Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Section 22 Report

“The 2006/07 audit of Western Isles Health Board”

Friday 11 January 2008 Audit Committee Evidence session 380 contributions · 19 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

380 contributions · showing 1–200
Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

We now turn to our main business. The committee will take evidence for its inquiry into the section 22 report, "The 2006-07 audit of Western Isles Health Board".I will explain the procedure. Evidence will be taken from four panels of witnesses, the first of which is now in front of us. We want to allow the maximum time for witnesses to be questioned and for them to respond fully to questions, but questions and answers should be short so that we make the best use of the available time. This is not a one-off meeting that will be the end of the matter; rather, it is part of a wider process that will culminate in a committee report that will be placed before Parliament. I remind everybody that this is not a public meeting; it is a formal meeting of the committee that is being held in public. That is important. Those who run national organisations are answerable to members of the Scottish Parliament, and their actions are openly scrutinised by the Audit Committee, to which they are accountable. That is at the heart of our democratic system.I welcome panel 1. Ronnie Cleland is a former interim chairperson, and Malcolm Wright is a former interim chief executive, of NHS Western Isles. Mr Cleland has said that he does not wish to make an opening statement. Does Malcolm Wright wish to do so?

Malcolm Wright
link

Yes. Thank you, convener.I was asked by the former Minister for Health and Community Care, Andy Kerr, and Kevin Woods to lead an interim support team for NHS Western Isles. The deputy chief medical officer, Peter Donnelly, and the director of nursing for Dumfries and Galloway, Gordon Jamieson, supported me in that endeavour.The minister visited the Western Isles on 8 August 2006 and had a frank conversation with the board about his expectations in relation to its responsibilities for governance and proper management. We commenced our work on 14 August and completed it five months later on 25 January 2007 with the appointment of a new chair and new chief executive. Our terms of reference were to support the interim chair and the board and to assess the situation with regard to patient services, corporate working, the board's financial sustainability and partnership working. We held more than 40 interviews with members of staff in the early weeks, had open staff meetings, talked about our organisations and conducted a high-level review of documentation. I will briefly outline to the committee our main findings. We found that patient services were generally in a good condition, that there was an appropriate range of services, that the board was working towards its access targets, that hospitals were clean, that staff were trained and motivated and that strong primary care services and very good examples of good clinical practice existed—there were general practitioners with special interests, screening programmes were going well and there were a lot of good health improvement initiatives. However, we found that the main challenges that the board faced were in leadership, governance and management. We found a serious level of dysfunction in those areas. There was a breakdown in relations between the board and some of its key staff, which had led to a vote of no confidence. There was no employee director as a member of the board, as there is, I think, on every other health board in Scotland. I think that the Western Isles had the poorest staff survey in the whole national health service in Scotland. The survey results had not been published by the time that we arrived, although just about every other health board had published its results.Although the financial controls had improved with the appointment of a new finance director and two qualified accountants, we found that they still fell far short of what national recommendations and guidance required. The financial recovery plan was not adequate and, in many ways, fell far short of being sustainable and realistic, with large parts of it having no sound basis in action plans. We found that the executive team had not been operating effectively and that a number of systems of basic management and control were not being put into place. Finally, we found that the board had not engaged properly in effective partnership working with Comhairle nan Eilean Siar.We quickly came to the view that the health board's finances were in a serious condition and that the budgets had been overset by some £4.5 million, which was subsequently reported in an internal audit report. We came to the view that, without immediate action, the board was heading for a £1.7 million in-year deficit, so our immediate priority was to put in place control measures, and I would be happy to talk to the committee about the measures that we sought to put in place. We supplemented that action by commissioning a range of substantive and wide-ranging independent internal audit reports, and I would be happy to talk to the committee about those.We focused our work on a number of key areas: the restoration of full partnership working with staff; setting up partnership working with the comhairle, particularly the establishment of the community care partnership—I think that the board was the only one in Scotland that had not adequately progressed such work; dealing with a number of grievances and disciplinary cases that required to be resolved; dealing with the financial recovery plan and moving the board towards financial balance; putting in place systematic clinical governance arrangements; the formation of a clinical strategy for the board, which I would be happy to talk about because it is key to the board's future sustainability; and ensuring adequate internal and external communications and adequate corporate governance arrangements.In all, we found a very serious situation, but one that was capable of resolution with good leadership and strong management. The board faced and continues to face significant challenges, but there are also significant opportunities for it, particularly in joint working with the comhairle and community planning. There are also opportunities for it to work in clinical networks and managerial networks with other parts of the wider NHS in Scotland.We finished our work on 25 January 2007 and handed it over to an incoming chair and chief executive.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

The committee will now look in detail at some of the points that you have raised under the headings of governance arrangements and systems of internal control, leadership and management, the financial recovery plan and performance management arrangements. James Kelly will start the questioning.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

In Malcolm Wright's opening statement, he acknowledged that there were weaknesses in governance. Will the witnesses give a bit more detail about the arrangements that they put in place to address the weaknesses in corporate governance specifically?

Ronnie Cleland
link

We quickly realised that the committees that were required to enable the health board to operate effectively by ensuring corporate governance were not doing that work. I am talking about the clinical governance committee, the staff governance committee and the patient involvement and public partnership committee. We were extremely concerned about the lack of functionality of those high-level committees, which every health board has.Two levels of work were done with those committees. Because the committees are populated by non-executive board members, I took some time to discuss with each of the non-executive members their roles and inclinations, in the belief that people would make a stronger contribution in areas in which they were interested. That process went on over a period.As well as making some changes in the composition of the board's committees, we undertook a programme in which we involved a number of people from Malcolm Wright's support team and brought in external people to visit the Western Isles, in order to provide clarity on the role of the committees, how they should work, the structure, the reporting relationships and where they fitted into the bigger picture of corporate governance responsibility. We encouraged people to take up roles of responsibility in an effort to ensure that clear programmes of work were delineated, action plans were in place and progress was made.

Malcolm Wright
link

I will add to that by giving some examples of areas of corporate governance that we did not think were adequate.Part of the advantage of conducting such a wide range of interviews and discussions with staff was that a number of concerns emerged from that process. We commissioned the internal auditors, which are independent of the board, to produce a number of reports for us. One report covered the work of the remuneration committee and another covered the work of the endowment committee. The report on the remuneration committee found a number of weaknesses in control systems and audit trails in relation to how decisions were made, when meetings were held and the reporting of minutes back to the full board.The endowment committee is a key committee of the board, given its responsibility for the stewardship of money that has been donated by people on the islands. We found that it had not met for some four years and that there were four years of annual accounts that needed to be signed off. Clearly, that is not an acceptable position. At the December 2006 board meeting, we reached the stage of re-establishing the endowment committee and having a first detailed look at the accounts, on which the auditors made a presentation. We finally signed off those accounts in January. Those are specific examples of areas in which things had gone wrong and improvements needed to be made.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

George Foulkes has a quick point to make.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I have a supplementary question for Mr Wright. Although the deficit in 2005-06 was by far the largest, there were substantial deficits in 2003-04 and 2004-05. Why did it take so long for you to be appointed to sort out the position? Were the problems allowed to run on for too long?

