Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Deer (Firearms etc) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2023 [Draft]

Wednesday 13 September 2023 Rural Affairs and Islands Committee About 09:00–09:45 Subordinate legislation 110 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

110 contributions
Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Good morning, and welcome to the 22nd meeting in 2023 of the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee. Before we begin, I remind committee members who are using electronic devices to switch them to silent.

Our first item of business is consideration of the draft Deer (Firearms etc) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2023. The instrument is subject to the affirmative procedure. I welcome to the meeting Lorna Slater, the Minister for Green Skills, Circular Economy and Biodiversity, and her officials from the Scottish Government. We have Hugh Dignon, head of the wildlife management unit; Brodie Wilson, policy manager with that unit; and Norman Munro, solicitor.

I invite the minister to make an opening statement.

Lorna Slater Green The Minister for Green Skills, Circular Economy and Biodiversity · Lothian
link

I thank the committee for inviting me along to outline details of our proposed secondary legislation amendments in relation to deer management. They include proposals to amend existing legislation to reduce the minimum ammunition weight used to cull deer, permit the use of night sights to shoot deer and remove male deer close seasons.

We are all aware of the destructive impact that wild deer at high densities can cause to our natural environment through overgrazing, particularly in regenerating woodland, including Scotland’s rainforest. In 2021, we agreed to implement 95 of the 99 deer working group recommendations to modernise deer management systems in Scotland. The proposals before you today are some of the first legislative recommendations to be progressed and are vital in helping us to achieve our deer management aims.

The proposed removal of male close seasons will remove the need for hundreds of out-of-season authorisations to be issued each year to control male deer. That will save land managers time and effort, and it would—

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Minister, we are currently considering the Deer (Firearms etc) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2023; we are not yet on to the Deer (Close Seasons) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2023.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Sorry. I should have said that I have one speaking note. I am happy to keep part of it for the later discussion, if that is helpful.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

That would be helpful, because it is quite confusing having two orders in front of us. Please focus on the firearms instrument.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Certainly, convener.

The proposal to reduce the minimum ammunition weight to shoot deer will make non-lead ammunition more accessible. That is important as venison suppliers switch to accepting only carcases that are shot with non-lead ammunition.

The use of night sights will allow longer deer shooting hours, especially in the winter months, and more effective culling operations in areas where deer use the cover of forest and woodland during the day and then, during hours of darkness, come out into more open areas, where they can be shot more easily.

The measures are part of a wider package of deer reforms that are designed to deliver a range of public outcomes, including native woodland expansion, the protection and enhancement of peatlands, and the reduction of human health and safety concerns on issues such as Lyme disease and road traffic accidents. I thank all the organisations and individuals that have contributed to their development and to delivering on these vital objectives.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Thank you. We will move to questions from members, and I will kick off. Under the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996, the Scottish ministers are required to consult, but there was no public consultation on the instrument; instead, stakeholders who have an interest in the issue were consulted. Why was the decision taken not to go to a full public consultation?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

We have met all the legal requirements to consult on the proposals. I can give you the background. The deer working group report, which contained the proposals, was published in 2020. In response to that, prior to publishing our formal response, the Scottish Government met with and sought written responses from key stakeholders, including the Association of Deer Management Groups and Scottish Environment LINK. Since our response to the report was published, in 2021, we have also met representatives, at ministerial and official level, through individual meetings with land management organisations and through groups such as the deer management round table, with some regularity.

Through those conversations, we developed a sound understanding of the stakeholders’ views on issues such as close seasons, which meant that, when we received the responses to our consultation, the views that we received were largely in line with what we already understood. Those are the steps that we have taken to consult on the matter.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I have a question on that. How long did you give stakeholders to respond to the consultation? On what date did you publish the consultation and when did they respond? What was the closing date?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I can get my officials to talk about the consultation dates. I think that Brodie Wilson can talk about that.

Brodie Wilson Scottish Government
link

The consultation closed on Wednesday 14 June. We gave stakeholders four weeks to respond, so it opened in the middle of May. I am sorry, but I cannot remember the exact date off the top of my head, but it would have been around 18 May, I think. The stakeholders had four weeks to respond.

