Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Looked-after Young People (Aftercare) (PE1958)

Wednesday 8 November 2023 Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee About 09:30–10:00 Petitions 33 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

33 contributions
Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Good morning, and welcome to the 16th meeting in 2023 of the Citizen Participation and Public Petitions Committee. Our first agenda item is consideration of continued petitions. The first of those is PE1958, on extending aftercare for previously looked-after young people and removing the continuing care age cap. The petition was lodged by Jasmin-Kasaya Pilling on behalf of Who Cares? Scotland, and I am delighted to see that Jasmin, who gave evidence at a previous meeting of the committee, is in the public gallery today.

The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to extend aftercare provision in Scotland to previously looked-after young people who left care before their 16th birthday, on the basis of individual need; to extend continuing care throughout care-experienced people’s lives, on the basis of individual need; and to ensure that care-experienced people are able to enjoy lifelong rights and achieve equality with non-care-experienced people. That includes ensuring that the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child and the findings of the Promise are fully implemented in Scotland.

We last considered the petition back in May. Following that session, I am delighted to welcome to the meeting Natalie Don, the Minister for Children, Young People and Keeping the Promise, and, from the Scottish Government, Sarah Corbett, the care experience policy manager, and Cara Cooper, the head of the unit for a good childhood. Thank you all for joining us. As I said, we also have the petitioner with us in the gallery.

Minister, I understand that you want to say a few words in opening, before we move to questions. I am delighted for you to do that. Over to you.

Natalie Don-Innes SNP The Minister for Children, Young People and Keeping the Promise · Renfrewshire North and West
link

Thank you, convener, and good morning, all. I am grateful to the committee for inviting me to give evidence. I welcome the opportunity to discuss the proposals in PE1958 to extend aftercare for previously looked-after young people and to remove the continuing care age cap.

I understand that the committee first discussed the petition on 31 May 2023 and that members listened in particular to the importance of ensuring that individuals are aware of their rights. The commencement of the incorporation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child into Scots law gives us all, across the chamber, a golden opportunity to continue to promote public awareness and understanding of the rights of the child and the entitlements of those leaving care to the right help and support.

Listening to the challenges that are experienced by our young people who move on from care must and will continue to inform our approach to reducing the variation in the support that they receive.

Two weeks ago, it was care experience week. Appropriately, given the focus of what the committee heard in its previous session on the petition and some of what we will no doubt discuss today, the theme for this year’s events was lifelong rights for care-experienced people. The First Minister and I attended different events at which we met young people with lived experience and some practitioners who work alongside them. I have been really moved by many of the meetings and discussions that I have had so far with our care-experienced community. Equally, I have been wholly impressed with their passion and dedication to help to ensure that their experiences influence positive change for others.

During care experience week, the Scottish Throughcare and Aftercare Forum, which is known as STAF, launched its 100 days of listening consultation to understand what people with experience of care—and the workforce that supports them—need and want to happen for the Promise to be kept. I am pleased to say that my officials are working in close partnership with STAF to take forward that work. We are actively listening to people with lived experience to understand what it will take to remove the stigma and barriers that our care-experienced community face, so that they can achieve equality with their non-care-experienced peers.

In this year’s programme for government, we committed to launching a public consultation on what the broad package of support for care-experienced young people should include to support them into adulthood. The consultation will be launched in spring 2024 and will build on what we hear through the 100 days of listening consultation.

I want to reassure the committee that we are determined to review and co-design the policies and supports for people with experience of care alongside those with lived experience, so that we get it right for our young people and that they feel loved, cared for and respected and can flourish into independent adults.

We recognise the particular financial challenges that our care-experienced young people face when they move on to independent adult living, which is why, on 26 October, the First Minister announced our plans to consult on a care leaver payment of £2,000, to help young people transitioning from care to independent living.

I am acutely aware that our work across Government to keep the Promise requires a cohesive and co-ordinated approach across all our care, health, education and justice services, and I am extremely grateful to the carers, the workforce, the agencies and the stakeholders who work hard to provide the best environment for our children and young people in care. I also put on record my admiration and appreciation for the young people themselves, many of whom I have met during my time in this role, who continue to share their experiences of care and to champion the rights of people with care experience.