Malcolm Wright
link

I am not really in a position to make a judgment on that. The previous Minister for Health and Community Care was very concerned about the operation and corporate governance of the board. In the months leading up to his visit on 8 August 2006, he had made very clear to the board what it needed to do. We need to be clear about the responsibilities of Government and of the board. It seems to me that the board is a statutory body that is charged by Government and Parliament to fulfil its functions. We concluded that, although what we came across was very serious, there was nothing that could not be resolved by the board itself. In my view, the then minister recognised that. There was the visit in August 2006, and our coming in really helped to identify that.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Do you not think that civil servants should have been telling the minister earlier that something needed to been done about Western Isles Health Board, rather than waiting for the 2005-06 deficit to emerge? It was, for comparison, about £500,000 in 2003-04 and £500,000 again in 2004-05. If you were head of the NHS in Scotland, would you not have said, "My goodness, something needs to be done about this"? Would you not be asking the minister to do something quickly?

Malcolm Wright
link

I am not head of the NHS in Scotland.

Malcolm Wright
link

I was asked to come in and do a particular job at a particular time. In coming in to do that job, I was aware that the Scottish Executive had offered a range of support to the health board in times past. I am sure that you will question subsequent panels on that. All I know is that I got a call and I was asked to come in. We found what we did, and the actions that I am able to describe are those that we took.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

You were walking into a deficit situation, which continued. What could you do about that?

Ronnie Cleland
link

I will start on that point, and I will then hand over to Malcolm Wright for the detail. You are absolutely right to say that we came into a deficit situation. Malcolm has already mentioned the various investigatory conversations that we held with a range of people and, as part of our initial work, we identified a number of areas where we felt there was room for improvement. In fact, I would be better to describe it as room for immediate action—and we took some immediate action. We had to arrest the deficit and its incline, and bring it back down. We brought a downward trend into the size of the deficit. Malcolm Wright will happily give you some examples of actions that were taken, if that would be helpful.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

In 2005-06, the deficit went up to £1.7 million. Then you got it down to half of that. However, that is still £880,000, compared with previous figures of £444,000 and £495,000. Clearly, that was a chronic situation.

Ronnie Cleland
link

You might want to use the phrase "run rate" in determining what we did. You are absolutely right—that was the nature of the beast that we came across. It was a difficult situation, with a load of problems. You asked what we could do about it. We can give you some clear examples of what we did about it immediately—upon arrival.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

What assistance was available to you to help solve the problems?

Malcolm Wright
link

We were able to call on whatever assistance we needed. We were able to call on colleagues from the Scottish Executive and from other health boards to come in and do specific bits of work for us. We quickly came to the eight areas that I outlined earlier and put a plan to the board around them. We were taking forward a range of actions. The point about the run rate on the money is important. Having reasonably quickly concluded that the budgets were overset by £4.5 million—for an overall budget of £60 million, that is a very serious position—and having reached a projected overspend of £1.7 million in year, the immediate priority was to clamp the expenditure and control the cash that was going out the door. There were a number of things that we could do immediately. I think that there were 52 order pads in NHS Western Isles—52 points where people were able to order things and commit the board to expenditure. We reduced that number to six. We also reduced to seven the number of people who could authorise expenditure and who had authority to sign things—that is, the directors and one or two senior people on the board. We controlled that quickly.We put in place a vacancy review mechanism. Basically, we said that no post was to be filled until it had been through a mechanism. That process was not easy, but we tried to follow it in partnership with staff, taking into account clinical concerns and the financial situation. Certain posts were approved, but we said that we just could not afford to fill others.We considered staff travel and control mechanisms for referral of patients to the mainland. Most NHS boards would have such systems in place. We found that adequate systems were not in place, so we worked with colleagues on the board, particularly the director of public health and the medical director, to put them in place.There was discussion of whether there was a plan for managing and controlling prescribing costs, but that was not an area that featured particularly strongly.I could go on. We sought to do a number of things immediately to reduce the run rate of cash from the organisation. By the time we left, our best estimate was that there would be an £800,000 overspend. There were opportunities to pull that down further, depending on follow-through action.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Although we are under time constraints, I am anxious to give you every opportunity to explain things fully. It is important that we hear the evidence.

Ronnie Cleland
link

I will give a short supplementary answer. You asked what resources were available to us. Our brief was to come here and do things. The quality of the people in the support team that I was given enabled me to feel comfortable that we could make decisions and take actions on the ground when we required to do so. It also gave me the freedom to reach out whenever I wanted to get support from within the Executive or from elsewhere in the NHS. We had a clear brief to sort things as best we could and create a stable situation for the people coming in. We needed to take action quickly and we were able to do so.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

Welcome to the meeting. During your period as interim leaders of the board, was it part of your remit to produce a report for ministers about the overall situation in relation to governance and other aspects of the board's work?

Ronnie Cleland
link

Our remit was not to produce a report. As I have said, our remit was to do what we could to sort things and produce as stable a situation as possible for the incoming chair and chief executive.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

So, you were not asked to report to ministers on the situation in the board in any drawn-together, substantive way.

Ronnie Cleland
link

We were not asked to produce a report, but we were clear that, according to normal managerial reporting relationship convention, we would let people know what we were doing. It is important to say that, on many occasions, we let people know what we had done, because our clear remit was to take action quickly. We made decisions on a day-by-day basis. We had communication with the then Scottish Executive, but most of that was our informing it what we had done. There was no requirement for us to produce a formal report.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

I should explain that Alasdair Allan is not a member of the committee but the MSP for the Western Isles. He is welcome.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

Malcolm Wright said that the budget was overstated by £4.5 million. The Audit Scotland report states a figure of £1.6 million. Will you clarify that? More important, how was the budget able to be overstated by such a large amount?

Malcolm Wright
link

The reconciliation between those two figures is explained in an internal audit report that was undertaken. Once we had identified the budget oversetting, some of the pull-back in the budget allocations could be carried out relatively quickly. I would need to refer back to the detailed internal audit report, but I know that there was an underlying £1.7 million that had been allocated out in real terms. I commissioned an independent internal audit report to look at the reasons for that. That report was produced and was then presented to the board's audit committee. We are talking about systems of control and matching income with what goes through the ledger within the board and the finance department. Errors had been made within the board, in terms of basic reconciliation of figures.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

It just seems quite astonishing that in working to a £60 million budget, the board can somehow manage to get into a situation in which the sums are out by around £1.6 million. Are you saying that that was related to the ledger systems, in that inaccurate budget information was posted on to the ledgers?

Malcolm Wright
link

I am not a qualified accountant, but there is a detailed internal audit report on that situation. My understanding was that budgets were allocated on to the ledger, and the reconciliation back to income was not carried out correctly. Once that was spotted, it was relatively straightforward to pull some of that money back, but there was the on-going issue concerning the £1.7 million that we really needed to manage down very hard. There was a very serious breakdown within the board.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Something fundamental within the organisation that should have been working was not working, so what did you do about it? Why was it not spotted before?

Malcolm Wright
link

I do not know why it was not spotted before, but as soon as we came in we sat down and went through the budgets and the financial recovery plan line by line, and that is what emerged through our work. As soon as it was spotted, immediate action was taken and, as I said, I commissioned an internal audit report—which is available—to examine the detail of that. To me, the most important thing was to stop the run rate of the money flowing out of the board and to put in place much better control systems that would bring the board back towards financial balance.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

We move on to leadership and management.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have a couple of questions. You have spoken about the terms of reference of the interim support team. Will you say a wee bit more about the objectives that were set by the team, and whether those objectives were achieved? You were here for five months: did you have adequate time and resources to achieve the objectives?