Brodie Wilson Scottish Government
link

It was 28.

Brodie Wilson Scottish Government
link

Sorry—it was 20 working days.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Was that the same as for other consultations that you have done on similar issues?

Brodie Wilson Scottish Government
link

It varies widely across secondary legislation.

Brodie Wilson Scottish Government
link

Because there is no legal minimum requirement to consult. We felt that four weeks was adequate, given that we had had so much engagement with stakeholders throughout the process.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Stakeholders have told me that they had very little time to engage in the process. The separate piece that you are talking about of publishing your proposals, which met legal requirements, was different. A considerable number of stakeholders were not asked to respond to the consultation within the 20 working days. A number of people have come to me and said that they were not asked to respond to your consultation. Why was that?

Brodie Wilson Scottish Government
link

We asked all external stakeholders who are on the deer management round table to respond. I have a list of those, if you would like to see it.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

The deer management roundtable members include: Lantra Scotland, Mountaineering Scotland, the British Deer Society, the Confederation of Forest Industries, the Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust, Trees for Life, the Scottish Gamekeepers Association, the Scottish Association for Country Sports, the Scottish Crofting Federation, the British Association for Shooting and Conservation, Woodland Trust Scotland, Lowland deer groups, Transport Scotland, Forestry and Land Scotland, Scottish Wildlife Trust, Police Scotland, Food Standards Scotland, Country Sport Scotland, NatureScot, the National Trust for Scotland, various departments within the Scottish Government including the veterinary adviser, RSPB Scotland, the Scottish Venison Association, Scottish Land & Estates, the John Muir Trust, the Association of Deer Management Groups, the Scottish Countryside Alliance, Scottish Environment LINK, NFU Scotland, SSPCA, wild deer best practice guides, the Veterinary Deer Society, the National Wildlife Crime Unit, the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Community Land Scotland, Scottish Forestry, Cairngorms National Park Authority, Loch Lomond and Trossachs National Park Authority, the James Hutton Institute, the Forest Policy Group and the Ramblers.

09:15

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

What is the total number of members? I was not able to count them as you read them out.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

So, that was quite a poor response rate.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

To put that in context, all of those stakeholders had been engaged in the conversation since 2020 and prior to that—it was not new information to them. When the independent deer working group published the recommendations, back in 2020, it did so on the basis of evidence that it had gathered for many months. It has been a very long process to get to where we are today, and it is on-going. The recommendations were published back in 2020. The Scottish Government then engaged with the stakeholders to develop our response in 2021. We had those conversations and, when our consultation came out, most stakeholders had already submitted to us what they wished to say, although a few—a dozen—wrote back to us with additional information. They did not contribute any new information but largely covered the same ground. The issues have been thoroughly discussed with stakeholders.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I thought that it was interesting that some of the groups that supported the Government’s position were looking at it from a climate change perspective rather than from an animal welfare perspective. However, that is just my observation. In particular, some organisations, such as the National Trust for Scotland, Woodland Trust Scotland, Nature Foundation and Trees for Life, were not looking at it from an animal welfare perspective. I have to put my cards on the table and say that that is my concern around this SSI.

Ariane Burgess Green Highlands and Islands
link

It was great to hear the context from which the instrument arose and the work of the deer working group, which was set up due to the concern about the levels of damage to public interests caused by wild deer. Those public interests include a healthy environment with flourishing biodiversity and woodlands that can capture our excess carbon emissions. Minister, to what extent is increased deer control important for our natural regeneration?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

As the committee probably knows, deer numbers have doubled in Scotland since 1990. That is not a sustainable trajectory, given that deer can have serious impacts on the environment through overgrazing and trampling of vulnerable habitats, preventing young trees from growing. Research on the national forest estate in 2013 found that 15 to 20 per cent of young trees at that time had been damaged by deer—and, of course, deer numbers are higher today.

