Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

A9 Dualling

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 15 June 2023 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Douglas Ross Con Highlands and Islands
link

The A9 is a main road in Scotland stretching from the central belt to the north. It is also one of the most dangerous roads in the country. The Scottish National Party promised to fully dual the A9 from Perth to Inverness in its 2007 manifesto—16 years ago. Yesterday, campaigners were in Parliament, raising the issue once more.

Recently, The Inverness Courier highlighted the Government’s broken promise on the issue with a tombstone on its front cover. After another death last month, the paper followed up with another sombre front page. It read—this is my question to the First Minister—

“the Scottish Government has no update on its delayed dualling project, leaving us all to ask: HOW MANY MORE PEOPLE HAVE TO DIE?”

Humza Yousaf SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Pollok
link

First and foremost, my thoughts are with every single person, family and community that have been affected by the tragic loss of life on the A9.

Douglas Ross, The Inverness Courier and others—including, I know, many MSPs from my party—who have raised the issue of dualling of the A9 are, of course, right to look at it through the prism of safety on our roads. It is a safety issue, which is why, since 2007 and the commitment to which Douglas Ross referred, we have taken action.

There has been £430 million of investment in the A9, and road users are already benefiting from dualled sections from Kincraig to Dalraddy and from Luncarty to the Pass of Birnam, which opened in September 2017 and August 2021 respectively. We—I and this Government—are absolutely committed to dualling the A9.

With regard to the timetable that is set out, Jenny Gilruth, when she was Minister for Transport, in February this year gave an update to Parliament—rightly—in relation to the Tomatin to Moy section. She made it clear that it could not go ahead because of our obligations in respect of public finance. During the update, she indicated that work was “on-going” and would conclude in “autumn of this year” to provide an “update” on the “renewed timescale for completion.” Of course, that does not preclude our taking action in relation to safety and road improvements on the A9, on which I can give some detail shortly.

However, I say to Douglas Ross that it is important in such infrastructure projects that we adhere to the obligation to provide value for money. We will give the update on the other side of the summer recess, in autumn 2023, but anybody who is listening should be absolutely assured that we have a cast-iron guarantee to continue the dualling work that we have already started and to ensure that we dual the A9 from Perth to Inverness.

Douglas Ross Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is perhaps one of the most disappointing answers that I have ever heard in the chamber. Last year, deaths on the A9 were at a 20-year high. The First Minister was trying to say that the millions of pounds of investment and the upgrades that we have seen are a success. In a decade, the SNP has upgraded 11 miles of the route—just over a mile a year—and somehow that is a success, while still too many families grieve the loss of a loved one.

During his leadership bid, Humza Yousaf claimed that dualling the A9 would be

“the first thing I will do”

in office. However, since his election, Laura Hansler, who has been campaigning for improvements on the A9, has said:

“Humza Yousaf made a lot of promises—so where are these promises?”

This week, Humza Yousaf’s Government lodged a question in order to announce the latest procurement timetable for the A9, but it was withdrawn at the last minute. We do not believe that that has happened before in this Parliament. Can the First Minister tell us why that announcement was withdrawn? Will he use the opportunity today, at First Minister’s questions, to tell us what his Government had planned to announce earlier this week?

Humza Yousaf SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Pollok
link

The Government-initiated question was withdrawn. I do not know whether Douglas Ross was in the chamber this week or doing one of his other jobs, but, if he had been here in the chamber, he would have seen that we have a new transport team in place. It is only right, of course, that I have asked that transport team to look at the detail of dualling of the A9.

It is also incredibly important, for the Government in particular, that when we give information to Parliament it is the most up-to-date and accurate information that we can provide. Today, of all days, the Conservatives should understand the value of accurate statements being made to this Parliament.

I have already asked the new transport team to look at A9 dualling and, of course, to update Parliament in due course.

