Good morning, and thank you for the opportunity to provide evidence to the committee. This introductory statement is made on behalf of COSLA and the Scottish Government as the joint chairs and partners in the ASL project board.
We recognise that there is significant interest in the implementation of additional support for learning and that the committee will use today’s session to inform its consideration of its future work in the area.
As members will be aware, the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004 is a highly inclusive legislative framework that seeks to address barriers to learning experienced by children and young people as part of their learning. The framework focuses on barriers to learning arising from the learning environment, family circumstances, social and emotional behavioural needs, and disability and health needs. Needs might be of short or long duration. Currently, 241,639 or 34.2 per cent of pupils are identified as having additional support needs in Scotland.
The Morgan review, which was undertaken in three phases during 2019-2020, considered the implementation of additional support for learning. In summary, the review focused on how additional support for learning works in practice across early learning and childcare centres, and primary, secondary and special schools, including enhanced provision; where children and young people learn within the balance of the provisions in local authorities; the quality of learning and support, including overall achievement and positive destinations achieved post-school; the different approaches to planning and assessment to meet the needs of children and young people; the roles and responsibilities of support and teaching staff and leaders, education authorities and national agencies; and the areas of practice that could be improved through better use of current resources to support practice, staffing or other aspects of provision.
The review was published in June 2020, and it made 43 recommendations across nine themes. It confirmed that there is no fundamental deficit in the principle and policy intent of the ASL legislation and guidance. It is therefore necessary that, in our work, our joint focus is on the collective actions to be taken to improve the experiences of children and young people and their families.
In the joint response to the review on 21 October 2020, the Scottish Government and COSLA confirmed acceptance of the review’s recommendations, including partial acceptance of one recommendation. No recommendation was rejected. At the same time, the Scottish Government and COSLA published the ASL action plan, which sets out 76 actions to be taken to deliver the recommendations of the Morgan review. As part of that response, we committed to publish regular progress reports, and two have been published since then.
The latest progress report was published in November 2022 and confirmed that, at that time, 24 of the 76 actions had been completed. In order to secure progress on delivery of the actions at pace, the Scottish Government and COSLA have established the ASL project board. The role of the project board is to oversee the delivery of the ASL action plan and associated workstreams.
Throughout the life of the plan, there has been continued progress towards the achievements of those actions. That has continued since the publication of the report in November. We expect to see more progress before the next report, which is due in May 2024.
It is acknowledged in the ASL review report that the
“recommendations are not a quick fix”
and that they will “challenge and cause discomfort”. We recognise that. However, we are confident that by working together, maintaining a focus on outcomes and taking seriously the implementation of the recommendations, we have achieved, and will continue to achieve, the necessary change. That knowledge comes through the regular scrutiny of the work plan to deliver the recommendations, including prioritisation of any areas of concern and progress on short, medium and long-term actions.
Member of the ASL project board are here today to provide evidence to the committee on the progress of the delivery of the ASL actions. We recognise that the committee will wish to explore wider aspects of the implementation of the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004.
To aid our discussions today, it may be helpful if I set out some key information. I have already set out the number of children and young people who have additional support needs. I will now turn to their achievements. In 2021-22, 22,550 pupils with additional support needs received a Scottish credit and qualifications framework qualification. That is the highest number of pupils on record. Within that, 75 per cent of leavers with an additional support need achieved one pass or more at SCQF level 5—national 5—or better, which is a 10.1 percentage point increase since 2014-15. In addition, 93 per cent of leavers from public secondary and special schools were in a positive destination three months after leaving, which is the highest proportion since consistent records began.
We have also established the success looks different award. The award was developed by Scotland’s national inclusion ambassadors, who are a group of young people with additional support needs from across Scotland. They gather to influence policy and reflect on the implementation of additional support for learning. The award is to highlight and celebrate education settings that support and champion children’s rights and can evidence inclusion practices as embedded within their school ethos, values and practice.
On support for pupils, the Scottish Government has invested £15 million a year to enhance the provision of pupil support assistants. That has contributed to an increase of 2,803 support staff in schools since 2018. That is within the context of local authorities continuing to prioritise funding for additional support for learning within their budgets, despite a challenging financial context. In 2022, local authority spend on additional support for learning was £830 million, the highest level of local authority spend on additional support for learning to date.
We cannot view support for learning in isolation from the wider on-going work to support children and young people; for example, through keeping the Promise, tackling child poverty and supporting mental health and wellbeing, including the forthcoming mental health strategy and plan.
In working to implement the recommendations of the ASL review, it is important that we recognise our strengths and challenges. The ASL review provides a clear framework within which we can work together with our partners in the ASL project board and beyond to continue to improve the experience of children and young people with additional support needs.
We are currently midway through that work together, and we will continue to deliver against the actions of the action plan and the recommendations of the review. We are absolutely committed to making that change together, and look forward to answering the committee’s questions today.