Ronnie Cleland
link

Are you talking about individual or corporate objectives?

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am talking about corporate objectives.

Ronnie Cleland
link

Malcolm Wright has already indicated the eight key items that we agreed with the board. It was important that we had engagement such that the board was signed up to what we were asking it to do. It had to understand why things needed to be done and why it needed to support them, and it needed to know what it had to do in a very short space of time. The corporate objectives were encompassed in the eight headings that Malcolm Wright mentioned—he can expand on that later if the committee wishes. We then translated that into individual objectives for both the NEDs—

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

We hate acronyms in this committee.

Ronnie Cleland
link

Sorry—for the non-executive directors as a group and for the executives. As I mentioned earlier, I spoke to each non-executive director to identify what I wanted them to do and what they wanted to do in order to achieve a cohesive unit. We then put in place training and development to help them understand their corporate responsibilities. I can expand on that at some point if members wish.It was a similar process as far as the individual executive team was concerned. We said, "This is what we want you to do, and this is what we want you to do within six months". We tried at the end of August to make it clear where we were, where we were going and what they had to do to achieve that. We were clear and forceful. We had—as Claire Baker rightly pointed out—a limited timescale, so we had a reinforcing seminar session with everyone in October at which we repeated where we were going and reinforced the point.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Did you get to where you aimed to be within that timescale?

Malcolm Wright
link

We were able to make significant progress, although I cannot report that everything was sorted. George Foulkes asked whether we had enough time or whether we should have stayed longer—I think that that is what he was hinting at. One of the priorities was to appoint a permanent chair and a permanent chief executive, because we were only ever going to be here as part of an interim team. The sooner a permanent chair and a permanent chief executive were in place, the better. The eight areas seemed to me to be—

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

You did not succeed in getting a permanent chief executive, though, did you?

Malcolm Wright
link

A permanent chief executive was appointed and we handed over—

Malcolm Wright
link

I understand so.

Ronnie Cleland
link

This is a difficult area, convener. It is difficult to discuss the allocation of blame, given the situation with the chief executive.

Ronnie Cleland
link

I am not trying to avoid the question.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have one more question. You said that there was nothing that the board could not overcome by itself. Do the current management and board have the appropriate skills and, more important, the appropriate support to address the weaknesses that have been identified?

Ronnie Cleland
link

At our final board meeting, which I think was on 25 January 2007, Malcolm Wright gave a public presentation on what we had been asked to do, what we had found, what we did about it and where we were at that time. We believed—we have reason to believe that this was acknowledged—that we had made significant progress. There was still work to be done with all the individuals involved at both executive and non-executive levels within the board, and an indication of the requirements was passed on to the new chair and the chief executive.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

You stated that you laid down clear lines of progress and what you wanted to be done. Was there a communication problem? Why were those things not done, given that you passed them on for action? You were speaking, but who was listening and acting?

Ronnie Cleland
link

Do you mean in the handover or during the time we were here?

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

I mean in terms of the objectives that you put forward for changes that you thought were necessary.

Ronnie Cleland
link

Many people were not clear about their roles and responsibilities. You asked earlier about resources: we brought in external people to talk about the roles and remits of audit committees, clinical governance committees and staff governance committees, what is expected of them and how they are chaired. Some of the conversations showed me that people were not clear about how those things should be done.We did not leave it there. We brought people in to try to develop the situation and, as a team, we spent time with individuals to try to ensure that they took on board the training and development, that they understood it and that it enhanced their performance. A lot of work was put in and there was certainly some improvement.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

We are talking about fundamental management.

Ronnie Cleland
link

Yes, we are.

Malcolm Wright
link

I will address capability and capacity. Western Isles NHS Board is one of the smaller NHS boards in Scotland, and it will always be a challenge to get the breadth and depth of managerial and clinical capacity in a board of its size. We will not get the breadth and depth that is found in, say, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, or NHS Lothian.We could take the view that, in the Western Isles, we must do everything ourselves and we must have the complete breadth and depth here, but that approach is not likely to succeed. We should take the view that we are part of the wider NHS in Scotland, that we need to link in with clinicians in Highland NHS Board, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, and the NHS in other parts of Scotland as part of managed clinical networks, and that a similar principle applies to management. There are different types of management and we need to link into bigger centres so that their depth of expertise can be drawn on. If the board adopts the mindset that it needs to be part of the wider NHS in Scotland, to draw in available expertise and to link with other boards in order to use that expertise, there is every prospect that it will flourish.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

In examining the board's leadership and governance, did you feel that changes needed to be made to the systems and mechanisms for scrutinising senior appointments?

Ronnie Cleland
link

Are you talking about the structure and the people who held various posts within it?

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

Yes, and the way in which people were appointed, how appointments were scrutinised and so on. Was that part of your remit?

Ronnie Cleland
link

No. Our remit was to focus on the existing structure and to find out how to make it work better. Of course, that meant that we had to make some personnel changes in the organisation.

Ronnie Cleland
link

We did not look at how people had been recruited in the past.

Malcolm Wright
link

That said, I should add that we also considered the internal audit report relating to the remuneration committee and we considered the committee's effectiveness. The board has to ensure that certain basic governance systems for approving senior appointments are in place.

Ronnie Cleland
link

That is an important point. We certainly looked at governance issues with regard to the remuneration committee. I thought that the question was about operational issues.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

What concerns, if any, did you have about the operation of the remuneration committee?

Ronnie Cleland
link

We were a bit concerned about the number of times it had met prior to our arrival. I have been in the NHS for a number of years, so I know that the remuneration committee should meet three or four times a year, but it had met nowhere near that many times.The remuneration committee has a very clear responsibility—we felt that we had make it meet in order to get its membership to understand the remit. I might be slightly wrong, but I think that in the time we were on the board it met three times in six months to deal with a number of issues. I know that it certainly met twice.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Stuart McMillan will ask about finance.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

Mr Wright said in his opening remarks that the financial recovery plan that was in place was not adequate, and touched on the various control measures and the system of internal audit reports that were introduced. Will you tell us more about those measures? Did you propose your own financial recovery plan?

Malcolm Wright
link

We considered a range of internal controls to deal with certain matters. For example, I have already mentioned the order pads and who was authorised to make expenditure on the board's behalf. We also looked at issues such as central vacancy controls, courses and conferences, and off-island visits.The board had three medical directors. I felt that a board of its size needs only one medical director who could span primary and secondary care. We also sought to appoint a new head of communications.I would like to come back to the point about clinical strategy. We certainly tried to address those issues head on and to ensure that the control systems that Audit Scotland would expect were put in place and could be evidenced.

Ronnie Cleland
link

On the financial recovery plan, we certainly worked very hard on that. Malcolm Wright has just highlighted a number of the actions that were taken.We were very action-oriented with regard to governance; Malcolm Wright, I and the rest of the team met at least weekly to discuss finances. Malcolm had weekly meetings with the senior management team as and when required. The budgets were examined line by line, and actions were built on that basis. Everybody was left in no doubt that the position had to be rapidly recovered in order that a sustainable position could be created for the future.

