The member has asked some really good questions. Circularity Scotland is a membership-based not-for-profit company. Its members include trade associations that are associated with small convenience stores, such as the Association of Convenience Stores, the National Federation of Retail Newsagents and the Scottish Grocers Federation—so they not only have a direct line to the information; they are also influencing Circularity Scotland’s decision making. The mechanism by which Circularity Scotland interacts with convenience stores is through their membership of those trade associations.
I meet those associations—and the Scottish Grocers Federation in particular—regularly and they have flagged up two categories of concern. First, they have emphasised that they want their members to participate in the scheme. They consider it a matter of footfall: where small grocers participate in the scheme, people will come through their doors, which is exactly what they want. They have asked me to help them to be involved in the scheme, and they are very supportive of it.
Secondly, some small businesses, particularly tiny ones, were concerned about their lack of storage space. Bakeries that sell bottled juice were also concerned, as you cannot have broken glass in a bakery. As the member pointed out, there are exemptions for such situations.
Let me give the high-level picture so that everybody understands. If you sell bottles and/or cans of juice, wine or anything else in Scotland, you have three options: you can choose to be a manual return point; you can choose to have an automated return point, which means installing a reverse vending machine; or, if it is applicable to you, you can choose to be exempt.
The grounds for exemption are proximity. For example, if several small stores are close together but a big store is nearby, the small stores might decide that they are not up for being return points and they can ask the big store to take their returns. Equally, they might decide that they want to work together to be a return point so they might pull together and get one reverse vending machine between them.
There are different models and it is up to each business to decide how it wants to proceed. If a business wants to be a return point, it can be a manual return point. That is the most cost-effective model if the business is collecting small amounts. That is probably what a convenience store would do. If a store has a small floor area, it might not have room for a reverse vending machine and it might not have high sale numbers of those products, so it would take them back as returns. In that case, customers would hand their bottles and cans over the counter.
The reverse vending machine infrastructure is probably most appropriate for bigger stores that not only have the space for them but the capital to do the up-front installations and the resource to do the administration of getting planning permission and all the things that go with that.
It is likely that big stores will have the reverse vending machines, small stores will have manual return points and other businesses that apply for an exemption—that is, small businesses or businesses with bakeries in them and so on—will be exempt.
On how we will know, we are the point at which it is with businesses to make their applications. Return point applications are open, so businesses can look at the evidence and decide what to do. Once the period of applications for return points is complete, we will have a picture of how many we have in Scotland and will know the mix—how many are manual and how many are RVMs. Then, knowing how much volume of material there is, we will be able to estimate how many will go to each point.
That will allow Biffa to work out its logistics. If there are more return points, that means fewer items per return point, whereas fewer return points means more items. Working out the logistics depends on exactly how many businesses sign up, where they are and what their volumes are, so it is an iterative process whereby we see what businesses have signed up.
I hope that I have answered the question. I might have drifted off a bit.