In 2021, a ClimateXChange report found that browsing changes the plant diversity and foliage present, which alters our potential to capture carbon. High levels of grazing are likely to affect bog species, and associated trampling causes greater levels of damage by breaking up the moss layer and exposing bare peat. Overgrazing occurs at a much lower density in bogs compared to forestry as well. Furthermore, Forestry and Land Scotland estimates that the cost of deer damage to on-going management is around £10 million a year and is at least £47 million a year across Scotland. Between 2015 and 2020, Scottish Forestry spent just under £19 million on deer fencing.

In addition to the environmental concerns that the member highlights, there are human and public safety concerns with regard to deer-vehicle collisions. It is estimated that there are between 8,000 and 14,000 deer-vehicle collisions in Scotland every year, and, in 2016, a report estimated that DVCs in Scotland cost £13.8 million, although the deer working group found that that number is very much higher. So, you can see that the issue is affecting not only our forest and tree regeneration. Having high numbers of deer affects many aspects of society and is very costly.

Ariane Burgess Green Highlands and Islands
link

Another part of this SSI is about land managers being able to control deer at night. They already do that, but it is currently challenging, as they have to bring lamps into the forest. Roughly how many land managers already control deer at night, and how will this instrument make that task easier?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Around 18,640 deer are controlled at night, which is about 17 per cent of the deer that are managed. My officials might know the number of land managers who have applied for that.

Brodie Wilson Scottish Government
link

We do not have information on the specific number of applications at the moment, but we can provide it to you.

Ariane Burgess Green Highlands and Islands
link

My question is, how will the proposed change make the task easier for those land managers?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

The intention of the SSI is to allow the use of the additional technology that we have mentioned. As you suggest, using the lamping technique might not be everyone’s preference, and the change opens up the possibility of using night sights.

It should be noted that that means that the sights can be used during the day, too—that is currently not allowed—which is an additional tool for the land managers, who will have that option should they wish to use it.

Ariane Burgess Green Highlands and Islands
link

Have the concerns around animal welfare been looked into?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Absolutely. In 2022, NatureScot did a review into the welfare issues relating to the use of intensifying night sights for the culling of deer at night. The review found no evidence that culling deer at night using thermal imaging technology increased the risk of deer being wounded, and it found that all the deer were humanely dispatched.

NatureScot was clear that the sights offered no significant welfare risks over and above the existing technique of lamping.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

What research has been carried out into the safety of the process? To me, having people going around at night shooting things seems inherently unsafe. People walk around and go into forests at night. What research has been done to ensure that people cannot be inadvertently shot?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I am happy to cover that matter. As I have already stated, 17 per cent of deer are already shot at night. Night licences for shooting can be issued only under NatureScot authorisation, and they come with clear conditions attached. The code of practice that comes with them explicitly says, for example, that anyone shooting deer at night must be accompanied by an appropriate dog, so that a wounded deer can be tracked and dispatched humanely. NatureScot can revoke any authorisation at any time, and it will issue the authorisation only under specific conditions. It can come to inspect the site to ensure that it is safe, which relates to the public safety concerns that you raise. At any time during the authorisation period, NatureScot can ask to come along on the shoot to observe that the rules are being followed. None of that is changed by the SSI; those authorisations and safety conditions are going to be monitored in exactly the same way.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I am thinking about the safety of people. You are talking about issues to do with animals.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

That is the same matter. It is covered by NatureScot’s ability to set conditions and inspect the site to ensure that conditions are safe. All shooting requires that the person pulling the trigger has a safe backstop and observes all shooting requirements. That would absolutely cover people, too. It is up to the person pulling the trigger to ensure that they have followed all the safety requirements and that it is safe for them to do so.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

It does not feel safe. Am I right in thinking that night shooting really only happens out of season? In the summer, there are long days and lots of light.

Hugh Dignon Scottish Government
link

The hind season is through the winter, and a large amount of the culling will happen at that point. That is where some serious effort needs to be made in order to reduce the deer population. So, indeed, there is night shooting of hinds during the winter season.

