You have raised some important points about the jobs that will be created in the green port areas. Mention has been made of green jobs and green manufacturing.
I come back to the displacement by companies that Liz Cairns has alluded to, whereby the business moves but maybe not the people. There is talk of green jobs and green manufacturing, but, as yet, no one can tell us what a green job is. Will someone using an electric bike for deliveries be classed as having a green job? There is no guarantee when it comes to green jobs and green manufacturing.
Let us take the oil and gas industry, the upstream and downstream elements of which extend from Aberdeen down to Grangemouth. There is a whole list of jobs in that industry that could change to green jobs under a just transition, but that has not been defined yet. Mention has been made of the possibility of green jobs being moved to Leith and the Cromarty Firth, but those jobs could displace jobs in the oil and gas industry if the green manufacturing has to be done in those areas.
The issue of manufacturing needs to be raised, because the Scottish Government is not investing in manufacturing. We want manufacturing to be done in this country. If we are to have new technologies, new green energy and new construction, those things should be built and manufactured in Scotland. Perhaps jobs can be created in those areas.
However, wider thought needs to be given to what the economy will look like. We cannot just say, “We’ll put green jobs in here,” without thinking where the green jobs will go. The oil and gas companies are investing in doing their new green energy work onshore in this country, so building work will be done here. Why is the manufacturing for the offshore wind farms not being done in Scotland? Why can that technology not be built in some of the areas that we are talking about? We keep asking those questions because there is no agenda for how we achieve a just transition. In our view, green ports are part of the just transition agenda. Jobs are being moved to the green port areas. It is claimed that those jobs will be new green jobs. However, if those jobs are new jobs, existing jobs will have to be replaced, because the technologies are not there to get things done.
The issue of a just transition is so much bigger than people think it is; it goes beyond just oil and gas. It is a massive issue that extends across a raft of areas, including the energy networks and local authorities, where jobs will be under threat and new training is needed. Perhaps we need to have another go at thinking about how those areas will be utilised by the Scottish Government and by the economy.
11:15
I will mention another area while we are talking about that. The first road into those two places will be construction, because construction will need to grow: the buildings will need to be built and the foundations will need to be put in. However, there is a real danger in construction that we do not want to see. If you do not get the procurement processes and investment right, you will have self-employed and bogus self-employed companies making fortunes out of those areas, and you will have people not paying tax. That is exactly what happens under bogus self-employed companies. The tax gains that you think you will get from that are not reasonable at this point in time. I am being as critical and as fair as I can be—I do not think that it has been well thought through in relation to the bigger picture of the wider Scottish economy.