We use the phrase “directly elected mayors” simply to distinguish them from the largely ceremonial provosts that we have. As you say, provosts and mayors can be interchangeable. It is about the person who is in charge in an area having a clear identity. The model that we suggest in our report involves using existing council boundaries and having somebody who is directly elected across the council area. It is not really the same system as the one in various places down south, where, for example, Andy Burnham covers the larger Manchester area.
It is about having somebody whose identity is understood and who can be a representative voice and an ambassador for their area locally, nationally across the UK and internationally, whether they represent Edinburgh or Moray, which might not always have the loudest voice because it is drowned out by the central belt. It is about paying a bit more attention to areas that are perhaps overlooked at present.
It is also about connecting individuals. At the moment, most local authorities are run by coalitions and there is not always great understanding of who is in charge. Some councils have had two leaders to reflect the nature of the coalition partners. There is not always great name recognition of council leaders. Of course, a councillor is elected to represent just one ward and they will not necessarily have a link to the full area.
Part of our thinking was about ensuring a move towards the parity that we spoke about earlier. How do we raise the profile and increase the understanding of the voice of local authorities? The structures might be different down south but, with the likes of Andy Burnham, we have seen that name recognition and the idea of people fighting for their area. People such as Sadiq Khan are voices for their areas against a stronger central Government. We are trying to increase the voice of civic Scotland, increase the voices that are out there and have identifiable individuals who can argue for their areas.
During the pandemic, when people could only move within their local authority area, there was a better understanding of which local authority was at which level for the Covid restrictions. At that point, we saw some arguments going on about whether local authorities were sticking up for their areas or whether they were just going along with their national party.
The key is that a directly elected mayor or provost is the people’s voice and a strong local champion, rather than a party’s voice for the people or the party’s voice in Glasgow, Edinburgh or wherever. If someone from whichever party just spouts party lines and sticks rigidly to what their party is saying, they will get kicked out—voted out—by the electorate. It is about building that link with what is right locally.
We have not always seen disagreement between local authorities and the central parties, but we should have that discussion more, because it is surely obvious that what is right in one local area may not be what a party leader wants to see. Some discussions have gone on about coalitions at the local authority level. We have had one party saying, “Oh, you can’t go into coalition with this party” and another saying, “Oh, you can’t go into coalition with that party”, but we have a voting system that is designed to encourage coalitions. That is what happens when the politics come into play. The proposal is a way of stripping the politics back a wee bit and giving a voice to the local authority area.