I can add to the minister’s points about the safety issues. All people who shoot at night are required to be on the fit and competent register that NatureScot operates, which means that they must have a deer stalking certificate at level 1 and two referees, or a deer stalking certificate at level 2. Further, all night shooting operations need to be notified to the police.

As the minister said, this type of operation has been carried out for many years now with no public safety issues as far as I am aware.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I have a question that follows on from that. The use of light-intensifying sights, heat-sensitive sights or other special sights is quite different from lamping. So, although I am not an expert, I suggest that the skill level that is required to ensure a clean kill is significantly higher with the newer methods. However, it appears that the legislation will allow people to use the new methods without there being a separate authorisation scheme. Are there plans to bring in additional training requirements or update the best practice guide?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

NatureScot will update the best practice guide.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Will it update the level of competence that is required in order for someone to be authorised to engage in night shooting if that person is using night sights rather than going lamping? There is quite a difference in the skill level that is required.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

NatureScot authorisations require that the people carrying out the shooting under those conditions are properly qualified and are following the best practice guidance. That is the mechanism. When the new best practice guidance is issued, alongside this legislation, it will be up to NatureScot to ensure, through its authorisation mechanisms, that that guidance is followed.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

My concern is that, if someone is authorised to lamp, that would mean that they were automatically authorised to use night sights without any additional conditions applying to that authorisation, which might mean that, if NatureScot refused to authorise someone to use night sights, because it felt that there was an issue with that person’s ability to use them safely or competently, they would lose the ability to lamp as well.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I am not sure that your assumption that an authorisation to go lamping automatically allows someone to use different technology is correct, but I am happy to get the information on that to you. I do not know whether the authorisation specifies which technology is to be used—I do not have that level of detail with me—but I am happy to clarify the position for you.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

The possibility that, if people are deemed not to be suitably trained or qualified to use night-vision sights, they might not get a lamping licence, because the authorisation covers both things, is quite concerning. As far as I can see, there is no differentiation between an authorisation for lamping and an authorisation for night sights.

Hugh Dignon Scottish Government
link

I would just add that, when NatureScot reviewed the position, it did not recommend that any further training be required in relation to the use of night sights—either the thermal-intensification or the image-enhancing sights—so I am not sure that we would accept the basic premise that a different level of skill is required. Clearly, lamping and the use of night sights are both things that require people to have experience and to be on the fit and competent register, but, as I said, NatureScot did not identify that the use of night sights involved a different skill set or required additional training.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

There are also different levels of specification of night sights, which could increase the margin of potential error. Is there any specification of the equipment that needs to be used for the heat-sensitive or light-intensifying sights? Lamping is lamping—you have a light source that enables you to use standard sights to shoot—but the night sights will have different specifications. I could go into a shop and buy night sights for an air rifle that would not be adequate to be used safely by someone stalking deer at night.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

As we have said already, stalking at night can be done only under authorisation, and people doing that stalking have to pass the fit and competent test. We have not specified the types of scopes that can be used, because technology is always evolving, and there are many scopes on the market. The specific authorisation for night shooting is the mechanism for ensuring that people who are doing it are fully qualified to do so. Of course, as with all these matters, it is up to the operator—the person who is pulling the trigger—to correctly identify the target animal, identify potential risks and ensure a safe backstop. That remains true whatever equipment anyone is using at any time.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Rachael Hamilton has a short supplementary question.

09:30

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

The minister has answered the questions, but it looks as though operators will need two types of equipment to do what the SSI requires. Investment in equipment will be required, and that money will need to come out of the budget. I have spoken to people who say that it will cost them, on average, £10,000 to get equipment that is up to standard. Hugh Dignon is shaking his head, but I have heard from stakeholders who say that.