Finally, I welcome the committee’s interest in the petition, and I will be happy to answer any questions that members may have.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you very much, minister.

We most recently considered the petition on 31 May, when we reflected on the evidence that we had taken in April from the petitioner and from Who Cares? Scotland, CELCIS, the Children and Young People’s Commissioner Scotland and The Promise Scotland. That was a striking round-table session, which persuaded the committee of the fundamental decency and drive of Jasmin’s petition.

I think that you have already answered this question but, to open the discussion, will you provide a clear assertion of where the extending of eligibility for continuing care and aftercare through legislation sits in the Government’s priorities?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

As I said in my opening remarks, the care that people receive is inconsistent, and we need to work on that. It is important that we listen to what young people and care-experienced people need.

I want to make it clear that “aftercare” refers to the advice, guidance and assistance that are provided to care leavers, which can include, but are not restricted to, advice and guidance on or assistance with the securing of accommodation, education and employment opportunities and financial support. As I said, we understand that there are inconsistencies there. For example, when young people leave care before their 16th birthday, they do not always benefit from smooth and well-supported transitions, which can leave them less well prepared for adulthood than their peers. It also means that they have no legal entitlement to the aftercare support that would have been available to them if they had left care after their 16th birthday.

The Promise makes it clear that lifelong advocacy is required to enable people with care experience to realise their rights, to thrive in life and to have a well-supported transition to adulthood. Throughout my time in this role, I have heard loud and clear that care experience stays with you for life. Therefore, such support needs to be available for people to tap into at key points in their life.

It is absolutely a priority for us to get it right for care-experienced people. As I have mentioned, we will take the learning from STAF’s 100 days of listening and the consultation that we will embark on in 2024 as we look to further expand our work in this area.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

If Cara Cooper or Sarah Corbett wishes to come in, they should let me know. The minister may also invite them to come in.

I think that I follow what you are saying, minister. Through the listening exercise and the consultation, you are exploring ways in which the priority of extending eligibility for continuing care and aftercare could be realised or delivered. That may or may not be through legislation. Is that where we are at? Do you see there being a role for legislation or do you think that, through the work that you are doing, there might be another route to achieving the outcome?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

I might bring in officials on whether a legislative route would have to be used. I can see other options, given that we already expect such provision to be available for care-experienced people of a certain age. Our Promise bill, which we have agreed will go through Parliament in the current parliamentary session, will provide an opportunity for legislative changes.

We expect to introduce that towards the end of next year, giving plenty of time for a lot of different pieces of work that are going on, to see what would be included in the bill. However, on the specific question whether the route would have to be legislative or not, I will hand over to my officials.

09:45

Cara Cooper Scottish Government
link

As the minister has explained, we are currently exploring what avenues we need to go down to improve the broadest package of support that we provide for our young people with experience of care.

On your question about legislation, and on our commitment to keep the Promise, we have the forthcoming Promise bill, which is slated for 2025 and through which we would be able to take forward any legislative changes that are required. There is the work, which the minister has already referenced, on our partnership with staff and the 100 days of listening, which is just one part of how we are engaging with all our stakeholders, and we are triangulating the voices of our young people with lived experience, the workforce that delivers that work and our partners.

The public consultation, which will be launched in spring, will be a broad-ranging consultation to ensure that we open up as widely as possible on what the current landscape looks like and what changes we need to make to effect transformational change and for us to keep the Promise. The Promise bill would be our most appropriate legislative vehicle. If we need to make legislative changes, if there is policy that needs to be updated or if we need a statutory footing, that is where we would consider that and take it forward.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Good morning, minister and panel members. Is the Scottish Government considering amending section 66 of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 to remove the need for a young person to still be in care on their 16th birthday to access support and to remove the age limit of 26 for accessing aftercare?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

The aim of continuing care is to provide young people with a more graduated transition out of care, reducing the risk of multiple simultaneous disruptions occurring in their lives, while trying to maintain supportive relationships around them. I will make the distinction between that and aftercare, which refers to the advice, guidance and assistance that is provided to care leavers, as I alluded to in my answer to the previous question. As I said, we understand that there are inconsistencies.