Malcolm Wright
link

We went through the financial recovery plan line by line and tried to put confidence ratings on what was going to be achieved and what could not be achieved. In some instances, there were significant sums of money in the financial recovery plan, but once we got beneath the surface, examined the plans and established who was responsible and whether it was really going to happen in that financial year, a lot of it started to fall away.We sought to be realistic about what was in the financial recovery plan and what could be delivered, which knocked on to the fact that we needed to deliver on other matters. It was an on-going, line-by-line iterative process. As Ronnie Cleland said, I made sure that the executive team met every week and that the financial recovery plan was on its agenda weekly. I set personal objectives for each director from when we started until when we finished. There was personal performance management as well as organisational performance management.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Mr Wright said in response to a previous question that there was not, because of the health board's size, the breadth and depth of financial and administrative expertise on the island. I know that it might be a sensitive issue, but did you ever consider suggesting that the health board should join with another health board—not Glasgow—to provide it with that breadth of expertise and knowledge?

Ronnie Cleland
link

No—we never made that suggestion. What we have alluded to, if we have not said it directly this morning, is that we feel that there is room for mutual support within the NHS family. Some of that support could be fairly close by—Scotland is a small country and it does not take long to get here. We used that support as part of our team. I know that we are talking about finance, but we took some time to involve the human resources director, who came up from Tayside to spend some time with us on staff governance issues and remuneration committee issues. We felt that help and support could be provided to the board in that way. That model would represent a natural evolution in the development of the board without the formality of the restructuring that might otherwise be needed.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

When you examined the financial recovery plans, did you consider the underlying financial position of the board? I appreciate that this is slightly after your time, but paragraph 52 of the "Western Isles Health Board—Report on the 2006/07 audit" states:"There is evidence that the Board's underlying financial position is in fact more serious than suggested by the overall deficit. Taking into account other income sources and the results of a corporate savings programme, there is evidence to suggest that the Board has an underlying deficit of £8 million, as illustrated … below."What do you understand by "an underlying deficit", and would you like to comment on it?

Malcolm Wright
link

What we saw was the accumulated deficit from previous years. The immediate priority for us was to do something rapidly because there was a potential £1.7 million on top of that. It was necessary to put in place control measures, to get the run rate on the cash down and, as a first step, to get the board towards in-year balance. After that, the incoming chair and chief executive would need to take further steps to move the board to greater financial stability. To be honest, we were focused on the fact that we were in a serious situation, which had to be brought under control fairly rapidly.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

For clarification, is it correct that no new financial recovery plan was put in place and that you used the existing plan, which was constantly scrutinised and amended?

Malcolm Wright
link

That is fair. We went through the financial recovery plan that had been presented to the board line by line. We took that as our starting point and decided that some things in it were not likely to happen, that other things were not likely to happen to the degree that was suggested, that other things were likely to happen and that other things had to be included in it. In that way, we sought to develop the financial recovery plan rather than just starting from scratch.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

What dialogue did you have with the Scottish Executive in relation to the financial recovery plan and performance monitoring?

Malcolm Wright
link

We had regular dialogue with the Scottish Executive, as is consistent for any board in terms of the Scottish Executive's performance management of them. My experience, having been chief executive of two NHS trusts, two territorial health boards and a special health board, is that the boards that are starting to get into difficulty become engaged in much greater and deeper dialogue with the Scottish Executive. We had regular and on-going communication with the Scottish Executive about the situation. It was keen that we should put in place the measures and bring down the deficit.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

You say that the communication was "regular and on-going". Was that once a week, twice a week, once a fortnight or as required?

Ronnie Cleland
link

In a sense, a weekly conversation took place on a number of issues, during which we would say what we had done and what we were doing. I would have that regular conversation, but Malcolm Wright would also be involved in direct communication on financial matters about once a week. It is important to say that we dealt with things as we went along. Our diaries did not state that there would be a conversation at 3 o'clock on a Thursday. There would be ad hoc conversations, as and when they were required, to ensure that everything was moving in the right direction. The contact was regular.

Malcolm Wright
link

That is consistent with Ronnie Cleland's appointment by the minister as chair and my appointment as accountable officer with the board. It was absolutely appropriate—in terms of accountability to Parliament—that such discussions went on so that we could keep the Scottish Executive informed about the situation and the actions that we were taking. We were not necessarily requesting that the Scottish Executive do anything, because we felt that the primary responsibility for moving things forward lay with the board. We needed to put in place actions that would rectify the situation.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

The board would have to turn the plan for action into actual practice. From where could it get the skills and advice that would allow it to do so?

Ronnie Cleland
link

We were careful about how we presented issues to the board. We recognised that there were limitations and we took special care in spelling out the issues relating to a particular item, what the action should be and why we were taking that action. In that way, we began to stimulate more informed debate. When necessary, we would set out a broader context for what we were doing.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

What help or advice was there for board members who wanted to improve their skills or knowledge in order to assist in those decisions?

Ronnie Cleland
link

We arranged for people to come in and talk about particular areas and to provide education and development. Occasionally, we sent board members to other health boards so that they could observe what was being done and speak to people about what they were doing. In that sense, there was on-going training and development activity.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

From what you have said, there appears to have been adequate support from the Scottish Executive, as well as various discussions and so on. Do you think that there is adequate support from the current Scottish Government to NHS Western Isles?

Ronnie Cleland
link

I have had no involvement since I departed at the end of January 2007, so I cannot comment on the current situation.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Was that said with a sigh?

Ronnie Cleland
link

I couldn't possibly comment.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

My question is about performance management monitoring, reporting arrangements and so on. The Audit Scotland report states that"corporate objectives were not agreed"during your tenure, which was from August 2006 to January 2007. In fact, it took until June 2007—after you had gone—for them to be agreed. However, both of you have said that you set corporate objectives. That differs from the statement in the Audit Scotland report. Can you clarify that point?

Ronnie Cleland
link

I am happy to clarify that. This morning I have found myself using the words "clear", "clarity" and "clarified" quite a lot. That was the nature of the game. The Audit Scotland report is correct that the corporate performance management system was fragmented. There was no document that indicated clearly what the board was going to do, but the board minutes show that the areas were covered. I hope that my memory is correct when I say that the paper for the December board meeting included a heading of performance management. It was under such headings that we dealt with matters.The corporate performance objectives that the Scottish Executive had set were being addressed. As I am sure the committee is aware, those objectives are usually monitored through the annual review. I came up here on 8 August 2006 and we started on 14 August. The minister came to carry out the review on 11 September. We had to put in place a report on what had been achieved and delivered in the previous year. Out of the annual review came a number of clear corporate objectives that we had to deliver by December, so there was a range of work around corporate objectives that had to be done in a short time. I am pleased to say that we delivered that work.However, Audit Scotland is correct that there was no corporate objectives document. We did not instruct any one to write such a document because we were more concerned about the key areas on which we needed to work and the ministerial imperatives for the end of the year. I invite Malcolm Wright to confirm that that is correct.

