My question is on the back of something that the convener asked about. You went into it a little in your answer. Do you think that the problems that we have identified have been incubating since devolution and that Brexit has just thrown an intensity into the system? Do you have any further observations on that?
My second question is about section 35, which you mention in your submission. We all realise that that issue has nothing to do with Brexit; it has come to the fore in recent months because of the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill. The committee heard evidence from Professor Jim Gallagher two weeks ago. Referring to section 35, he said:
“It is there because devolved legislative power is writ very wide. The test of devolved competence is wide, because it involves anything that does not ‘relate to’ a reserved matter.”
Therefore,
“there is a real possibility that devolved legislation would have a material effect on law in relation to reserved matters but still not be reserved, so some kind of safety net was inevitable.”—Official Report, Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee, 9 March 2023; c 32-33.
What is your response to that? Do you agree with him?