The Promise has made it very clear that lifelong advocacy is required for people with care experience and, as I have said, we have heard loud and clear the calls from the care-experienced community.

I feel as though I am repeating myself, but I want to make it clear that we are determined to review and co-design the policies and supports and, if necessary, to legislate for people with experience of care, alongside those with lived experience and the practitioners who work with them. We will do so to ensure that we get it absolutely right for those people.

In response to your question, we would certainly consider amending the 2014 act, but that will be worked through once we have further information from the 100 days of listening and the consultation. Those measures will be considered if we think that that is right for children and young people, but I emphasise that we are listening to the voices of the care experienced and the organisations that are leading that work.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

Thank you. I will probably get the same answer for this question, as well. Will the Scottish Government consider amending regulations to increase eligibility for continued care beyond 21 years?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

In my previous answer, I made the distinction between continuing care and aftercare. That can certainly be considered. There might be difficulties with somebody being placed in their place of care past the age of 21, because they are getting into adulthood at that point. That certainly would be considered, but the focus at the moment is on providing aftercare and continuing support throughout the lives of care-experienced people.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Maurice Golden has a question, which I think that I have heard two answers to already, so we will see if he can drill down and get the definitive one.

Maurice Golden Con North East Scotland
link

To recap, there will be a consultation on a bill about the Promise by the end of 2024, with the bill to be introduced in 2025. Please clarify whether that is the case. If that is the case, what will the key themes of the consultation on that bill be?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

I may hand over to my officials to talk about the consultation, because we have not finished designing that yet. The bill itself will be based on the keeping the Promise implementation plan, which sets out a vision for delivering the Promise by 2030. There are 14 top-level actions within that plan and about 80 other recommendations, which cut across all parts of Government.

During my time in this role, there has been a much greater focus on managing the cross-portfolio work on the Promise. We are very aware that it cuts across various ministerial portfolios. There is a cabinet subcommittee on the Promise and there is real evidence of us working together to try to achieve our aims. The actions in the Promise implementation plan that aim to reduce poor outcomes focus on poverty, homelessness, poor health—which can often include poor mental health—offending, school exclusion, educational attainment and low employability.

As I said, there are many aspects to keeping the Promise. Many of those will be considered as part of the consultation and any that require legislative change will be included in the Promise bill.

Cara Cooper Scottish Government
link

To be clear, the consultation that we are discussing today is our PFG commitment regarding the support that is available for young people who are transitioning out of care and into adulthood. It is closely linked to how we keep the Promise. I hope that that is a helpful clarification.

We are still in the process of designing that consultation. It will be informed by our on-going engagement with all stakeholders, particularly with our young people with experience of care and with the workforce. The consultation will look at the broadest package of support that is in place for young people with experience of care. We will look at the current policy and legislative landscapes and will really listen so that we can analyse what is or is not working well. We will look carefully at what tangible changes are needed to improve the consistency of care for our young people, as well as improving their life chances and outcomes.

We hear loud and clear that things are not working well. The Promise tells us that, as did the independent care review. This is about drilling down to a more granular level to effect real change.

Within that, it is likely that we will consider the definition of “care experienced”. Committee members may be aware that we currently have a legal definition of a “care leaver”, but we do not have a definition of “care experienced” that is used consistently across the country. We recognise the need to address that challenge. At the moment, the Promise uses what we call the University of St Andrews definition of “care experienced”. It is really important that we get that definition right and that it is universally understood and used, so that young people can realise their fullest rights and have the opportunity to access the right support, at the right time, to improve their life chances and outcomes.

The minister already touched on the on-going work that The Promise Scotland is doing on lifelong advocacy, which is very much the theme of the petition. From our perspective, that is about ensuring the right support at the right time for the right people, regardless of whether someone left care before their 16th birthday or whether they might need support beyond the age of 26—those are the rough parameters for continuing care and aftercare at the moment.

