Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Budget Process 2002-03

Tuesday 13 March 2001 Finance Committee Committee business 19 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

19 contributions
Mike Watson Lab The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

We move swiftly on to item 6. The letter from the Minister for Finance and Local Government, in response to my letter on improving the annual expenditure report, relates to this item. The letter looks rather like a company's profits warning—not because it warns about profits, but because it suggests how the new annual expenditure report will look. I am not entirely happy with it.

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link

I think that the convener, on behalf of the committee, should ask the minister to detail how he deals with performance monitoring and how that is reviewed—even though he is building in a new system. The Executive makes decisions now. I presume that it uses some measures, otherwise it would blindly agree to votes in the budget. It would help if the minister explained what he does while we consider what he should do in the longer term.

Mike Watson Lab The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is a fair point.I realise that it will not be possible to achieve all that we have asked for in the coming year. However, I am interested in whether members share my concern that the linkage between expenditure and aims will take a few years to develop fully. That is not quite what the committee had in mind when we drew the issue to the minister's attention.

Andrew Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I agree. The link should be made as soon as humanly possible. I thought that it was part of the Government's programme. It would be fine if we made that point as strongly as possible through you, convener.Secondary to that are the other issues that we have raised consistently in the past two years. I guess from the letter that we can assume that those requests will all be accommodated, which would be a huge step in the right direction.

Mike Watson Lab The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

We can assume that in as much as the issues are not mentioned as exceptions.

Andrew Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Exactly. We can recognise that as a step forward, which is at least progress. I guess that we can keep up the pressure.

Mike Watson Lab The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

We accept that considerable progress will take place. However, I will write on behalf of the committee to say that we need further clarification at the least about the import of some of the issues that are mentioned in the letter.

Andrew Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

May I seek clarification from Callum Thomson on another question? The letter says that the annual expenditure report is due to be published on 30 March. What are the committee's or the chamber's activities around that date likely to be?

Mike Watson Lab The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

The committee meets on 27 March. I do not think that we are scheduled to meet in the following week.

Callum Thomson Clerk
link

We are now. In addition, I hope that Scottish Executive officials will give a briefing on the AER. That will be not a formal committee meeting, but an informal chance for members to tease out some of the issues.

Andrew Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

So we will meet in April and there will be no plenary debate on the AER until we report on it.

Callum Thomson Clerk
link

Exactly. That will not happen until just before the summer recess starts.

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link

The debate raises the issue of the written agreement between us and the previous Minister for Finance. I presume that we ought to clarify that by mutually agreeing a time scale with the minister on the implementation of what we seek.

Mike Watson Lab The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

I agree. However, we must not forget that our written agreements are not with the minister, but with the Scottish Executive—the correct way of describing it is with ministers as a whole. The agreements should not change or be open to a differing interpretation just because a new minister is in place.

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link

I accept that, but in light of the letter, the Parliament is entitled to ask for a time scale to debate with the minister acting on behalf of the Executive.

Mike Watson Lab The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

Would that be a time scale for the full implementation of our recommendations?

Mike Watson Lab The Convener · Glasgow Cathcart
link

We will take up that point in the letter. When we receive a response, we will revisit the issue.We move on to agenda item 7, which we have agreed to take in private.

Meeting continued in private until 12:15.

  1. Scottish Parliament Finance Committee Tuesday 13 March 2001 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Proposed Contingent Liabilities Committee business · 76
  3. Convention Rights (Compliance) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 5
  4. Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (Expenditure Plan) Committee business · 12
  5. Audit Scotland (Expenditure Plan) Committee business · 3
  6. Budget Process 2002-03 Committee business · 19

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.