Malcolm Wright
link

Yes. I will add to what Ronnie Cleland has said. The board decided to formulate a board recovery plan, based on the eight areas that I outlined earlier. The plan went to the board in December 2006, which the board decided would form the basis of on-going performance management reporting to the board. Our view was that we needed to move forward on the eight basic areas that had been identified. For example, I regarded partnership working with the comhairle as critical. I was pleased that the community health and care partnership proposals were able to move forward, and by the restoration of full partnership working, the appointment of an employee director to the board and the removal of the vote of no confidence. We also worked hard to resolve the various discipline and grievance cases that I have mentioned.We have not touched on clinical governance, which we regarded as fundamental. Gordon Jamieson, supported by Jane Adams, led on putting in place a clinical governance strategy for the board. We saw the organisation's clinical strategy as being fundamental. The unsustainability of the model of services that was being operated needed to be addressed. We needed to get the right balance between care that takes place off the island and care that is provided on the islands, and between what happens in the hospital sector and what can be done in the primary care sector.It seemed to me to be quite a big step to get the scoping paper to the board in December 2006, outlining the main issues for the clinical strategy and the proposed way forward. A new communications manager was appointed, and we carried out some of the things that Ronnie Cleland and I have described to do with corporate governance. The eight points were the framework that we sought to take forward for on-going performance management of the board.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Mr Cleland, on your ability as chair to hold your management to account, you have agreed that what the Audit Scotland report says is accurate, and that no agreed corporate objectives were operating internally during the period during which you served the board. Does that explain why Mr Wright said earlier that he did not know why the £1.6 million deficit occurred at an early stage?

Ronnie Cleland
link

When we came in there were no corporate objectives. We identified eight clear corporate objectives.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

According to the report, none had been agreed by the time you left.

Ronnie Cleland
link

I think that there might be an issue of nomenclature. The eight objectives were agreed by the board at its meeting in August 2006 as the key corporate objectives, and that is what we took forward. The outcome of the annual review was that they were objectives that the organisation needed to achieve by the end of December. That is the scope of the corporate objective structure within which we worked.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

The basic financial problem here seems to be that the spend was running away from the budget. One way of controlling that is to have a management accounting system in place in which there is monthly measurement of actual spend against the budget to identify variances. Was a system like that in place when you took over in August 2006?

Malcolm Wright
link

Yes—a system was in place to track expenditure month by month. We needed to take management action and to analyse the information and what it meant, and to decide what action managers needed to take to get expenditure under control. We were working closely with the finance department to ensure that reporting of expenditure was timely so that we could take action.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

Was expenditure being measured against the budget at that time?

Malcolm Wright
link

It was.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

When you came in, did you review that system and see any need to put improvements in place?

Malcolm Wright
link

When we came in, systems were in place in which there were regular monthly reports to the executive team and to the board about the monthly financial position. I guess we felt we needed much more rigorous management action. We needed to ask what the information was telling us: we needed to get below the detail of it and consider the underlying run rate on cash.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

So variances between actual spend and the budget were being flagged up but there was no investigation to assess the reason for the variances.

Malcolm Wright
link

Although I would not like to say that action was not being taken, one of the internal audit reports points to weaknesses in respect of individuals accepting responsibility for doing things about the variances and following through on agreed actions. There were improvements that could be made, such as managers at much more local level getting timely information on which they could base decisions. Improvements could be made and needed to be made.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

In summary, there was a basic reporting system in place, but enhancements needed to be made to it to make senior managers and managers aware of the actions that were required to address the financial shortcomings.

Malcolm Wright
link

Yes. Rigorous management action was needed, for example saying, "We're going to have much stronger vacancy control measures", "We're going to restrict the number of ordering points", and "We're going to look at study leave". That is what we sought to do.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

There seems to have been a slip between theory and practice. What system was in place to ensure that what was requested was actually delivered?

Malcolm Wright
link

All the executive directors of the board had personal objectives that I had agreed. I was responsible for performance management and I conducted performance appraisals before I left. We held weekly meetings of the executive team and we made absolutely sure about the financial position and the financial recovery plan. We went through it tediously, line by line, asking who was responsible for each issue and whether action was being taken. I followed that up with a range of one-to-one or small-group meetings so that we could consider individual projects and really get into the detail and hold people to account for delivery of those projects.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

That brings us to the end of our discussion with this first panel of witnesses. Do you have any final comments?

Malcolm Wright
link

No.

Ronnie Cleland
link

No.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Thank you for your evidence. If you wish to add anything, please write to us.We will now have a 15-minute suspension.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

I reconvene the meeting. We will now take evidence on finance from the second panel. I welcome Mr Ken Matthews and Mr Donald Macleod, who would like to make an opening statement.

Donald Macleod
link

Thank you very much, convener.I will tell members about my background. I have 32 years' experience of working in financial environments. I joined the health board in 1990 as a unit accountant and was appointed director of finance in May 1995. I served in that role until November 2004. My last financial report was for the period that ended in October 2004, which is more than three years ago.Towards the end of my time as director of finance, the finance function implemented a new financial management system known as eFinancials, which is the national system in NHS Scotland. The internal auditors reported that the system had improved the overall control framework and the flexibility and functionality of management cost reporting. Their work on financial controls did not highlight any fundamental control weaknesses. Those two statements are based on what was said in a January 2005 report and a March 2005 draft report. I understand that Audit Scotland's 2003-04 report said that the new financial management system had enabled the board to provide a clearer trail from the ledger to the financial statements.I was not involved in finance work at all from December 2004 until May 2006, when I left the board, but I was involved with staff who were trying to embed the risk agenda into the NHS board's day-to-day operations. We developed the risk management strategy and tried to develop a corporate risk register and risk management action plans. I also updated standing orders, documentation on decisions reserved for the board, schemes of delegation and the board's code of conduct. The approach was based on good practice in Tayside NHS Board. A number of those documents are on the NHS Western Isles website. I also set up a system for tracking outstanding audit recommendations. In my final 18 months, the role was slightly different.In my role as director of finance, the main cost pressures that I experienced towards October 2004 came from locum costs, difficulty in complying with the working time directive—similar difficulties were experienced by other boards—and increased mainland activity. Cases that are dealt with on the mainland are more complex, so treatment on the mainland is more expensive. In October 2004, the costs of GP out-of-hours services, the general medical services contract, the consultant contract, the agenda for change and pay modernisation were starting to have an impact.In addition, our allocation from the Scottish Executive's funding formula was reducing because our population was dropping. Prior to that year, we had been what is known as a gaining board, in that our uplift was higher than the national average, but with the drop in our population we became what is called a losing board—we received the minimum uplift—which had an impact on our financial position.Another point that I want to make is that during that period, not only did I leave, but a number of other senior finance staff in the department moved on. Given our combined service, between 70 and 80 years of NHS financial experience were lost. That is all that I would like to say at this point.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

My apologies to our witnesses. I now bid a formal welcome to Mr Donald Macleod, who is a former director of finance, NHS Western Isles, and Ken Matthews, who is a regional organiser for Unison. Derek Brownlee has the first question.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link

In your opening statement, you set out some of the issues that affected the finances of NHS Western Isles. We recognise that some of them are common to all NHS units in Scotland, while some are highly specific to this location. The position now is that there has been a fairly consistent period of deficits. In your view, what underlying problems—it is clear that such problems exist—have led to the deficits of NHS Western Isles?