The minister has said that changes will need to be made to best practice and to the fit and competent test for night shooting authorisations for the welfare of the operator. We are being expected to pass the SSI when we have no answer to those questions. It is just like what has happened with other pieces of legislation that have passed responsibility for codes of practice to NatureScot. Committee members are being expected to be mind readers and to know what will be in the fit and competent test so that the welfare of operators can be upheld.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I am afraid that the member is not accurate in what she has said. The SSI does not require the use of night sights; it allows the use of night sights.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

You are trying to control the deer population, which means that more operators will go out and shoot more.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

You said that we are requiring people to buy night sights; we are not requiring them to do that. They will now be allowed to use the new technology—

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

No, this is an unintended consequence. Let us consider the practicalities. Things need to be safe, and you are expecting operators to go out and shoot more deer in order to control the deer population, so they will be doing more shooting, possibly at night. It is a hypothetical situation, but the likelihood is that that will happen, so operators will require the right equipment. Why would you not want an operator to have the right equipment? I do not understand.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

The SSI that will be passed today allows the use of the equipment. We know that 17 per cent of the deer that are culled in Scotland are culled at night, so we know that people wish to do that. If they wish to cull deer at night, they may now do so using sights. That is the change to the legislation. We are not requiring anyone to manage deer in that way, and we are not requiring them to use any particular equipment. We are merely opening up the option should they wish to do that.

With regard to the fit and competent test, the fit test relates to someone having a certificate to be able to use firearms, and the competent test relates to someone holding the correct deer stalking certificate and the correct authorisations from NatureScot. Those matters are unchanged. Of course, the authorisation will be in line with the new guidance that NatureScot will issue on using the equipment safely.

I think that Rachael Hamilton has misunderstood. The SSI does not require anything of anyone. It just allows the equipment to be used should people wish to do so.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

Good morning. As I understand it, one reason for the SSI is to make non-lead alternatives more accessible so that more carcases can enter the food chain, which is a positive thing. In the past few years, we have seen examples of huge levels of waste, particularly when non-shooting, non-commercial estates have culled tens, if not hundreds, of deer and left them to rot. What engagement has the Scottish Government had with estates that might be considering doing that? What encouragement is being given to ensure that that great meat source is relieving hunger in this country rather than being wasted?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I support your call for a thriving venison industry, and I agree that we should ensure that those deer become a reliable food source. You correctly identified that changing the ammunition weight allows non-lead ammunition to be used by more practitioners, because it fits the standard firearm that most people have.

We are doing several things to ensure that there is a thriving venison industry. We have been working with those in the industry to promote venison as a healthy lean meat by providing £60,000 of funding for an online marketing campaign. We have been supporting local chill and processing facilities through £80,000 of funding being made available for a pilot project. I am also aware that the Scottish Venison Association has recently announced that its partnership with the Country Food Trust will result in wild venison from Scottish deer going to food banks, kitchens and other charities.

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

That is very helpful. You might be familiar with the Country Food Trust, which does a great job in taking venison that might otherwise go to waste and creating nutritious meals that it then donates to food banks.

One of the risks, however, is that, if there is a massive increase in culling, particularly out of season, that has a huge impact on the likelihood of that meat being eaten. The idea that we might be wasting meat sits so wrongly with me. Does the Scottish Government have a word of warning to give that, if we are to see culling increase, particularly out of season, that is not a licence to see far more carcases going to waste, especially if one of the benefits of this SSI is actually to see more carcases going into the food network?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I absolutely support what the member says. Have we drifted into discussing the close season?

Kate Forbes SNP Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch
link

No, we have not—we are very much still on the first SSI.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

We absolutely need to make sure that venison can go into the venison industry and that we remove lead ammunition and increase the options there. I think that we can all work towards ensuring that we have a thriving venison industry. Does Hugh Dignon want to come in on that?

Hugh Dignon Scottish Government
link

I have a couple of minor things to add. First, the proportion of carcases that have been left on the hillside is tiny. There were some incidents a couple of years ago that aroused considerable opposition among deer managers, but such incidents are pretty isolated and the people involved probably do not do that very much. They would argue that there are some conservation reasons why, where carcases were in an inaccessible position, they might have taken some of the best cuts from them and left some of the carcase there for golden eagle management and so on.

On the other side, we have certainly been talking with venison wholesalers and the like about the likely effects of the increase in cull and how we can improve the market for venison and get it out to the wider public.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

We have been joined by Edward Mountain. Edward, do you have some questions?