We will consider all those aspects in the consultation that will happen in the spring. It will also be informed by information that we obtain from our current live consultation on the care leaver payment, which the minister referred to in her opening remarks. The First Minister announced that payment during care experience week. It is a PFG commitment as well, and it is one part of the broadest package that we have in place to support young people as they leave care and move into independent adult living. That consultation is due to close in January, so we will be able to use the information that we synthesise from there to inform and help us to design our later consultation.

As the minister has already said, we are absolutely committed to working alongside our young people, as well as the broadest range of our stakeholders, to ensure that we get the consultation questions right. It will not just be a case of my team designing a consultation that will then go out. It will go through rigorous conversations and robust dialogue with a range of stakeholders to ensure that we frame the questions in the right way for us to get the best possible sources of information to tell us how we should design the policy and improve the landscape.

Maurice Golden Con North East Scotland
link

Thank you. You have also answered my other question on updating definitions, which is helpful.

The minister mentioned educational attainment. Is she comfortable with current educational attendance?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

I do not have the relevant figures in front of me, but I know that a lot of good work to improve things is happening on the ground, through the Promise and other initiatives. I have been on several visits where there are virtual schools and different set-ups for learning to encourage or assist care-experienced people who might find it difficult to attend school, for whatever reason. I hope that that work will make an impact on the figures as we move forward, with the main aim being to improve the lives of care-experienced young people.

I will bring in my official to expand on the figures.

Cara Cooper Scottish Government
link

In the figures for 2021 we saw a narrowing of the gap in overall educational outcomes for our children and young people with experience of care, but we understand that more work needs to be done there.

As the minister mentioned, there are virtual school headteacher networks where we bring headteachers together to take a deeper look at challenges in relation to young people’s attendance and attainment at school. We also have initiatives in place such as the care-experienced children and young people fund, from which money goes directly to local authorities to help them to target resources where they feel that they will be best used and are most needed to support young people with experience of care. That covers young people right through until they are 26.

We recognise that although the gap in educational outcomes is closing, there is still work to do. We recognise, too, that good work is going on to support care-experienced young people to remain in school and avoid exclusion where possible.

Maurice Golden Con North East Scotland
link

Thanks for that. It would be useful if you could share with the committee the data that you hold on that, ideally broken down by local authority, if that is possible.

Minister, are you confident that local authorities have both the facilities and the staffing resources to provide that enhanced care package?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

Absolutely. I have already referred to the visits that I have been on. Fantastic work is going on across our local authorities, who are best placed to understand what is needed in their areas. As I have already mentioned, the Promise covers many different aspects and policy areas. Local authorities have been very good at understanding what is needed in their areas and taking action accordingly. I have seen a lot of positive work on my visits, and our aim is to expand that work across the country. Obviously, capacity issues might affect that approach.

I appreciate that there has been an increase in the demand for, and the complexity of, the work that social work staff undertake and that currently there are recruitment and retention challenges there. Although local authorities are responsible for planning their workforces and ensuring that they have appropriate staff levels, we understand the issues that the sector faces, including that increase in demand. A number of actions are therefore being taken to improve matters.

10:00

A joint working group with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities has been established to address the issues immediately affecting the workforce. Members will be aware of the proposals for a national care service and, within that, the establishment of a national social work agency that would support and invest in the profession. However, I appreciate that that will not help immediately; it is a longer-term approach.

We have set up that joint working group with COSLA. We also have a national approach to workforce planning, which we hope will help to achieve the optimal future workforce capacity. A short-life working group has been created to oversee the development of that work and to produce up-to-date data on social work vacancies and demand for services there. I hope that that will allow us to facilitate planning and resource allocation at national level to meet the expected increase in demand. A workforce improvement plan has also been developed to address acute recruitment and retention challenges, and it will include workforce planning and workforce vacancy data.

Throughout all those initiatives, we are working collaboratively with COSLA, social work departments and the various agencies involved in the sector, which is hugely valued and around which the Government has created its aims and priorities. We are absolutely switched on to those and are trying to improve matters.