Donald Macleod
link

I can comment on 2003-04, which was my last year as finance director. The deficit in 2003-04 was £294,000, which was less than 1 per cent of the allocation. In that year, the deficit came about as a result of a late decision by the interim chief executive to incur some early retirement costs. That is what pushed that year's budget over; we were not planning for a deficit in 2003-04.In 2004-05, I was involved in the reports that were produced up until October 2004. We in finance reported that if the board did not reduce expenditure and attempt to manage its locum costs, it could be heading for a deficit. We could also see the costs of GP out-of-hours services and the consultant contract on the horizon. At that time, the extent of those costs was generally unknown by boards—they were trying to get a handle on it. The in-year deficit was £444,000 and, as I understand it, there was a cumulative deficit over two years of £738,000.The deficit for 2005-06, in which I had no involvement, is a significant deficit, which does not seem to correlate with my experience. As I was not involved in that year's finances, it is difficult for me to comment. The cost pressures came from GP out-of-hours services, locum costs, the consultant contract and the agenda for change. There might have been changes to the management structure as well. However, the jump in costs between 2003-04, when the deficit resulted from a non-recurring cost, and 2005-06 and 2006-07 seems quite significant. A deficit started to appear in around 2004-05 because of the cost pressures that I have mentioned. In a small board, such costs are quite significant. It is difficult for me to comment on what happened in 2005-06 and 2006-07.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link

In general, most of the cost factors that you have mentioned seem to have arisen externally. In other words, they resulted from changes in policy and practice that, as far as I am aware, applied across the NHS and which might have had a disproportionate impact on NHS Western Isles. Are you saying that, although there are underlying cost pressures as a result of the specific geography and recruitment problems, the main change has been as a result of external factors?

Donald Macleod
link

The main change has been a result of external factors. I would have expected the changes to impact on the board and leave it in a difficult financial situation, but the deficit in 2005-06 seems higher than I would have expected it to be, based on my 10 years' experience. However, I acknowledge that GP out-of-hours provision and so on are cost pressures.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link

The other side of a deficit, apart from the cost, is the income stream, which you mentioned. You mentioned the change in the allocation. In the time that you were there—you might also be able to comment on what happened thereafter—was the budget allocation received by the Western Isles NHS Board adequate? Is it adequate now?

Donald Macleod
link

I was the director of finance. Under the old formula, we were a gaining board, which means that we received a higher than average uplift. I would be content with that and would not question the allocation. If I were a director of finance in a losing board and received a minimum allocation, I would tell the Scottish Executive that the allocation was unfair. There is a degree of advantage or disadvantage in the allocation, depending on the circumstances of the individual board. Western Isles NHS Board is in a rural, extremely remote and widely dispersed area from the Butt of Lewis to Barra. Its geography is probably unique; it is made up of a long stretch of islands from north to south, with communities scattered around the spine, which need to be supported by the NHS.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link

I suppose that you are saying that the funding allocation is okay for a gaining board but not for a losing board. That is another way of saying that the funding allocation is not adequate for boards such as yours, because it does not specifically take into account factors such as additional cost pressures.

Donald Macleod
link

Yes. Losing boards are given a degree of protection. They will receive a minimum uplift. We were due to lose £699,000 because we went from being a gaining board to a losing board. However, losing boards are protected by the Scottish Executive, which gives them a minimum uplift, which would be 6.5 per cent, whereas gaining boards would get 7.5 per cent or 8.25 per cent. A degree of protection is built in, but the change in allocation would certainly have had an impact.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link

If I picked you up correctly, you said that, at the time, you were a gaining board, but you are now a losing board.

Donald Macleod
link

Yes. Under the Arbuthnott formula, we became a gaining board. It was recognised that we needed additional funding, so we were given a higher than average uplift, because of factors such as our elderly population, low birth rate and dispersed communities. Our population then shifted considerably—there was a significant drop in the population. When that was keyed into the formula, our allocation dropped back to the minimum uplift.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link

At that point, it must have been clear that once such things flow through, they present challenges—to use the euphemism—for the organisation. Was any attempt made to get additional funding or to make the case that the formula was not appropriate to your circumstances?

Donald Macleod
link

My understanding is that the formula, which was called Arbuthnott 1, was due to be reviewed—there was to be Arbuthnott 2. The primary care element of the formula, which could have impacted significantly, was being looked at. A review was happening, to which we would have fed in.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Every director of finance says that the funding is not adequate. What reassurances can you give us about efficient use of finances?

Donald Macleod
link

When we were setting the budget, we would always set an efficiency target for budget holders. We would ask them to achieve a 1 or 2 per cent efficiency target and to produce plans for how to achieve it. All through my tenure in the NHS, we set budgets with 1, 2 or 3 per cent efficiency targets. As time went on, it got increasingly difficult to do that. However, we always set a 1 per cent target. The Scottish Executive in giving us the allocation would ask the board to identify its efficiency savings as 1 per cent of its budget.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Efficiency savings can be a bit of a chimera at times. How much did you succeed in hitting those targets?

Donald Macleod
link

It was difficult and challenging. I was director of finance from May 1995 till October 2004. During that period, we overspent only once, in 2003-04. That was to do with a one-off, non-recurring cost to which I alluded in my introductory speech. However, I have to acknowledge that, looking into the future, I could see that cost pressures were becoming significant for the NHS board.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link

When you were in post, what was the mechanism for reporting on the board's financial situation and keeping everyone up to date even in the years when the situation was significantly healthier than it is today? What were the lines of accountability?

Donald Macleod
link

Even in those days, the financial position was challenging, although we were managing it. We would do a monthly report for each budget manager and a report would go to the senior management team, the executive team and the board. We would also hold what we called team briefs with staff in the hospital community in which we would brief them on finance and usually also tell them what the overall situation was.In addition to that, each year we had to submit a five-year plan to the Scottish Executive, which would agree the plan. Each month, before the 15th day of the month, we would submit monitoring reports to the Scottish Executive. We would produce a range of reports each month for people down to departmental level and right up to the Scottish Executive.

Derek Brownlee Con South of Scotland
link

Are you aware of any change in the reporting mechanism over time or is it essentially the same as it was when you were in post?

Donald Macleod
link

I would say that it has stayed the same.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

What were the arrangements for internal and external audit? Did such a thing exist?

Donald Macleod
link

My understanding is that the Scottish Executive appoints external auditors. The internal audit was outsourced to an accountancy firm called Deloitte. Rather than each health board in the north of Scotland trying to do its own tender, the boards came together as a consortium to put out a tender for internal services. Private sector firms made bids and Deloitte was successful.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

What were the auditors saying towards the end of your time in post at the board? Did they raise any concerns about the way that things were headed?

Donald Macleod
link

All I can do is quote what I quoted in my introductory remarks. Reports were sent in January 2005 and March 2005. They did not raise any red-flag issues, as they are called. I have the March 2005 draft report here.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

Forgive me for not being an accountant, but what is a red-flag issue?

Donald Macleod
link

There is a red-green-amber system. Green means that things are okay; amber means that there is a risk; and red means that there is a high risk. The auditor did not identify any high-risk areas.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

Are you saying that, even by 2004, the auditors did not have access to any material that led them to suggest that any high risks were associated with your finance?

Donald Macleod
link

Yes, according to the report that I have here. We put in a new financial management system which significantly improved the reporting lines in terms of what are called business objects, which sit on top of the FMS, and gives standardised reports that are used throughout the NHS in Scotland. We were applying good practice. Being a small board, we were not trying to do things on our own. We were keeping our independence but, building on big brother, we introduced the eFinancials system, which was a national system, and we were part of an audit consortium for internal audit. My view at that time was that, with the new FMS, we had improved the financial reporting considerably.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

I will ask something about your introductory statement. You said that, when you left, other finance staff with a total of 70 to 80 years of financial experience left. That is an awful lot in a small board. Why did that happen?

