To ask the Scottish Government whether it will provide an update on the deposit return scheme, in light of the First Minister recently stating that he was actively looking at options around the scheme and that he was “taking advice”. (S6T-01313)
Official Report · Chamber
Deposit Return Scheme
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Lorna Slater Green 9
- Maurice Golden Con 3
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 2
- Christine Grahame SNP 1
- Colin Smyth Lab 1
- Liam McArthur LD 1
- Liam Kerr Con 1
- Fergus Ewing SNP 1
The record
19 contributions
link
Delivering a deposit return scheme is an important part of our environmental ambitions, and we remain committed to the scheme. However, we continue to need a decision from the United Kingdom Government on an exclusion for the scheme from the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020.
Over the past few weeks, the First Minister and I have made it clear that we want more to be done to support small businesses to be part of our deposit return scheme. That includes looking at options to address their concerns with a view to identifying fair, legal and simple solutions that will allow this important scheme to go ahead. The First Minister will provide an update this afternoon on the Scottish Government’s priorities for Scotland, which will include the deposit return scheme.
There was no answer there; I hope that the minister will be able to define the scheme, so that the UK Government can then make a decision.
With just four months to go until the scheme begins, the minister and the First Minister have floated major changes. As we stand here today, we have no clarity on what those changes will be, so I will ask the minister a very easy question. She has proposed changes in relation to small producers. What is the definition of “small producer”?
link
On working with businesses of all sizes, we want all businesses to participate in Scotland’s deposit return scheme that are included by the regulations. As I said, the First Minister will provide an update this afternoon on the Scottish Government’s priorities for Scotland, which will include the deposit return scheme, and I will provide further details in my statement on Thursday. The First Minister and I have made it clear that we want more to be done to support small businesses to be part of our deposit return scheme, and we continue to assess the options.
There was no definition and no understanding of the difference between a small producer and a small business. It is no wonder that the scheme faces such severe problems, but there is more. The minister welcomed the award of the collections contract for deposit return to a multinational company with a dubious environmental record. When the Scottish Government agreed the proposition of DRS in 2021 with Circularity Scotland, it agreed that no new vehicles would be purchased and that no new sheds would be built, yet 200 gas-guzzling vehicles have been purchased and up to eight new sheds have been built. Why did the minister not hold Circularity Scotland to account?
link
Like similar deposit return schemes around the world, and under the legislation as passed by the Parliament, Scotland’s deposit return scheme is an industry-led scheme. It is led by Circularity Scotland, which is a private not-for-profit company whose business decisions are for it to make. Circularity Scotland was set up by producers, retailers and wholesalers and, as a private company, it decides how to deliver the scheme for Scotland.
As members can imagine, I have received a number of requests for supplementaries. I very much doubt that I will get them all in, but I will try to take as many as I can.
I understand that the current system of packaging waste recycling notes will end when Circularity Scotland’s system kicks in. Who will benefit from the loss of PRNs? Who will experience a disbenefit?
link
The current PRN system is part of the producer responsibility system. The deposit return scheme is also a producer responsibility system, so we are working with the PRN scheme to ensure that, in the transfer from the existing scheme to the new scheme, anyone who has participated in the PRN scheme is not double charged and does not have to pay a producer responsibility charge twice.
In a letter last week to the First Minister, the Campaign for Pubs spoke for the many small producers in my region when it said:
“DRS exists in many jurisdictions and is the right policy for our time, but couldn’t be realised in a worse manner than the Scottish proposed scheme ... The few winners ... appear to be large industrial drinks producers and one large recycling company, who are delighting in the sweeping away of SME competition.”
Why has the minister got this so badly wrong that so few small producers have signed up for the scheme, which they see as destroying their business?
link
I am not sure that the member has that right—hundreds of small producers have signed up to the scheme. Six hundred and seventy producers have signed up, including many hundreds of small producers. [Interruption.]
Members.
link
As I have said, the First Minister and I have been clear that we want more to be done to support small businesses, including small producers, to be part of our deposit return scheme.
I will not pre-empt the statements from the First Minister or myself. The First Minister will provide an update on the Scottish Government’s priorities this afternoon and I will provide further details in my statement to Parliament on Thursday.
link
Does the minister not recognise that the Scottish Government’s succession of changes and many U-turns on the proposal has, as Colin Smyth suggested, undermined any prospect of it delivering the scheme? Such schemes are being successfully operated in countries around the world, but the Government has made an absolute shambles of it. Does she realise the damage that that is causing businesses across the country?
link
I do not agree with the member’s characterisation of the scheme. There have been no U-turns, and we have been committed to the scheme from the start.
We have been listening to business and systematically working through business interests to ensure that they can participate in the scheme by, for example, streamlining the exclusion process, working on cash-flow issues and working on labelling issues for smaller runs of product. We have been doing all that in line with business requests. We will continue to work with businesses to make sure that they can all fully participate in the scheme.
If the member is concerned about uncertainty, I am sure that he is as shocked as I that, with just four months to go, the United Kingdom Government continues to keep us and Scottish businesses in limbo by not granting an exclusion from the United Kingdom Internal Market Act 2020 in a timely fashion. The uncertainty is frustrating progress on the scheme and undermining certainty for businesses. I reiterate my call to the UK Government to follow the process and to grant the exclusion urgently, so that we can give businesses the certainty that they need.
link
According to Circularity Scotland’s branding and communications plan, we should be two months into the consumer campaign ramp up for DRS. What precisely has been produced? Has the campaign started? If so, is it on track?
link
The beginning of the communications plan for the deposit return scheme is to ensure that businesses understand what they need to do. Circularity Scotland has ramped that up in the past two months in particular, to ensure that producers know and that those acting as return point operators understand what their obligations are, and it has been working them through the process of their signing up to and fully participating in the scheme.
First, we had producer registration. Now, we have return point operator registration open. Consumer comms will be part of that as that goes forward. In terms of communicating with consumers, all those steps are part of that communication plan.
Last week, in a letter to the First Minister, the Scottish Chambers of Commerce, the Federation of Small Businesses, the Scotch Whisky Association, the Confederation of British Industry and many other business organisations—virtually all of them—argued that the DRS would increase consumer prices above the 20p deposit, hitting the poorest hardest. Even David Harris, the boss of CSL, who is paid £300,000 a year, admits that that is the case. Does the minister agree with the boss of her own agency? If so, why is she as a Green Party representative so intent on imposing, at the height of the cost of living crisis, price hikes to the poorest people in Scotland? It is a kind of green poll tax.
link
I remind the member that Circularity Scotland is a private not-for-profit company, not an agency of the Scottish Government. I also remind the member that the regulations for the deposit return scheme were passed by this Parliament, and we are implementing those regulations.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 18 Apr 2023 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Topical Question Time Questions · 1
- Deposit Return Scheme Questions · 19
- Council Tax (Second Homes) Questions · 17
- Government Priorities for Scotland Statement · 63
- Cost of Living and Child Poverty Debate · 83
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 15
- Wear a Hat Day 2023 Members’ business · 13
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.