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

Yes—thank you, convener. Before I go any further, I remind members of my entry in the register of members’ interests. I have a small farming partnership that has roe deer on its land, which are given protection because my neighbours kill an awful lot of them.

Minister, I am less concerned about the use of night sights. I am disappointed that you are unable to say that there will be a difference between using image-intensifying, infrared and TI sights, and which sights will be acceptable under the legislation. I think that that is an admission—it is an admission on training as well, and the extra requirements in that regard.

As the convener said, you can see the backdrop with lights at night but you cannot see the backdrop with thermal imaging. You can to a certain extent with II and IR, but not with TI, because it will just blend in with the backdrop. That concerns me if there is to be no extra training.

I would like to ask you about non-lead ammunition and the use of copper bullets. The point of lead and expanding bullets is to cause catastrophic shock to the animal, which causes it to die instantaneously. There is some tolerance, when you are using lead bullets, on the exact bullet placement; if you are slightly further back on where you should be shooting at, it will still pick up the lungs and the liver and cause the animal to die almost instantaneously.

That is not so with lighter bullets and copper. What investigations have you done regarding the use of copper bullets and bullet placement where you are going to shoot the animal, especially at night, using a TI, an II or an IR sight? How are you are going to achieve that with lighter bullets that require more accurate bullet placement?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Absolutely. NatureScot undertook a trial of the minimum bullet weights that are being proposed to shoot deer, in order to ensure that animal welfare would not be compromised. I share the member’s concern about that.

We considered the results of the NatureScot report, alongside advice from NatureScot on deer welfare. I read NatureScot’s “Review of the minimum bullet weight for the lawful culling of all deer species in Scotland” report—it is very interesting with regard to the placement of the shot and so on. The review found that the proposed changes would have

“no detrimental effect on deer welfare.”

That is partly because, along with the change to the minimum weight, the requirements for muzzle velocity and bullet energy are unchanged. With regard to the effect that the member mentions, that fits within the grounds for leeway—there is, as he said, some leeway in that regard—because it still requires the minimum energy of the bullet to have that impact on the animal.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

I would love to have a long discussion about ballistics with the minister. Muzzle velocity is one thing, but it is nothing to do with delivering a certain number of kilojoules of energy directly at the point of aim. The problem with lighter copper bullets is that, unless you hit a bone, there will be deflection. There is no doubt that, if you hit an animal slightly further forward on the shoulder blade, the bullet can travel over the shoulder blade and out the other side. If you hit it too far back, in the guts, it might pass directly through the animal because there is no expansion.

Using copper bullets is fine during the day, because you can aim specifically for a bone at the top of the leg and, one would hope, hit it. Are you confident that that can be achieved with thermal imaging, infrared illuminators and IR sights? I am a practitioner with 40 years’ experience, and I am not sure that I would be able to do it, and I have used some very good thermal imaging sights.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

When NatureScot investigated the use of night sights and the proposed change to ammunition weights, it did not find any welfare concerns at all, over and above those that apply in relation to lamping, which is a practice for trying to see things in the dark. No additional welfare concerns were found. That has been addressed from the ammunition angle and the night-sight angle.

Of course, as Edward Mountain will know, it is always up to the practitioner not to take the shot unless it is safe to do so—unless they have a correct backstop and the animal has been correctly identified and paired up with any young that it might be responsible for. It is always up to the person who pulls the trigger to decide whether the shot is safe to take.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

Did NatureScot carry out its experiments on whether it is possible to achieve what is sought with night sights at night? If it did not do so at night, I would question those results. I am asking from a welfare point of view, because the welfare of animals is really important. I will come on to that in the second part of my questioning.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Two different sets of tests were carried out. There was a review of welfare issues using image-intensifying rifle sights for culling deer at night. I do not know what ammunition was used for that testing. There was separate testing on the use of copper bullets. That testing looked extensively at where the animal was hit and whether it was still possible to dispatch the animal humanely. Both of those tests have been done.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

They were probably done during daylight, which is the equivalent of using a lamp at night. It works fine in those circumstances. Has it been explained how difficult it is to achieve that with a TI sight, an II and an IR sight?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

The NatureScot report on minimum bullet weight involved an experiment to understand how the bullet impacted the animal when it was shot in different places on the body. That would address Edward Mountain’s concern.

