The last item on our agenda is our work programme for next year. Members will have received a copy of the proposals. The suggestion is that we move to fortnightly meetings. The only point that I want to make relates to the week after the spring recess, for which no meeting is scheduled. If we do not meet that week, we will not meet for more than a month. Given that we will not have met in the week immediately prior to the recess, I do not understand why a meeting is not scheduled for the first week after the recess.
Official Report · Committee
Forward Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Mike Watson only · show everyone- Mike Watson Lab 10
- Keith Raffan LD 5
- Andrew Wilson SNP 4
- Callum Thomson 1
- Elaine Thomson Lab 1
- David Davidson Con 1
Mike Watson’s contributions
10 contributionsI understand that, but I am not happy about it. Perhaps I have misread the paper—I said that we would not have met in the week prior to the recess.
That will be the pattern in future. The conveners group has discussed moving to a pattern of fortnightly meetings. That pattern will not be absolutely firm, but the committee office will schedule a programme of meetings that fits in with it. That does not mean that we cannot meet between scheduled meetings. If committees need to fill in the gaps to deal with legislation or other matters, they are at liberty to do so—subject to accommodation being available.
That is a fair point. The conveners came up with the idea of fortnightly meetings. I am not aware of the Parliamentary Bureau having been involved, or even of its having a view on the proposal. I do not imagine that the bureau would be greatly concerned either way. The conveners reached their decision on the basis of their experience of how committees have operated in the first year and a half of Parliament.
For those who are not aware of it, Keith Raffan is referring to what will shortly become the social justice committee—the deputy convener of the Social Inclusion, Housing and the Voluntary Sector Committee made that very point at the conveners group meeting. She did not feel that the social justice committee could get by on fortnightly meetings. My experience would endorse that view.The programme is mapped out, and committees will fill the gaps as they deem necessary.
That is a reasonable proviso, and my understanding of the situation is the same. As convener, I would not want it any other way. I do not think that anything else is intended. We will accept the work plan—which will stand for the first three months of next year—for the moment but, at a meeting early in the new year, we will consider whether we wish to get involved in any other issues.
Speaking absolutely personally, I share that view, particularly in view of the fact that members will generally now be on one committee rather than two, following committee restructuring.I think that we will meet once a week. The point that I was making—without stating it explicitly—was that we will fill the gaps; the gaps in the programme will not always remain gaps and we have the flexibility to fill them. Our report on the budget process will indeed come up for further consideration.
If Andrew Wilson is asking whether we should commit ourselves now to the dates on the programme, I would say no. We will fill many of the gaps, but our main programme will be based on a fortnightly cycle.
I do not think that we have a deadline, but Keith Raffan is right to identify that that is effectively a self-imposed deadline. We could consider that and get a report on the matter at our first January meeting, which would therefore put it on the agenda for 16 January.There is one more matter that I want to raise. The committee is required to approve the reimbursement of travel expenses for witnesses who attend our meetings. I am sure that nobody will disagree with that. When Professor David Heald travelled from Aberdeen to give evidence to one of our reporter groups last month, costs were incurred. I ask for the committee's formal approval that we reimburse Professor Heald for his costs.Members indicated agreement.
There is nothing else on the agenda, but I wish to do two things before closing the meeting. First—I do this perhaps a little prematurely but, the way things work out, I am probably not too far out of line—I thank those committee members for whom this will almost certainly be the last Finance Committee meeting. I do not think that I am out of line in mentioning that Rhoda Grant, Ken Macintosh, Keith Raffan and George Lyon—George is not here today—are moving on to other committees. I thank them for their contribution during the past year and a half. It has been an important 18-month period, which has been informative, not only for this committee, but for the development of the Parliament's budget process. Everybody has played a part in that and, although we are by no means at the end of the process, we can be proud of the way in which the committee has operated and shaped that process. I thank all members for their contributions, and I wish them good luck and success in their new challenges.Finally, I wish all members, the clerks, the official report staff and the sound engineers a merry Christmas and best wishes for a prosperous 2001.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Dec 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Finance Committee Tuesday 19 December 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Education (Graduate Endowment and Student Support) (Scotland) (No 2) Bill Bill debate · 35
- External Research Committee business · 8
- Budget Process Committee business · 43
- Forward Work Programme Procedure · 23
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.