Maurice Golden Con North East Scotland
link

Thank you, minister. It would be useful if that data on staff retention and recruitment, broken down by local authority, could be shared. I appreciate the measures that you are seeking to deploy.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness and Nairn
link

Good morning, everyone. The petition was lodged on 6 September 2022, which is 14 months ago. Minister, at the moment we do not have any written response from you or your predecessor on the petitioner’s specific asks. The petition seeks to extend aftercare provision in Scotland to previously looked-after children who left care before their 16th birthdays, and to extend continuing care throughout care-experienced people’s lives according to their individual needs. The crux of the petition is that care should be based on need, not the arbitrary occurrence of people’s dates of birth or their attaining a certain age.

If, as I understand it, your plan is to introduce the bill in 2024-25, it will not become law until 2025. It might not come into force until some time after that—typically, 2026 or later. That would mean that about four years will have elapsed between the petitioner making her plea to the Parliament, which it is our duty to interrogate, and the occurrence of any potential response. That obvious problem raises two questions. First, what can the Scottish Government do now to end the practice of young people being taken off compulsory supervision orders ahead of their 16th birthdays? Who Cares? Scotland has given us worrying examples of that problem happening in practice. With respect, although your good intentions are admirable and absolutely clear, I think that the petitioner wants concrete actions.

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

I completely appreciate that. I have already talked about the discrepancies that the member has mentioned, and it is good that the petition is highlighting those and the need for further support. Again, it is not clear whether that would have to be done through a legislative route. If that is the case then, as the member has mentioned, that would happen at a later date. However, there could be opportunities to improve guidance on and change the structures around the issue prior to that. Again, that will be defined by the work that I have already mentioned on the consultation and on listening to stakeholders.

We are taking actions at the moment. We are updating guidance to simplify language and improve the practice in continuing and aftercare services and provision. We are working closely with stakeholders, including young people with lived experience, providers and the workforce, to better understand the barriers and what might need to be done to remove them. The moving on change programme that I have referred to is actively seeking and facilitating opportunities to further take on board the views of people with experience of care. As much as I understand that you want us to move quickly, we need to get it right. We need to ensure that there is capacity and that it works for our children and young people.

I believe that that might answer your question, but I will bring in my officials in case there is anything that I have not touched on.

Cara Cooper Scottish Government
link

No, minister, I think that you have covered everything.

Our whole approach to improving outcomes for children and young people in Scotland is underpinned by the getting it right for every child approach, which places the child or young person at the centre of all decisions that are taken and made for that young person. On young people being taken off their compulsory supervision orders on their 16th birthday, our guidance is clear that, when young people are coming to that point, what is best for the child or young person should be placed at the centre when those conversations are being had, when care placements are being reviewed, when we are looking at how that young person will transfer into independent adult living and when we are considering how we support that young person as they grow and develop. We have very clear guidance in place that the child or young person should be at the heart of all those decisions.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness and Nairn
link

I do not think that anyone doubts the good intentions of the Scottish Government, but the trouble is that the question that I asked has not really been answered. The question is, what will be done now to deal with that anomaly? The answer that you gave, minister, was that you do not yet know clearly whether the change can be made without legislation. It seems to me that that is a yes or no question: either legislation is required to make that change or it is not. If it is not—you have suggested that that is something that you are considering—surely it is your duty to give us clarity on that specific question. If the answer is that you do not need to make changes to the law, the petitioners will say, “Get on with it; do it now.”

In response to Mr Golden, who quite rightly asked whether there is a capacity issue, your first answer was no, there is not. So, if there is the capacity in local authorities to provide the care, by not acting now we are allowing the anomaly to remain in place for another three, four or five years.

I appreciate that you have not been in post for a particularly long period of time—things take time in Government, as I well remember—but, nonetheless, with respect, your predecessor and you have had 14 months to give an answer to this question. The lack of clarity on the specific question is unfortunate. I would be most grateful if we could get a specific reply in writing. As I said, if legislation is not required, the petitioners will say, “Get on with it; what is the problem?”

In effect, you have admitted that this is an anomaly—I think that “inconsistency” was the word that you used. It seems to me completely anomalous.