In terms of safety—because I always bring it back to the issue of safety, which is so important when it comes to dualling the A9—we have an on-going programme of road safety improvements, so the fact that we are taking time in relation to the timetable for the A9 this summer does not stop us from making those road safety improvements. For example, last year we spent approximately £100,000 to improve safety at three sites on the A9. We have also invested almost £400,000 to refurbish the average-speed system between Dunblane and Inverness. Since January, as part of a £5 million investment by 2024-25, we have delivered lining and signing improvements around Dunkeld. Additional signs are being installed at key locations, too, and we have made a number of other interventions.

I go back to what I said at the beginning of my response to Douglas Ross’s first question: a single loss of life on our roads is not acceptable. That is why we have very ambitious targets in relation to reducing casualties and fatalities on our roads. The longer-term trend for road fatalities in Scotland has been downward: since 2000, the number of people who are killed on our roads has decreased by 47 per cent.

However, I want us to go even further, which is why dualling the A9 is a priority for the Government. We will continue to make progress on that priority.

Douglas Ross Con Highlands and Islands
link

The First Minister is trying to say that the change of transport minister is the reason why his Government took what was, as far as we are aware, the unprecedented step of withdrawing an announcement. The question was lodged at 3:47 on Monday afternoon. It was just a little over 12 hours later that the new transport minister was in place. That was almost a week after the previous transport minister had resigned. Something happened between Monday afternoon, when Jim Fairlie, as a back-bench MSP, was asked to lodge the question in order to get an announcement from the Scottish Government, and the question’s being withdrawn. The fact that we were going to have a new transport minister was known to the First Minister, to the Cabinet and to the entire Parliament. Why did the question have to be withdrawn? What did the SNP want to tell Parliament and Scotland about the A9 that it now sounds like the First Minister is not going to tell us until the autumn? These are serious questions that need to be answered.

We also heard this week from the Civil Engineering Contractors Association. It said:

“The civil engineering sector in Scotland have known for many years that the promise to dual the A9 2025 would not be met.”

It said that the SNP-run Transport Scotland is regarded by civil engineers as

“the worst client to work for in the”

United Kingdom.

Does the First Minister have full confidence in his agency to dual the A9 from Perth to Inverness, and will he tell us what he planned to announce in Parliament this week that now seems to be delayed for months?

Humza Yousaf SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Pollok
link

I have already answered the question about withdrawal of the Government-initiated question. There is a new transport team in place and it is looking again at the timetable for A9 dualling. As I have said, it is very important and when we are ready to update Parliament with an announcement on the A9, we will absolutely do that. We will also ensure, of course, that any update that we provide in a statement to Parliament is accurate.

On the criticisms from the Civil Engineering Contractors Association—which I have seen—I take them very seriously. I have asked Transport Scotland, which has engaged with CECA before, to ensure that it continues to engage with the association to consider what improvements can be made to our contract delivery, which is important, but also to the procurement mechanisms that we have in place to maximise market interest in the new procurement. I think that there is a lot in the submission from CECA that we can reflect on. I expect Transport Scotland—as I have told it—to reflect on it.

On Transport Scotland’s ability to deliver infrastructure projects, I remind Douglas Ross that, under the SNP Government, we have seen delivery of the Queensferry crossing, the Aberdeen western peripheral route, the M8, M73 and M74 motorway improvement projects and many other infrastructure projects—not only on roads but in rail, for example. We have a proud track record of investing in capital infrastructure in Scotland and of improving roads and rail across the country, and I will look to ensure that we build on that progress. [Applause.]

Douglas Ross Con Highlands and Islands
link

The “proud track record” that SNP politicians applaud has seen only 11 miles of the A9 being dualled in a decade, despite the SNP’s having said a decade and a half ago that it would be fully dualled.

The First Minister is getting annoyed about having to repeat answers about the withdrawn question. He must have known that he was about to appoint a new transport minister. I have said that, on Monday afternoon, his Government asked one of his back benchers to lodge a question. Will he pledge now to publish all details of communication between Government ministers, Transport Scotland and special advisers on what led to the decision—which is, I think, unprecedented in Parliament—to withdraw that Government-initiated question?