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am afraid that it does not address my concern. It is very difficult to follow up on animals that have been shot at night, to minimise any welfare issue. You cannot do that unless you have a dog with you.

I want to pick up on your comments that using night sights would allow more extensive deer culling to go on over a bigger period and that Forestry and Land Scotland spent £10 million a year on deer control. I have here some figures that I know are correct. Forestry and Land Scotland asks its rangers to kill more than two deer every day of the year that they work. That amounts to a huge number, which is probably not achievable. If some of that £10 million was spent on putting people on the ground, more deer culls would probably be achieved and the proposed measures would not be necessary.

Are you comfortable that harrying an animal from dawn to dusk, irrespective of its sex, is the right way to do it? To me, it sounds like a form of warfare, which is something that I used to do when I was in the army.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

The Scottish Animal Welfare Commission and OneKind were among the stakeholders that were consulted on the proposals, and no welfare concerns were raised by those organisations, which prioritise animal welfare—that is their reason for being—in relation to the legislative proposals. That has been looked at.

Edward Mountain briefly mentioned the use of dogs for night shooting. It is, of course, part of the good practice guidelines to have a dog to make sure that any animal can be tracked.

09:45

Edward Mountain Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am glad that you clarified that that is in the good practice guidelines. Not a single member of the Scottish Animal Welfare Commission—not a single one of them—is a deer management practitioner. They include a World Federation for Animals officer, animal welfare officers, veterinarians, police and lecturers, but not a single one has practised deer management on a large scale. That concerns me because, at the end of the day, all of us as parliamentarians must ensure the welfare of the animals that we are killing in order to protect our natural land.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

On the subject of animal welfare, minister, you have cited the NatureScot review. I spoke to the Scottish Gamekeepers Association, which cited a study by the Royal (Dick) school of veterinary studies—the Dick Vet. From that study the SGA concluded that

“Night shooting ... is a method proven under test conditions to be the least in the interest of animal welfare, which requires quick, humane dispatch”,

and for that reason the SGA opposes

“the normalisation of night shooting”.

As my colleague Edward Mountain has said, we need to look at this issue from a practitioner’s point of view. I do not know the opinion of FLS on this. Does it agree with the SGA? Why did you not get more information around the humane cull of deer from the Dick Vet?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Scotland’s chief veterinary officer was one of the members of the deer management round table.

I want to make it really clear that night shooting requires an authorisation from NatureScot. The authorisation requires that the good practice guidelines be met and that NatureScot is allowed to come and see the site where the night shooting will take place and even to accompany the practitioners when they do that. That is unchanged—night shooting requires that special authorisation.

We know that there is demand for this move because, as I said, 17 per cent of the animals that are culled are shot at night. The need for authorisation will not change: night shooting will still require that special authorisation and special oversight from NatureScot. Again, the legislation does not make night shooting a requirement. People who wish to manage their deer at night may now use these new technologies—that is what has changed. It is a new option open to land managers, should they wish to use it. They are absolutely not required to do so, but if they do, they will be required to obtain the correct authorisation from NatureScot.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

I think that the figure you quoted was that 17 per cent of culled deer are culled at night.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

What percentage of the operators doing that are operating within public land?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I do not have that information in front of me, but I am happy to write to you with it.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

I am still concerned about the fact that there is only one authorisation scheme. Can you give us an indication of how many stalkers are currently authorised to lamp—to shoot at night?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Authorisations are not given to individuals; they are for a certain circumstance. An authorisation for a night shooting is for a specific set of circumstances—specific dates and specific locations. There are no blanket authorisations for an operator.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