We have clear evidence that many young people do not know their rights, and they do not know that, by being taken off a CSO, they will lose their rights. How can they be expected to know that? They certainly do not know about the incorporation of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. Why would a 15-year-old have any knowledge of that? The idea that the fact that that was done in the Scottish Parliament makes a blind bit of a difference to young people knowing their rights seems to me to be completely fallacious.

It is our job to press for answers for the petitioner. You have had 14 months. We have not got anything in writing. We have not got clarity on that question. With respect, minister, if you are not able to give that clarity today, I would be most grateful if you could write to the committee as soon as possible to answer that simple question. To me, that then determines whether we might want to take the matter further in various ways, such as having a debate in the Scottish Parliament about it.

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

There are a number of points to address in that. On the issue of young people not knowing their rights in this area, in my previous response, I referred to updating the guidance, the intention of which includes ensuring that it is more accessible for young people. With regard to young people being aware of their rights under the UNCRC in particular, I have visited a lot of schools, and that is something that is on the agenda. Children are talking about their rights and are aware of their rights. I do not want to generalise, and there might be schools or areas where that is not always the case, but I can say that the young people in the schools that I have visited are very switched on to the issue. That is facilitated by a number of fantastic youth groups and organisations that are working to promote those rights to young people.

Outwith the Government’s support and aftercare provision, a number of advocacy schemes are currently in operation. There is a national helpline operated by Who Cares? Scotland, which is funded by the Scottish Government, and there is the national children’s hearings advocacy scheme, which was enacted in November 2020. So, there are ways for care-experienced young people to access support. However, as I have said, what I have heard so far is that there are inconsistencies. We know that some sort of change will be required, and it is likely that that will be legislative change, but that will be decided by the consultation and the work that is under way just now. I am more than happy to write back to the committee with further information on that.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Mr Torrance, is there anything that you would like to come back on?

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I have one final question. What is the Scottish Government doing to ensure that the provisions of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014 are fully implemented in practice, as well as in law?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

Guidance for that is absolutely explicit with regard to our expectation that corporate parents should work collaboratively with young people to deliver the integrated support that is required. The emphasis of that legislation, the regulations and the guidance is on ensuring that the young person is supported to develop in all aspects of their life.

As I have said, the guidance is absolutely explicit that the principles of getting it right for every child should be at the core of that pathway assessment, including everyone working together in local areas and across Scotland to improve those outcomes for children.

The children’s services planning strategic leads network—that is a very long title; I am surprised that I got it all out—is co-chaired with the Scottish Government. That is a national forum that promotes collaboration, shared learning and improvement activity at national and local level, between and across children’s services planning partnerships, the Scottish Government and key stakeholders. That is all done with the aim of strengthening the development, delivery and accountability of the children’s services planning partnerships, in line with the 2014 act.

On behalf of ministers, the Scottish Government undertakes a review of children’s services plans every three years against criteria set out in statutory guidance. That is all to support improvements at local and national level. We then publish a report that summarises areas of strength and areas where development is needed. I think that the most recent report was published in July 2022.

Again, we believe that lived experience should be absolutely core to all of that, so we have involved care-experienced young people directly in co-designing and co-producing services, so that they support care leavers effectively.

A lot of work is under way, with scrutiny and regular checks to ensure that the act is being implemented in practice.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you, minister. We have listened carefully, and, in the comprehensive responses that you have given, a number of our questions have been answered without our having to put them, so that brings us to the end of our questions. Is there anything else that you feel that we might not have touched on that you want to add before we conclude?

Natalie Don-Innes SNP Renfrewshire North and West
link

I do not think so. I would just thank you for the opportunity to come along. As I have said, the petition has done a really good job of highlighting some of the inconsistencies, and I look forward to working on that and working towards our shared goals.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

Thank you all for being with us this morning.

Are members content for us to reflect on the evidence and any further submissions that we get and consider them afresh at a subsequent meeting?

Members indicated agreement.

Jackson Carlaw Con The Convener · Eastwood
link

We will suspend briefly to allow the witnesses to leave.

10:15 Meeting suspended.

10:16 On resuming—

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 33
  2. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  3. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  4. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 5
  5. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  6. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  8. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 3
  9. 10:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 4
  10. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 8
  11. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.