Donald Macleod
link

I am not sure that I can answer that question. I have 16 years' NHS experience and I think that others who left had 32, 14 and 10 years' experience.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Mr Matthews seems to want to answer the question. Do you, Mr Matthews?

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

We should be careful not to stray into territory where we should not be.

Ken Matthews Unison
link

Obviously, I am happy to ensure that we do not stray into territory where we should not be. I can comment only as the staff representative for the individuals concerned. I have to declare that discussion of the subject of their leaving is constrained by a confidentiality agreement. Although I requested that that be waived for the purposes of this process, my request was denied, so I can only leave it to the committee to explore that if it so wishes.Individual senior officers within the finance department were the subject of what we have argued consistently was a fundamentally flawed and hostile finance investigation. Without being too impassioned or unreasonable, I think that there was an element of seeking scapegoats for the financial situation at the time, but I do not want to—

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

I think that we are going down the wrong road here.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

With respect, I do not think that we are going down the wrong road.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

I urge caution because all sides would have to be heard. We are entering into the discussion of individual cases so I urge caution; I do not think that that is the way to go.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

With respect, convener, it would appear to be material to the reasons why the health board got into financial difficulties. If a significant number of financial staff—with 70 to 80 years of experience between them—leave, surely the board is going to be incapacitated or find it difficult to maintain financial control.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

We need to keep it general, Mr Foulkes.

Ken Matthews Unison
link

Suffice to say that additional information could be made available to the committee if it wished, but I make it clear that it would be constrained by confidentiality agreements.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

We would appreciate it if you could give us that additional information.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Now that the convener is happier, I will return to easier territory.There have been other financial recovery plans, Mr Macleod. Why have they not succeeded?

Donald Macleod
link

Again, I can talk only about 2003-04, which was my final full year. We were planning to break even during that year. We would be in discussion with the Scottish Executive about our five-year plan and year-end position and we would highlight our financial position at meetings with a cohort of directors of finance. In 2003-04, the plan was for the board to break even but, in the end, we went 0.75 per cent over on a one-off, non-recurring basis.We were managing our finances to a degree at that point in time, while acknowledging that there were costs on the horizon. The situation was slightly different later. Although there was a significant deficit in 2005-06, there was not a significant deficit in the preceding years, although there was an underlying deficit trend—I take that on board, to a degree.There would be ring-fenced moneys. We were given an allocation for specific things that we were to do, and if that money was not spent, it could be used to help to offset. In my time, that would not have been significant. It was standard practice throughout the board that our internal control statements would have to identify that, although the board had broken even, the ring-fenced moneys of, for example £280,000, had assisted. However, that was true across the board.In my tenure there was also an opportunity to do a capital-to-revenue transfer or virement. We could vire 1 per cent. We used that facility, but it is now gone. So there have been some changes to the financial regime and the use of capital-to-revenue transfers.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

During your time, what kind of support did you ask for and get from the Scottish Executive to help the board manage its financial position?

Donald Macleod
link

We were in daily contact with the deputy director of finance of the NHS in Scotland. At that time, we had a financial adviser and support, and we submitted monthly monitoring returns to the Scottish Executive, which would come back and query the figures. There was an on-going monthly debate about the figures and the assumptions. There was dialogue about the assumptions, which it would test. On occasion, we invited Scottish Executive officials up to the Western Isles because we did not have ready access to them in Edinburgh as others based in Glasgow or at Little France in Lothian would have—they could just pop down to see officials. Officials would come up and we would discuss the financial situation once or twice a year, so there was dialogue back and forth.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

I seek clarification. You just mentioned that there were changes to how you could transfer money from the capital to the revenue account. When did those changes take place?

Donald Macleod
link

It was possibly around 2003-04. My understanding is that it happened when I was still director of finance so it could have been 2002-03, but I cannot say for certain. That facility is not available.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

Was it the same situation for the ring-fenced moneys that you mentioned?

Donald Macleod
link

The same applied to ring-fenced moneys. Boards are given a base allocation and we were given up to 75 allocations throughout the year for various streams. If we could not spend those moneys within the year, they would be ring-fenced and carried forward. I understand that that was still happening then.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Will you clarify something that you said earlier about the internal audit report giving a clean bill of health and not putting up any red flags? The figures in our committee papers suggest that at the end of financial year 2003-04, there was an in-year deficit—rather than a cumulative deficit—of £0.5 million. Should we take from that that the internal review did not red-flag that as an issue and that you therefore understood that the board's performance had a clean bill of health that year?

Donald Macleod
link

With such a deficit we could still have had a clean bill of health to a degree in that we had proper and adequate internal controls in place. The internal review looked at how we processed the payroll and creditors and how we implemented the FMS system—it commented on our internal controls. I am not aware of there having been any comment on the deficit at that point.The review commented that the board was at risk, but it did not look specifically at the deficit. It looked at how we reported the deficit as a finance function—whether we reported the deficit to the board and whether the board got the right information. For example, the review asked whether my financial report to the board in October 2004 specified what the likely outturn and the key costs were. If we reported that as a finance function, the review would comment on it and say that the reporting might be inadequate, but that was certainly not highlighted at that point.

Willie Coffey SNP Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Was there a perception in the board or from others that, because the report did not highlight the deficit as a red-flag issue, the level of financial performance was somehow acceptable?

Donald Macleod
link

No, it was not acceptable. However, with the GP out-of-hours contract coming online part way through the year, there was some uncertainty about our figures in 2004-05. In the scheme of things, the figures were up by perhaps 1.25 per cent or maybe not even that much—perhaps 1 per cent of our total allocation in a demand-led service. We identified that the main cost increases might be locum costs and GP provision; how the board would manage that in future—our five-year plan; and how the board was taking that cost pressure out of the equation over a five-year period. That would be the reason.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

The recent Audit Scotland report quotes two instances of accruals being incorrectly recorded. In your time, were any audit issues raised about the accrual process?

Donald Macleod
link

I am not aware of it. One of the accruals mentioned in the Audit Scotland report was a benefit to the board in that we were overstating. As regards prescribing in 2003-04, our information was always two months in arrears and therefore we always accrued two months into our annual accounts. That is my understanding. Obviously Audit Scotland has taken a different view on that or perhaps reporting has changed. At that point, however, we had to accrue two months' prescribing accruals into our figures. I notice in the report that information is now only one month in arrears, which is a benefit to the board.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

I want to be fair to all our witnesses, but time is pressing. There is time for two very quick questions.

Dr Alasdair Allan SNP Western Isles
link

I realise that we should not stray into issues about personnel. From a union perspective, did you think that the well-known difficult relationship between the leaders of the board at the time of its greatest troubles, around 2004, and its workforce made it more difficult for the board to cope with its financial situation and to operate efficiently? Did you raise those concerns with the leaders of the health board? Were they available, so that you could raise such concerns with them?

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Please keep your answer on a general level.

Ken Matthews Unison
link

I will, convener. Through partnership working and the usual reporting mechanisms, staff consistently raised a number of concerns about the breakdown of relationships and difficulties with budgets and service delivery. Mr Foulkes asked about the time that it took for action to be taken. There was serious concern on the staff side that it took so long for there to be intervention.

