The answer to Ross Greer’s question is as complex as the multitude of additional support needs. I agree with Susan Quinn that we have to be charitable to local authorities, given the plight that they face. There is not an endless pot of money, and the level and complexity of additional support needs are growing every year. However, in my experience, the way that local authorities and schools across the country work is inconsistent. There is no single method of allocation of ASN resource to schools across each local authority. I will give an example from my local authority of where I see it working, to a degree, within the limits of the pot of money.
I agree with Mike Corbett that, if a young person has a label, they will automatically get support. If the local authority does not provide that, the likelihood that the matter will go to a tribunal is very high. Local authorities will therefore put all their resources, first and foremost, into ensuring that those who have a diagnosis are supported as outlined by the medical professionals.
People will always say that they do not get enough support, but, in general, we can assume that those youngsters I described earlier, who may be in a severe and complex needs facility or part of a mainstream school, will get a very good level of support if they have severe and complex needs. The trouble for local authorities is that, when more youngsters have that diagnosis and therefore get that level of support, even if the facility is more flexible than most mainstream provision, that diverts most of the money to that cohort of young people and away from the ever-increasing numbers of pupils with mid-range additional support needs in the classroom. Teachers and additional support needs staff are most concerned about that group, because there is a lack of suitable staff and training to deal with the ever-increasing numbers in the mid-range.
To be fair to local authorities, we have to ask how they should decide where the money goes. In discussions between the local authority, central team staffing and school staffing about the individual needs of youngsters in a class or in the school, there will always be a degree of disagreement over the need. For example, a member of staff might try to keep the pot available for 10 schools, but a headteacher or, usually, a depute will make an argument that is based on the needs of their individual school. There is not enough money to provide the level of support that each individual school will ask for, so that dichotomy goes on all the time. That is why nobody is ever happy. Local authorities have to spread the money increasingly thinly, which does not make them look good, and schools are not getting as much money or staffing as they need to cope with the needs that they see every day, so that is not working either.
On top of that, a political game is played in trying to maintain staffing levels in individual schools even though that might not be the best use of resources for the local authority as a whole. I will give you an example of what I am talking about. If a youngster comes into S1 with a particular level of need, the local authority and the high school might agree that X number of hours will be set aside for that young person. Although it will never be agreed that it is enough, that support, which might be one to one, will stay with the youngster. There is an argument—and there is mention of this in the guidance—that, as they grow in confidence, experience and familiarity with the secondary school setting, they should develop a degree of independence so that they do not constantly need to have somebody sitting with them one to one. In fact, if that was the case for four years, the system would have failed.
For the majority of those in the mid-range, if an ASN member of staff has sat with them one on one for four years, the system will have failed because we will not have prepared them for life after school. That is not to say that we should remove their support by the end of S4, but we should be able to use the ASN member of staff differently, given the appropriate training. I talked earlier about the need to set aside time for such staff to talk to teachers. By S2, some of their time could be diverted to help others in the class. By S3, even more time could be diverted and they could help three or four people.
However, that level of communication requires CLPL and time to talk. That level of nuance, which would distribute the resource better, does not exist. I go back to the point that I made in response to the first question. If we set aside some time to allow that to happen, the resource would be better distributed overall and it would benefit far more youngsters within the limited pot that the Scottish Government and the local authorities will always have.