spend in a hearing room. It is hard for me, and I hope that I know what I am doing. Can you imagine if it is about your whole life? Children ask us, “Why do adults think that we are not allowed to get upset when they are talking about things that upset us?” These are highly sensitive environments.
We therefore put in place a number of pre-hearing steps to reduce the amount of oral evidence. We have written witness statements and outline submissions, so that before everyone comes into the hearing, each side knows what the other side is arguing and what the other witnesses have to say.
More recently—the plan was to pilot this in 2020 but it had to be delayed—I introduced documentary evidence guidance. Four folders as thick as those that I have with me would be the documentary evidence. It was about trying to stop things like putting into evidence a 50-page handbook if we had to refer only to page 3, or stop putting in primary 1 to P7 school reports if we had to look at a secondary school placement at S4.
It was about educating people to help them to understand that the process is a judicial process, not an extension of education, or health. A hearing is not a case conference meeting. A case would be tested evidentially and there would be a conclusion. A lot of information was also put together for unrepresented parties, because although I have said that parties are mainly all represented, we have seen a rise in the number of unrepresented parties.
I started to formulate everything that I was asked and I put in an information note to explain what witnesses could expect to happen in a hearing and how they should behave. For example, we would say to a witness for an independent school that they are not here to give evidence to promote the school’s position but to support us in understanding what the child’s additional support needs are.
Trying to steer witnesses better is a journey. I have not eaten very much this morning because I was coming here and I was nervous. Any witness who appears in any setting in which a decision is going to be made will be nervous, no matter how good their evidence is. Our job is to make the environment as non-confrontational as possible to assist that witness. Everyone wants the best evidence. I have a principle of dignity and respect, which means that both parties are to behave in a dignified and respectful manner. We do not use court language. We do not talk about cross-examination; we ask whether there are any questions for the witness. We have stripped out all of the jargon. We do not permit multiple questions to be asked of children. For children, one set of questions is agreed by the parties and there is one questioner. The child does not have to be exposed to having to take a turn.
We have the option of a one-to-one room where the child can give their evidence without seeing everyone, although they know that everyone is out there. That is a very popular choice for parents and for children. We also make it clear that the child and young person is at the centre of the process.
However, we cannot rub out the journey to the tribunal. I do not know the correct answer to this, but some people say that we should be the last resort, while others argue that we should be the first. I have had parents say to me, “If I had just known and had come to you first, I would have saved myself years.” Disputes can last for years. I do not know the answer to that—and because it concerns a matter of policy I cannot comment—but I can see that there is an argument either way.
11:15
I have read the comments in some of the submissions to the committee. I do not regulate what parties decide to rely on in their documentary evidence. I say that there should be no duplication. If someone puts in a 50-page report I tell them that I will ask them about pages 1, 2, 3 and so on, all the way through. They have now got that message and so we have seen the bundles of papers reduce in size.
However, the moment that a document enters the process in written form it becomes part of the evidence and the other party has the right to test it. At tribunals we see the broadest expression of people’s rights, and they should be able to argue their cases. Whoever a party is, they should be able to test the evidence that is presented and to make submissions. In many ways that sits outside the control of the tribunal, but all the efficiencies have reduced the number of days required, so it is now more common for us to have two-day hearings and we would rarely have five or seven-day hearings.
Once it is better understood who we are, and the fact that the tribunal is of a judicial nature, things might change. No one ever likes coming to a tribunal. It would be highly unusual for someone to say, “I am excited because I have three tribunals coming up.” I do not think that even the tribunal judges would be too excited about that, because the evidence in our hearings is so intense.
The other point that I would make is that it is common for experts to be present at our proceedings. If we look at the example of the children’s hearings system, that is not a common phenomenon there, or even in some other jurisdictions. However, we commonly have to hear expert evidence, which adds its own depth to proceedings. We are providing a forum in which two parties who cannot agree have an opportunity to argue their points before a specialist body that is independent of them, which goes on to say, “Here are the facts. They are facts; they are not disputed any more. We have found them to be factual. Here is our decision and here are our reasons for it.”