Claire Baker Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

My question follows on from the previous one. How do you view current staff involvement in the NHS board? To what extent have staff bought into the recovery process?

Ken Matthews Unison
link

At the time of the initial interim team, there was an agreement that a partnership finance working group would be pulled together. That would allow formal input to be made from the staff side into the mechanism. There have been difficulties in ensuring that the group meets regularly. I am aware from our representatives and other staff side representatives on the group that it took some time for them even to be given a copy of the recovery plan.Members report to me that, at service delivery level, they as budget holders have had difficulty obtaining accurate statements of their budgets. I am led to believe that in 2006-07 it took until nearly the third quarter of the budgetary year for budget holders to receive such statements. Clearly, that made it difficult for people to manage budgets effectively at service delivery level.

George Foulkes Lab Lothians
link

Can I confirm that Mr Matthews will provide us with a written submission, containing some confidential information, if necessary?

Ken Matthews Unison
link

I am happy to support the Audit Committee by providing that information.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

I bring this evidence-taking session to a close. I thank our witnesses, Mr Donald Macleod and Mr Ken Matthews.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

I welcome to the committee Mr John Turner, acting chief executive of NHS Western Isles, and Mr John Angus Mackay, chairman of NHS Western Isles. I invite John Angus Mackay to make an opening statement.

Mr John Angus Mackay Western Isles NHS Board
link

Madainn mhath agus fàilte gu na h-Eileanan an Iar. Good morning and welcome to the Western Isles. I am John Angus Mackay, chair of NHS Western Isles. I confirm that with me is John Turner, acting chief executive of the board. I have been chair since the beginning of February 2007; John joined us in September 2007.I thank members for inviting us to give evidence to the committee. Although we have been in post and working together for only a short time, we will do all that we can to support the committee in its inquiry. Western Isles NHS Board appreciates the time and trouble that you have taken to come here to conduct your inquiry.No doubt we will discuss the difficulties and challenges that the board is facing, but I must emphasise to the committee that NHS services are being delivered day in, day out to the people of the Western Isles by dedicated, professional, caring staff who work hard for patients and the public. That confirms what Malcolm Wright said earlier. It is still the case. Key clinical targets are being met and patient service improvements are happening. I believe that the board is fortunate in having such staff working for it.I am clear that the board has a lot of serious, hard work ahead of it fully to meet the legitimate expectations of us, and we take our responsibilities seriously. We are realistic and determined. Equally, there is an improving picture here, and we can describe to you sound progress and the building blocks that are being put in place. We are continuing and, where possible, accelerating the pace of the improvement that the support team commenced. We are clear about the challenges that we face, and it will take time to meet them to our satisfaction.In our discussion with the committee, we hope to demonstrate that progress is being made on key areas such as governance, leadership, management, performance management, clinical strategy development and financial recovery. The fact that our latest financial position is forecasting, albeit with tremendous caution, an in-year break-even position is a sign of the necessary progress that is being made on the road to recovery. It is essential that we continue to drive forward that improvement during the next financial year and I am determined that we will do that. Thank you for your interest in the process.

Andrew Welsh SNP The Temporary Convener · Angus
link

Tapadh leat. James Kelly will lead our questions.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

A number of sources have identified weaknesses in the areas of governance arrangements and systems of internal control. The previous two section 22 reports noted significant weaknesses in corporate governance and for a number of years the internal audit reports noted failings in internal controls. In addition, NHS Quality Improvement Scotland noted shortcomings in clinical governance and risk management. Why do such issues continue to arise? What steps have been taken to try to address them?

Mr Mackay
link

I will make an initial comment before I hand over to John Turner. I continued the process of improving governance that Ronnie Cleland and Malcolm Wright described earlier. However, I took the board back to basics and looked at the Nolan principles, on which governance should be based. I ensured that the board was clear about the distinctive roles that it has at executive and non-executive levels—that it has a stewardship role for the financial, human and material resources that it gets, and that the executive staff are responsible for deploying those resources effectively and efficiently.We got that clear and we established corporate objectives, albeit that it was May by the time we drafted the first lot and June before they were fully set up. We drafted those objectives because we became aware that we could not drive those principles and practices without having clarity at the top about the corporate objectives. We ensured that the systems were in place. We looked afresh at financial and operational systems to ensure that the objectives could be met.Mention was made of governance committees. We reviewed the terms of reference of all the governance committees to ensure that they are more in line with the corporate objectives. We continued the process that the support team established. We ensured that the governance committees met regularly. The endowment committee, which had not met for four years, has met regularly during the past year, and I think that the remuneration committee met about five times last year.In addition, we continued the process of board training and development that was described to you. For example, we held two workshops last year on remuneration issues—one in May and one in September. I could go on, but basically I am trying to say that we reviewed our governance arrangements and we built on the process and the progress that was made by the support team. We have revised all our key documentation, such as our mission statement and the financial recovery plan that you will come to, as well as the scheme of delegation, standing financial instructions, standing orders—the whole lot. In the course of the past year we have put a fair amount of time into ensuring that governance arrangements are tighter than they were at the beginning of last year.

Mr John Turner Western Isles NHS Board
link

In the short time that I have been here, since September, I have developed a picture in my head of an organisation that has continued to improve on the actions that were put in place by Mr Wright and Mr Cleland and the team, but which still has a long way to go.In looking at the internal control environment, I have examined, for example, the internal audit reports, which Mr Wright referred to having commissioned in his time here. In those internal reports, there are 29 priority 1 action points—I think that priority 1 is the same as red flag—and I have reassessed where the organisation is in relation to those points. In my assessment, 18 of the 29 have been actioned, eight are on-going, and on three there has not really been any progress. To my mind, that describes an organisation that is starting to address its internal control environment and is making progress, although there is clearly more to be done.With regard to the performance management systems that have been put in place, members are probably aware that the Scottish Government sets a number of health improvement, efficiency, access and treatment targets, on which each board has to deliver. There are 28 of those HEAT targets, for example on waiting times access. The executive team now reports regularly through the board on progress in relation to those targets. I am delighted to report, for example, that we met all the December 2007 access targets that we were required to meet.As members are aware, the organisation's corporate objectives are now in place. I also look at those objectives, and my assessment so far is that good progress is being made on them, although, clearly, as I am sure we will talk about in a few moments, there is much more to be done in the future.You mentioned the NHS Quality Improvement Scotland report that we received—we have in place an action plan that clearly describes all the requirements upon us in terms of moving forward, and where we are in relation to that. The action plan identifies a number of important things that we still need to take forward, but I have a sense that we are in a much improved environment with regard to reporting and control.

Mr Mackay
link

One further point on corporate governance is that in the course of last year we have established a corporate risk register, which brings together all the departmental risks. That register goes before the board, so the board is clear about what the situation is in a way that I do not think it was at the beginning of the year.

James Kelly Lab Glasgow Rutherglen
link

On a specific point in relation to risk, the Audit Scotland report identified the lack of a disaster recovery plan for the information technology systems, which are obviously crucial to internal controls. An action plan was drawn up and you were tasked with drafting a disaster recovery plan by January 2008. What progress has been made on that?

  1. Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Friday 11 January 2008 Committee business · 2
  2. Interests Procedure · 3
  3. Section 22 Report Evidence session · 380

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.