I welcome the panel. Professor Denham, I will start by picking up a point that you have just made. I also thank you for your written submission, which is welcome. I do not think that we in Scotland think enough about the English aspect of devolution. I was struck by your comments about your belief that tensions in the union stem from the conflation of the Government of England and the Government of the union, and that there has been a failure to delineate between the two.
With regard to intergovernmental relations, which is a major part of what we are looking at, what sort of system would you like to see in place? What system would be beneficial in mediating and leading to agreements between the component parts of the union in this day and age?
Thank you for that. I ask the other panellists to give their thoughts on the system that should be in place for intergovernmental relations and how we can improve them. May I turn to you first, Nicola?
Last week, interestingly, we heard evidence from civil servants who talked about the interrelationship between the system that we set up and the culture. There is a view that, if we put the system in place, the culture will follow. I do not know whether you agree with that. I want to bring in Akash Paun as well, but do you have a comment on the culture, Nicola?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.