We get lots of negative comments about part-time timetables and informal exclusions. Parents are regularly coming to take their children out of school for the safety and wellbeing of the child, but that means that the parent has to come out of work and the child is not accessing education. When I challenged that from a parental perspective several years ago, I asked to see how it was being recorded on the school register, and it was “Sent home sick with permission.” It is not recorded that the parent does not want to remove the child but the school is refusing to keep the child in the school environment.
That also has a huge poverty impact, because parents lose their jobs. It is difficult to sustain work and maintain good physical and mental health, because, if a parent cannot go to work and access respite because their child is either on a part-time timetable or is being sent home most days of the week, they feel that that fundamental right to education has been taken from them. That is a huge issue.
One of our parents, who engages with a lot of other parents through her child’s primary school, gave a wee bit of input, which covers a lot of it. If it is okay, I will pass on what she says. She says that many families that she speaks to continue to fall between the presumption of mainstreaming and special needs education. The first of the young people who were thrust into mainstream education were allowed to fail due to inconsistency or lack of support, especially in the early years, despite strong evidence of need and promises of support.
It seems that it is now almost a requirement that a child must first fail badly before they are seriously considered for a specialist placement. The parent said that she has even heard that said to families from within education. In the meantime, the child and the family endure so much trauma—trauma is a huge issue—that it takes years to recover from it, if they ever do. Evidence also tells us that the school staff are traumatised, as we see in staff absences, unsustainable stress and even some staff leaving the teaching profession altogether.
The other extreme, which the parent says she has seen with her youngest child—she has three autistic children—is when the child gets a specialist placement but the bar of expectation is set so low and assumptions are made about abilities, or the lack of them, and so much potential remains undiscovered that life chances and outcomes shrink and become limited. That impacts on the emotional and mental health and wellbeing of the young person and the family.
The young people do not even get a chance to choose subjects, because many of them cannot be offered within the special needs placement and, due to cuts, the model of going to other schools is becoming less of an option. Traditionally, children from the special needs school system would go to other schools to sit highers, because they might not be available in their school. However, we know that mainstream education, especially in secondary, would not and does not suit many of our highly anxious yet highly able young people.
We therefore need a model of education that can better differentiate and celebrate the strengths of all our young people and offer consistent support that is not removed when they begin to succeed. They succeed because they have good support, not because they suddenly do not need support any more, yet it is often removed just as it is beginning to work. Supports are regularly removed once the person starts to make some progress. Would we take a ramp away from someone who required to use a wheelchair to access the room?
The parent says that, instead of presuming mainstreaming for all, we need to presume that young people have potential and, as a collective of families and services, find creative ways to unlock and celebrate that potential, however it looks. To do that, we need to have trained staff who not only understand the many diverse presentations of neurodivergence but can also show genuine compassion and acceptance of our young people and their families where they are, even when that is not easy.
She says that we also need more peer support and advocacy so that families feel empowered, feel part of the solution and work with services rather than fight for them. No one wins when the current battle rages on and on. Energies need to be conserved and used wisely through people working together to the same end. That can be summed up as a thriving next generation of young adults who are differently abled being proud to be who they are without apology or limit.