How can NatureScot be assured that the stalker has the appropriate training if the authorisation is not for individuals? I am concerned about the lowest common denominator here. If there is only one authorisation scheme, someone who is authorised to shoot at night—to lamp—would automatically be able to shoot using night sights. As we have already suggested—and I think we have agreed—that requires a different level of skill, given the margins of error that infrared or heat-sensitive sights have. If someone was at the standard to be able to lamp, they would automatically get authorisation to use night sights—is that correct?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

Every night-shooting project gets its own authorisation. Authorisations are for a fixed period of time, under fixed circumstances, and they specify which practitioners are doing the work, so—

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

But is that based on the technology or based on the fact that the practitioner is seen as being up to standard? I know that we are talking not about individuals but about a scheme. So, if someone puts in an application for authorisation for night shooting in a forest, they would only need to come up to the lamping standard, but they could, in effect, go out and use infrared sights under that authorisation. It is a general you-can-shoot-at-night authorisation.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

It is not a general authorisation because it is specific: it specifies a location, a time period, who will be doing the work and the outcomes. I do not have in front of me the detailed paperwork as to what that authorisation requires, but it is a detailed and specific authorisation for a particular night-shooting project—

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

But it is not specific about the method or what practitioners are able to carry out that shooting.

Hugh Dignon Scottish Government
link

The authorisation would require the individuals involved—that is, those who are going to carry out the work—to be named, and all those individuals would need to be on the fit and competent register.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Fit and competent to lamp, but not necessarily fit and competent to—

Hugh Dignon Scottish Government
link

As I explained earlier, and as I think the minister has also said, the fit and competent register requires that an individual has at least deer stalking certificate level 1 and has some referees who will give evidence to the fact that the person follows best practice and understands the business involved in deer stalking, or a deer stalking certificate level 2. That gets a person on to the fit and competent register. The person also, of course, needs to have a firearms certificate; that is the other aspect of a person’s being fit, as the minister said.

I go back to the point that, when NatureScot reviewed this, it did not find that a different level of skill set that would require additional training was necessary for the use of those new additional pieces of equipment. There will be changes to the best practice guidance, which will involve things around shot placement and so on, but the review that NatureScot carried out and the evidence that it submitted to us did not point to a different level of skill or training being required.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

For the record, I am very concerned that the scheme potentially does not require anyone to say whether they are going to lamp or whether they are going to use infrared or thermal sights. That means that an authorisation could potentially be given to someone who is competent in lamping but who has never used a night sight at all and who may also not be equipped with sights that are up to the standard that we would like in order to ensure not only the highest level of animal welfare but also public safety, which is where my concern lies.

Rachael Hamilton Con Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire
link

Minister, how many operators are on the fit and competent register and how many spot checks does NatureScot do?

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I do not have that information with me, but I am happy to write to the committee with it.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

As we do not have any further questions, we move to the next agenda item, which is formal consideration of the motion to approve the instrument. I invite the minister to move motion S6M-09460.

Lorna Slater Green Lothian
link

I move,

That the Rural Affairs and Islands Committee recommends that the Deer (Firearms etc.) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2023 be approved.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

As no member wishes to debate the motion, is the committee content to recommend approval of the instrument?

Members: No.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

We are not agreed, so we will move to a vote.

For

Adam, Karen (Banffshire and Buchan Coast) (SNP)

Allan, Alasdair (Na h-Eileanan an Iar) (SNP)

Burgess, Ariane (Highlands and Islands) (Green)

Forbes, Kate (Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch) (SNP)

Grant, Rhoda (Highlands and Islands) (Lab)

Wishart, Beatrice (Shetland Islands) (LD)

Against

Carson, Finlay (Galloway and West Dumfries) (Con)

Hamilton, Rachael (Ettrick, Roxburgh and Berwickshire) (Con)

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

The result of the division is: For 6, Against 2, Abstentions 0.

Motion agreed to.

Finlay Carson Con The Convener · Galloway and West Dumfries
link

Is the committee content to delegate authority to me to sign off a report on our deliberations on this affirmative SSI?

Members indicated agreement.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 110
  2. 09:45 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 130
  3. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  4. 11:15 Bracken Control Committee business · 78

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.