I thank colleagues who signed my motion when I lodged it in November; it has now been rather overtaken by the events that it predicted. I thank all those who are taking part in the debate to highlight concerns about the A9 and other routes in my region and in their own areas.
My motion recognised
“that work on the A9”
was
“clearly not on schedule”,
and it noted
“calls for the Scottish Government to”
provide
“an updated and achievable timetable”
to
“be presented to ... Parliament as soon as possible”.
That was prescient, given that on 8 February, Scotland’s worst-kept secret was finally revealed: that the Scottish National Party’s promise to dual the A9 in its entirety between Perth and Inverness by 2025 would not be achieved.
It was a surprise to no one: not to those of us who, as politicians and as road users, have been campaigning for dualling for more than a decade; not to the communities who live alongside the route and rely on it as they go about their daily lives; not to the businesses for which the A9 is a vital link from and to the Highlands and Islands; and certainly not to the Scottish Government, which—even though it may have repeatedly given the impression otherwise—knew that the project was badly off track and years behind where it should have been.
Only weeks after that announcement, the Scottish Conservatives used our allotted party business to bring ministers to the chamber to answer more questions on why the project had gone so badly wrong, and why, when it was clear to all that the deadline was not going to be met, ministers kept pretending that all was fine.
That debate was a chance for Parliament to show its anger that the date would be missed, and for MSPs from across the Highlands and Islands, and from all parties, to stand up for their constituents. It was a chance for us to send a clear and unified message to the Scottish Government that our constituents were angry too and wanted answers, and that there should be no more excuses and no more delays.
However, that did not happen, because not one Highlands and Islands MSP from either the SNP or the Greens came along to the debate. When it came to the vote, every one of those members—bar Fergus Ewing, who I know had a valid reason to miss the debate—followed their whip and voted down any criticism of the Scottish Government for the A9 debacle. It was shameful.
I am pleased to see that Mr Ewing is in the chamber, and I look forward to hearing his contribution. I know that there are other MSPs from the region attending the debate too.
In that Conservative debate on 22 February, we finally learned when Scottish ministers had first been told that the 2025 target was not going to be met. Following an intervention, Jenny Gilruth told me that it was in late December 2022, and then—after appearing to have consulted the Deputy First Minister—she raised a point of order to put on record that it was actually on 7 December that ministers were first made aware. That clarity was welcome, although it took another three months for the Minister for Transport to inform Parliament of that.
However, we still do not know when Transport Scotland finally made the call that the target date would be missed. In a written response that I received earlier this afternoon—conveniently—the minister would say only that it was in late December. We still do not know when doubts were first raised in the Government and in Transport Scotland over whether that date could be delivered. We still do not know when contractors or consultants who were working on the project first raised concerns that it might not be completed on time. We do not even know by how many years the project is behind. That is why, in our motion for the debate on 22 February, the Scottish Conservatives called for ministers to commit Transport Scotland to publishing
“a quarterly update setting out progress against published targets.”
Perhaps the transport minister will give that commitment today.
I return briefly to the date of 7 December, when ministers were first told that dualling by 2025 was not achievable. On 15 December last year, eight days after Jenny Gilruth had said that ministers had been informed that the dualling would not be completed as promised, the Deputy First Minister, during questions on his budget statement to Parliament, told me, in direct response to my question on the A9 dualling, that
“The Government’s position on the completion of the dualling of the A9 remains intact.”—[Official Report, 15 December; c 86.]
If the minister stands by the 7 December date that she has given, what does she think is more likely? Is it that the Deputy First Minister had, as he prepared and presented his budget, and as an MSP whose constituency the A9 runs through, been kept out of the loop on a key manifesto commitment—one with serious financial implications—and was not aware that the 2025 date had been shelved, or that he did know and so may have misled Parliament?
As I spoke of in the previous debate on the A9, there are many reasons that the road needs to be dualled. Those are economic and social, and they are about connecting our communities and regions, but we must also never underestimate the safety benefits of dualling the route. As Inspector Greg Burns of Tayside’s road policing unit said only last week:
“if we had a dual carriageway section all the way up it would certainly reduce the likelihood of fatalities there.”
I drove down the route on Sunday, and as two police cars with blue lights sped past me, it was hard to escape that thick dread that another family may be getting a knock on the door from a police officer. Too many lives have already been lost, and every month of delay risks more. I take the opportunity to thank those, including local police, paramedics and firefighters, whose job it is to respond to incidents on the A9 and other roads. I thank all those who, like Conservative members and members on all sides of the chamber, will continue to fight for the dualling to be completed as soon as possible. I thank the A9 dual action group in particular for their work.
I am sure that we can all agree on one simple message for this Government—and this is a call that I have made before in the chamber: no more delays, no more excuses. Get the A9 dualled.
17:21