I will mention again the importance of using effective remedy, or access to justice as it is termed in international human rights law. That means effective processes as well as effective outcomes. To go back to what I said at the beginning, we can think about it from the perspective of a rights holder. You will see this with your constituents and research tells us this time and again: when something happens and people experience a violation of their dignity and of a right, they want an apology; they want it to stop happening; they want the issue to be fixed and they do not want it to happen to anyone else.
Our system is very individualised in nature. It relies on individuals bringing cases, which is really difficult for people who are in precarious circumstances. It also does not account for the clustered nature of the problems or the systemic issues. We rely on and place a huge burden on an individual to raise a case regardless of whether the routes are legal or non-judicial. We need to change that way of thinking to allow collective responses. Ultimately, regardless of whichever route is available to be taken, it needs to meet the threshold of being effective in nature and, at the moment, that is not what we have. From research into access to justice, we know that there are multiple barriers for people to overcome, even to use non-legal routes.
Let us go back to the start and think about this from the perspective of undergoing a journey. Something has happened to someone and they know that it is wrong but they do not know what to do about it. First, they need to be aware of their rights; they need legal consciousness of the fact that rights exist and that they are entitled to them. They also need to be aware of the processes and have knowledge of the system, and that needs to be supported with resources, whether those be financial, legal or emotional, because it is not fair to place the burden on one individual. In the mental health sector, for example, people often say that they use collective advocacy to raise such issues. There is a fear of retribution when an individual raises a case and they use a collective advocacy system to bring problems before various authorities.
We need to resolve the complexity of the system. Ideally, someone would be able to go to an ombudsman, a tribunal, or just a complaints body in the service that they are working for, but that body needs to be able to respond effectively and issue an effective remedy.
Also, people do not realise that, sometimes, if they pick one route, they can bar themselves from taking another route. People do not know enough when they engage with the system and there is not enough support to help them navigate it.
11:15
Ideally, you would have proper advice and co-located services available. Rather than asking people to come to see a lawyer, for example, you would ensure that advice providers are in places such as libraries, schools, or food banks. Food banks have unfortunately proliferated and that is where people go who experience clustered problems. There should also be support in doctors’ surgeries. Those are the types of places where people should be able to get support.
When the act comes into force, it will create a transformative system in which these rights take on a legal status. That will enable routes to effective remedies, but all the non-legal routes need to be supported and slightly recalibrated. The system needs to change in order to respond to the particular types of rights and the nature of the violations. It can be done through collective advocacy and collective cases and ensuring that people are not hindered from taking another route. Always, as a backstop, we need to ensure that people have access to a court as a means of last resort and as an overall supervisory body.
Finally, in that type of clustered approach or when you are responding to something structurally, there is the importance of moving away from looking at it as an individual case. People are not looking for compensation. They genuinely want their situation restored. Often, there is a fear that you will create some kind of litigation culture but it is about trying to address the violation itself and helping to restore people to the place where they should have been. It is about avoiding the administrative mud, where people get stuck in a system that will not even be able to give a remedy at the end of the day and ensuring that we change things to enable our systems to respond differently.
That means wider definitions of standing and different types of tests than those we currently use. We need to have a broader reasonableness test to assess and interrogate compliance with rights, ensuring that we can respond collectively and structurally to problems and ensuring that economic, social and cultural rights are grounds for challenge and can be raised in different places—perhaps a bit like a devolution issue, which can be raised in lower courts and the lower courts can then refer the issue up. If, for example, an issue comes up and a tribunal does not know how to respond to it, it could refer the issue up to the inner house for a response. There are so many different mechanisms to ensure that we open paths to justice for people and move away from this individualised approach.