The fact is that the SNP has broken its promises to dual the A9 for 16 years, and there is still no end in sight, with devastating consequences for so many families. People from Perthshire to the Highlands are scathing about the Government’s record. They feel that they are being forgotten by SNP politicians at Holyrood. They say that failing to get the situation fixed is a dereliction of duty. Campaigners say that they fear that dualling the A9 will now take to 2050. Is it really going to take another 30 years to fulfil a promise that was made by the SNP more than a decade and a half ago?

I go back to my first question. How many more people have to die before that road is fully dualled?

Humza Yousaf SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Pollok
link

It is not going to take until 2050 to dual the A9. As I have said, we will give an update to Parliament, as previous transport secretaries have said, once the work is done over the course of the summer.

One of our other challenges with capital infrastructure projects, of course, is the increasing costs because of high inflation. The Conservatives should know about that well, given that they are the architects of sky-high inflation because of their economic mismanagement of the public finances. The Conservative UK Government has, of course, repeatedly cut our capital budget over the years. That is why we have to make extremely difficult choices. However, even with those difficult choices, I reiterate once again our cast-iron guarantee on dualling the A9 and building on the progress that we have already made. [Interruption.]

Alison Johnstone The Presiding Officer · Lothian
link

I have already asked members to resist any temptation to contribute while members are putting questions or while they are being responded to.

Humza Yousaf SNP The First Minister · Glasgow Pollok
link

On the GIQ, I have already made it clear that we have a new transport team in place, and I have asked that new transport team to look at the issue once again.

This is desperate stuff from Douglas Ross, who is no doubt trying to dodge and deflect from the serious scandal that his party is engulfed in, with Boris Johnson having not just lied to the House of Commons but having betrayed the people of this country and the UK. When people could not visit a loved one or attend the funeral of a loved one—[Interruption.] The Conservatives should not be shouting this down. When people could not attend the funeral of a loved one, Boris Johnson was breaking the rules and having parties in number 10. Douglas Ross can try to deflect and dodge, but nobody in this country will forget that he backed Boris Johnson to the hilt.

  1. General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. Highly Protected Marine Areas (Community Engagement) Questions · 10
  3. Paramedic, Nursing and Midwifery Student Bursary Questions · 4
  4. Ukrainian Children Leaving MS Victoria (Education) Questions · 8
  5. EventScotland and Creative Scotland (Funding) Questions · 6
  6. Child Obesity Rate Questions · 8
  7. Skills Delivery Landscape (Independent Review) Questions · 5
  8. A9 Dualling First Minister’s Questions · 10
  9. Cancer Strategy First Minister’s Questions · 6
  10. Rural Schools (Viability) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  11. Clean Air Day First Minister’s Questions · 10
  12. Heating Systems in New-build Homes First Minister’s Questions · 10
  13. Scottish SPCA First Minister’s Questions · 7
  14. World Blood Donor Day First Minister’s Questions · 2
  15. Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Polmadie Station) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  16. Child Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 2
  17. Bracken Control First Minister’s Questions · 2
  18. Abortion Services Safe Access Zones (Scotland) Bill First Minister’s Questions · 2
  19. Car Wash Licensing Scheme (Human Trafficking and Modern Slavery) First Minister’s Questions · 3
  20. World Asthma Day 2023 Members’ business · 10
  21. Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body Question Time Questions · 1
  22. Passholder Secure Entry System (Access Difficulties) Questions · 4
  23. Car Parking for MSPs and Staff Questions · 4
  24. Children and Young People (Visits) Questions · 6
  25. Scottish Parliamentary Business (Public Access Apps) Questions · 5
  26. Net Zero and Just Transition Questions · 1
  27. Just Transition Plan for Energy Questions · 11
  28. Net Zero Transition (Economic Benefits) Questions · 6
  29. Water Scarcity (Peatland Restoration) Questions · 6
  30. 20mph Speed Limit Questions · 4
  31. River Water Quality Testing (North-east Scotland) Questions · 9
  32. Environmental Quality and Protection (Community Initiatives) Questions · 4
  33. Just Transition (Grangemouth Community) Questions · 5
  34. Provisional Outturn Statement · 32
  35. Gender-sensitive Audit Debate · 95
  36. Decision Time Decision time · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.