Thank you very much indeed, convener, for that warm welcome. It would be useful if I gave an overview of why we took that decision way back in 2011. As you know, the Scottish National Party made a manifesto commitment in 2007 and another in 2011 that we would dual the A9 between Perth and Inverness and upgrade the A96, although it did not specifically say that in the 2011 manifesto; it said that we would have a dual carriageway between Inverness and Aberdeen.
After the 2011 election, I was appointed as the Cabinet Secretary for Infrastructure and Capital Investment in the Scottish Government. That meant that I had responsibility for the national infrastructure investment plan, which was due for update later in 2011. The infrastructure investment plan covers every aspect of capital investment right across government, including housing, climate change, schools, universities, roads, rail and other aspects of transport, as well as broadband. The document is wide ranging.
When it came to the roads budget specifically, I looked at how we could implement the manifesto commitment. I set a strategic objective for Transport Scotland and the Government that, at the earliest possible opportunity, we should link the seven cities in Scotland—Glasgow, Edinburgh, Perth, Stirling, Dundee, Aberdeen and Inverness; we now have eight because Dunfermline is a city—either by dual carriageway or by motorway. The reason for that was fivefold: to stimulate economic growth; to improve the overall productivity of the Scottish economy; to reduce emissions; for social cohesion and inclusion; and, last but not least, for road safety considerations.
I asked officials to come up with a plan to achieve that objective and for the earliest realistic date by which we could do it. There were two major considerations. The first was the physicality of being able to plan the road, because when you plan such an ambitious project as dualling the A9 between Perth and Inverness, you are talking about the acquisition of land, the bits of the road that are ready to be dualled quite easily from previous works and other bits of the road that are very challenging indeed. Overall, the physical ability to do that was a major consideration and so I asked my officials to be realistic but ambitious.
When it came to funding, we had to look at the Scottish Government’s long-term capital programme. In particular, we looked at the period from 2015 to 2030, because, by the time the preparation was done, we knew that we would not get most of the capital works done before 2015, given the procedures that had to be gone through for the acquisition of land, all the ground assessments and all the rest of it, and we looked at the likely amount of capital that would be available for investment, how much was committed and how much was left that was uncommitted. That is the key figure. When that exercise was done in 2011, we estimated that £14.7 billion of capital was not allocated to any project or designated for any purpose between 2015 and 2030. I can explain some of that in more detail later.
The estimate for dualling the A9 between Perth and Inverness was a working assumption, as was normal for a project that had not been costed in detail. The working assumption, which was at the high end of the estimates, was that it would cost roughly £30 million a mile. It was the same for the Aberdeen to Inverness dualling. We estimated that the maximum figure for both the projects would be £6 billion. That would have been only 40 per cent of the available capital at that time, so there was still 60 per cent to do all of the things that we wanted to do, which were also priorities in other areas. We then built that into the national infrastructure investment plan that I announced on 6 December 2011.
We received clear advice on the dates that were set. I emphasise that point, because I have been reading through previous evidence sessions of the committee. I asked Transport Scotland to be realistic, and it assured me that, physically and financially, it was perfectly feasible to achieve the dualling of the A9 between Inverness and Perth by 2025 and between Inverness and Aberdeen by 2030. As I said, we published that decision in December.
Road safety was a major consideration. Some officials tried to claim that the A9 was not the most dangerous road in Scotland, but it was certainly one of the most dangerous roads in Scotland. Since 1979, there have been 335 fatalities on that stretch of the A9—remember that it goes north of Inverness as well—with another 13 last year, which was a record for 20 years. I am afraid to say that those who say that the A9 is a safe road are not looking at the evidence and the facts.
I am disappointed by the delay, because we had a detailed schedule. In preparation for today, the permanent secretary, as he can under the ministerial code, gave me access to all the papers that I had in relation to the A9 and the A96 during my period as the cabinet secretary for infrastructure. I am not allowed to print those or forward them to other people, but I have made a note that, on 28 May 2012, at my request, I received a detailed memorandum from David Anderson, a senior official in Transport Scotland, addressed to me and Keith Brown, who was my deputy and the Minister for Housing and Transport. If you get that paperwork—I strongly suggest the committee demands it—you will see that annex D gives the outline programme for the completion of the A9. I will quickly read it out, because it should be put on the record, and then I will be happy to answer questions.
Luncarty to Birnam was due to be finished in 2018-19; Birnam to Ballinluig in 2024; Pitlochry to Killiecrankie in 2022; Killiecrankie to Glen Garry in 2024; Glen Garry to Crubenmore in 2024; Crubenmore to Kincraig in 2025—that would have been one of the last bits; Kincraig to Dalraddy in 2017; Dalraddy to Slochd in 2025; and Tomatin to Moy in 2021. That last bit was completed in 2021, but I signed it off for approval on 30 May 2012. Why it took nine years to complete I do not know, but it was completed in 2021. The other parts, apart from Luncarty to Pass of Birnam, have not been started. I am sorry; one of them has, but it has certainly not been completed. It is extremely disappointing and very damaging to the Scottish economy, and proportionately far more damaging to the Highlands and Islands, that that well-thought-out project has not been completed, let alone completed on time.
I am happy to answer any questions.
10:45